replies about original writing
msilverstar replied to your post āastroloquacious replied to your post āreplies and asks and suchā ...ā
Maybe it's your unpublished first novel and you should move on to the next?
I have moved on, many times, and have circled back around to it because it is a story I want to tell and care about deeply. I think thereās a story in it I ought to tell, but I am also aware that Iām fairly mired in it-- however, the only reason itās being discussed at all is that I picked it up briefly because I spent a year slogging through a Brand New Idea that also bogged down into bullshit after I wrote about 3/4 of a draft and it failed to develop a plot.
So methinks itās not that particular novel thatās the problem, somehow.
mikkeneko replied to your post āastroloquacious replied to your post āreplies and asks and suchā ...ā
I'm sure you've heard this one before, but: perhaps printing out your draft, the whole ass draft, and then typing it up again would let you sift out the good stuff
Mm I tried that. The waste of paper horrified me, so I used side-by-side computer windows and transcribed it entirelyĀ in the 600,000-word process I described earlier. What happens with that is that I often think āoh I could go this other completely different direction here insteadā and then I have two completely incompatible storylines going, and you can repeat that infinitely and itās super easy to get a million words of which there is not one coherent chunk for you to work on. So thatās super not an approach thatās useful for me, but I know it works for other people and Iām not knocking its validity-- I just know, Iāve tried it, a bunch, thatās great for a really thorough final polish but utterly disastrous for a good way to winnow through a lot of ideas and pick just one.
astroloquacious replied to your post āastroloquacious replied to your post āreplies and asks and suchā ...ā
WOW, that's a lot! I rescind that particular bit of advice, then, ha ha. Would you say that the issue is more a lack of feedback, then? You mention feeling like it needs editing-- do you mean structural editing? Is it an issue of not feeling like the plot & characters are solid?
Itās that I have too many ideas, chase down more and more of them, and wind up with a huge fractured mass of story, mostly worldbuilding, with endless iterations of new reworkings of the old ideas, and they are measurably better with each iteration! but I canāt actually support a plot on them, theyāre too fragmented.
My problem is largely that for most of my life I havenāt had anyone willing to read my writing, and itās only made worse by my horrid rejection-sensitive dysphoria that means that if someone says a thing I wrote isnāt exactly perfect as-is then I have to lie on the floor in despair. Iām hoping Iām a bit more robust now as like a whole-ass adult but thatās debatable. In my real life, people think itās funny that I think I can write a novel, and are super not interested in reading it, and thatās all Iāve had.
pantsy-fancy replied to your postĀ āastroloquacious replied to your post Ā āreplies and asks and suchā Ā ...ā
Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā If if would help your original novel progress to have an AO3 comment squad for cheerleading & encouragement as you write chapters, then sign me up!!! You are one of my favourite writers and I would love to read anything you're working on. (Apologies if this is out of place--I realize I'm jumping into the middle of a conversation here) Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā
Oh, youāre not out of place at all. Someone else (@s_leary? maybe?) suggested I put this original work up locked on AO3, and I was under the impression that original works were prohibited on AO3, but now that one mentions it I guess they changed that. Itās not impossible! I just... donāt use AO3 as a place for concrit, so Iām not used to attempting that, but I guess Iāve had some good comment discussions there. But thatās why I was trying to post the mammoths thing on Dreamwidth back in 2019 (you know, before the earthās crust had cooled, back in that epoch, so long ago), but so few people use DW it was rather difficult to really get any discussion going.
I could try AO3, I suppose!