Hey chicken, I got hold of a pdf of scott cunningham " earth power" and "earth air fire and water " and something that confuses me in some spells is the method used relating to the goal. For example:
In one to help break bad habits, it says to write this bad habit in a a leaf, take it to a tree and bury close to the roots. Then put an offering for the tree in the same hole, cover it up and pour some water on the spot
But couldn't this action of burying and watering, be seen as "planting" the bad habit? And if you are planting it would grow...
Another one is for love/relationship, where with a burned stick you draw two hearts interwined in a piece of paper, visualizing a satisfying relationship and then put some rose petals in the paper, fold it and burn it in a candle or fire.
He describes that as it burns the power is released
But it makes me think that burning your wish in the paper would have an opposite effect, like destroying the wish
Idk. What do you thinks of those "mechanics" of spells? Am I overthinking?
Hi! I've never read those books and I'm not a Wiccan.
So I can only comment from my own perspective, which may be the incorrect perspective to accurately interpret what Cunningham is saying.
You are not over-thinking; you have stumbled onto a very important aspect of sorcery and one that is good to think about.
How is it that sometimes, a box is used to trap and bind energies, but at other times a box can be used to coalesce and radiate helpful energies?
How is it that a candle can both open portals and close portals? How can a candle both be banishing of spirits, and an offering to spirits?
How can burying something in the earth not only be destructive or even an aspect of curses, but also be a technique of prosperity and growth?
The reality is that burying something isn't magic and it doesn't do anything. Lighting a candle isn't magic and doesn't do anything.
"Doing magic" is not taking a leaf and writing things on it and burying it. A mundane person can do these things in a mundane way and no magic will occur.
Nothing is automatically happening; burying something neither automatically causes an act of banishing, nor an act of conjuring.
As the practitioner, it is you yourself who determines what happens. This is the vital and inexorable power of 'setting intent.'
The tree does not decide what happens to your habits leaf. The earth does not decide what happens to your habits leaf. YOU decide what happens to it.
No, it isn't strictly true that burying things is always an action of generative planting. A very popular form of cursing is to turn an apple into someone and then bury them to rot. But the Earth can also gently break things down through the cycle of decay. Or it can trap things, like a cave-in.
We see all of these things occurring in nature; of course you can plant seeds to grow strong. Of course if you bury a body it will rot. Of course leafs slowly decay and their particles return to nature.
All of these things are valid.
YOU decide which one happens. This decision is germinated with intent; it is gestated with technique. YOU are the creator god. The leaf is clay in your hands, and you can decide:
You are the body of the beloved that broke my heart, as this leaf decays their joy will decay.
You are the mustard seed that returns a hundredfold harvest, mightest among trees.
You are the leaf of the forest floor, breaking down and returning to nature, just as my bad habits break down and return to source.
It is not a leaf. It is not planting. It is a spell. You create the reality of what the leaf really is, and you dictate how it must try to interact with its environment.
It must be good with you, or it is not a good spell*.
So if you personally cannot get around the idea that burying something will always be an action of generative "planting," then you shouldn't do the spell like that!
It's not an issue of "wrong belief." You may be following valid intuition. You may be at a time in your practice where the Earth calls you to plant things to grow. You may be at a time in your practice where fire whispers sweet promises of destruction to you.
Explore what's around you and what you're feeling! Change the methods if you don't think they're right for you.
But it is also untrue to say that putting things into the earth is always an act of planting. It can be many things.
*This is not true but this is a post, not a book.