#raview

Just imagine either as a dude  

Caitlyn and Vi oh-so-subtle lesbian romance subplot is the weakest part of the series. If you don’t see it that way, you would have, if they were a heterosexual pair.

I didn’t read into LoL lore to check how close they are. From the barebones I get, female commissioner Gordon hired a female Batman. If Arcane took this angle and showed them respecting one another due to their differences mutually complementing them, it would be much better. If they want to develop them into a pair, that’s a material for Season 2. If they wanted to tease it more explicitly, they could have Jinx talking about knowing her sister’s tastes.

The series does establish why Vi and Cait get along better, with Vi proving herself useful to Cait’s investigation, and Cait saving Vi’s life, and then Vi saving Cait. That’s a solid foundation for bonds of friendship, upon which you can build your lesbian romance. You don’t skip straight to romance, especially when you establish neither as being into girls until their meeting. Before meeting Vi, Caitlin was romancing with Jayce. As for Vi, she was too preoccupied with her sister and getting street creed to swing either way. But sudden lesbians find out they are into each other, but things don’t work so well, and they must split. The tragedy of oil and water! Give me a break with this rushed forced nonsense.

This romance is detrimental to characters, not just Vi and Cait, but also Jinx. But let’s first focus on the pair, by demonstrating why they suck. And we can do that by imagining either as a dude.

So, Caitlyn and Vittan. The naïve proper lady policewoman, and male cynical former leader of a teenage gang, in search of his unwillingly abandoned younger sister. Caitlyn was previously romanced by Jayce, but she didn’t like a man of science and success that tried to be overly protective of her, so she found somebody who is more rough on her. He screws with her, tricks her into pretending to be a prostitute, but at least helps her to advance with her investigation. He gets stupidly injured and keeps important secrets from her, but she saves his life. Then he saves her from his sister, but remains an impulsive man that prefers to do own thing, because using Cait’s mother’s connections didn’t work. Though he still used what he has learned from her, to talk her friend Jayce into helping him out with his vendetta against Silco, behind her back. Vittan is quite an asshole, but Cait is set up to choose him over Jayce.

So, Caito and Vi. The naïve proper gentle policeman, and female cynical former leader of a teenage gang, in search of her unwillingly abandoned younger sister. Vi is driven by her guilt and knows that her sister does awful things now, but prefers to believe she does it for the sake of self-survival. She initially can’t stand Caito, so she tries to mess with him, and then finally gets rid of him. She does it in the simplest way possible, by leaving the horny man with a prostitute. Sure, Caito ends up saving her when she messes up on her own. But that blockhead not only withholds that his true aim is a stolen technology, but also ruins her reunion with her sister. Vi thinks she still has to find her sister that is under bad influence, but chooses to save Caito instead. Caito drags her to a place that turns out to be his bedroom, because for some suspicious reason he didn’t want to use main doors. Supposedly, Caito has in the council a friend with the opposite gender. And between said friend, the prostitute from the club, and Vi, Caito sure likes jumping the flower. When Vi decides to stop working with Caito, he suddenly asks “what about us?”, really quickly escalating the relationship between them. That dude sure is stupid and lustful. And maybe it’s still wrong to kill him on Jinx’s request, but somehow Vi acts all heartbroken over it and is meant to eat up his dull advances.

Lesbians in media. Isn’t it insulting for women, to write them as shut-ins that rebel against their parents and escape from them, after stealing everything valuable they have, over a piece of juvenile punk-star genitalia? Apparently not, if said piece of genitalia is a vagina – Gone Home got critically acclaimed this way. Go figure.

Anyway, the badness of this romance is also detrimental to Jinx’s character, so let’s move onto that…

Lost focus on how the monster was created

Jinx can hate Caitlyn and be hallucinating things about her, but that whole jealously over a girlfriend (or even a boyfriend, if that was the case) is distracting the viewer from the core of Arcane’s main tragedy – Jinx is Vi’s creation, Silco only accelerated what Vi had put into Powder.

And it’s a great tragedy. Powder is a result of outside influence (looking at the crows and reading into the lore, there is possibly an even more dreadful influence over her), same as Vi. They both share a tragic past and live in a harsh world. Even when Vander helped them, both with preparing them to face their harsh reality, and also ensuring some peaceful order in it.

But Vi was driven by her anger towards Piltover and its enforcers. Again, perfectly understandable, they were responsible for the situation in undercity and death of her parents. This is why Vi wanted renown and street creed. This is why she had her fuck the police attitude. This is why she was willing to rob a man that has done nothing wrong to them (and actually was nice to her little friend), just because he was from the upper city. And Vi put all that into Powder, made her idolize her being eager to prove herself (robbing Piltover without consulting Vander) and rebelliously independent (withholding stolen crystals from him). She encouraged her to her learn shooting at people. She approved of her learning to make bombs. All so Powder would make her happy by demonstrating her usefulness to her cause against Piltover.

Jinx is made out of all of those things. As a kid, Powder knew no right no wrong, but what she has picked up from her sister. And Vi’s first act character arc was learning to realize that actions have consequences, that picking a fight with Piltover will result in confrontation, which very possibly will result in Powder losing her life. Vi has learned her lesson, which is why she decided to sacrifice herself to Piltover. But things happened, Vander needed saving, Vi had no time explain her newfound worries to Powder, and then everything went downhill. Silco picked up Powder and encouraged her towards the exact same direction Vi had, just without any restraint.

Really, nails grenade. Powder always was desperate to prove her worth, even if by killing somebody. Vi was both stuck in the past and blind about past signs of Jinx forming herself.

And that could be the focus of Jinx’s obsession over Caitlyn. She was literally an enforcer of Piltover’s will, her and her sister’s natural enemy. And she intended to prevent Jinx from giving the lower city an edge over the upper city. And Vi was helping her now? Sure, anything useful to reunite with her sister. If that’s the case, Vi shouldn’t have a problem with killing the stupid enforcer woman, once she outlives her usefulness. Oh, Vi is hesitant, because the enforcer has saved her life? Suddenly not into wronging any upper city twit? Suddenly it matters when they are alright? What has changed, since we had robbed her nice to us boyfriend and blew up his apartment? Why don’t you love me when I only follow your example, Vi? Why did you want me to learn how to shoot at people and blow them up, Vi!? Did you tell her the things you were happy with me doing as a kid?! Hey, my sister’s girlfriend! Tell me – did I go insane, or was she the insane one in the first place!?!

The final song of the series begins with the words “I am the monster you created”. This is the intended core of Arcane’s beautiful tragedy between Vi and Jinx – the supposed heroic sister is responsible for her villainous sister, nobody else. Vi has failed Powder, and was constantly failing her since the beginning. Now only Jinx remains, Vi’s creation.

Nonetheless, Arcane has still done a groundbreaking job with Jinx. The show has picked up a Harley Quinn knockout, le crazy wacky girl, and has done tremendous job with turning her into something better. There is no shame anymore in Jinx being based on another character, like there never was any shame in Batman being based on Zorro. Jinx is now her own tragic figure – an unfortunate confused girl that has been corrupted by wrongs of her world, turned into a living reckoning against it. She has outgrown the wacky psychiatrist that ended up being manipulated by the Joker.