Iâve had a few different pride flags cross my radar over the last couple of weeks. I think itâs important, in a flourishing community with a resulting growth of flags and pride colour schemes to represent us, to have a conversation about representation and design.
A-Spec Versus Aro-Ace Pride Flags
If youâre making a specific a-spec pride flag, I ask that you consider designing it in such a way that it is somewhat distinct from aro-ace pride. Most of the flags for both combine both the ace and aro flags together in various ways, which is reasonable enough given that ace and aro folks are part of both identities, but it results in neither flag looking distinct from the other. Iâve seen multiple flags that combine aro and ace pride colour sets together, leaving some stripes out or adding another purple stripe, and while some are aro-ace and some are a-spec, they all blur together to me. I canât tell the difference, and I doubt I am the only one with this inability.
Aro-ace is not an umbrella term for the a-spec community. Itâs its own identity and needs its own pride. Aro-aces should have their own pride design to distinguish themselves and their experiences from other ways of being a-spec, while allo-aros and allo-aces shouldnât be forced to find their a-spec pride under something that looks more like aro-ace representation. As aro-aces rightly have a history of combining the ace and aro flags together for their pride, I think a specific a-spec flag should shift away from this combining of two flags to something new that speaks of both but represents a-specs as a whole.
Thereâs many ways one could make both flags different, even with using the same colour schemes but changing order or arrangement, or adding other simple designs across a striped field. What about vertical stripes for one and horizontal for the other? Or colour bars taken from ace-spec and aro-spec identity pride flags, together with purple and green, to celebrate and centre the a-spectrum? Or an a-spec flag thatâs half green and half purple for the aro and ace spectra, but with a single narrow black stripe (black for unity?) in the centre?
Itâs important to have both ace and aro colours represented in a specific a-spec pride flag, but I think it is also important that aro-ace be seen as distinct from a-spec in the minds of flag designers and the community promoting, discussing and using these flags.
Design Authority and #Ownvoices
People not of one identity should not be making flags/pride colour sets for that identity unless they have been commissioned to do so by someone of the identity and have had feedback and consultation from someone (preferably more than one person) of the identity.
This happens quite a bit in broader LGBTQIA+ spaces, so I absolutely understand it not seeming like a problem here. Itâs common for people to realise that a flag is missing and then make a flag to fill the gap or complete a set while not being of the identity in question, which is then collated by the many pride-flag collecting blogs and reblogged to the community. I do not see malicious intent in this; I absolutely understand that best intentions are meant. But I also donât think that this stepping-in serves the best interests of the community the designer intends to represent. Colours and designs are often chosen without any consultation from the people for which this flag is intended.
Pride colours come to be a visual shorthand for our identities, and on a visually-heavy platform like Tumblr, they often result in a lot of creative media. If that pride set takes off, especially if other bloggers give it attention and promotion or the designer is well-known, we suddenly have a flourishing of art representing a certain identity, used by people not of the identity in making pride art sets ... and that identity having had no say in the colours and designs now representing them.
Itâs even worse when the designer assigns symbolism to the colours: Iâve seen a few flags created by folk not of the identity where the symbolism offered is designed to match relating flags but says nothing distinct about the experience of the identity (my identity) in question. This is why itâs so important that people of the identity are determining their own colours and symbolism, because most of the time, the outsider designer wonât know whatâs desired or important in the symbolism. I donât feel connected to these flags; theyâre not made with my lived experience in mind and it so often shows.
If youâre a designer and you see an identity that isnât yours in need of a flag or pride colours, approach someone of the identity and ask if theyâd like you to help. You must be willing to take on their advice on colour, design and symbolism, but if youâre working with the people for whom the flag is meant, this is fine and awesome. Donât step in and just decide on a flag yourself.
Speaking for the people lacking pride colours isnât what pride flag design should be about. Helping people lacking pride colours to speak for themselves by providing software, file formats and design skills should be the role of a designer. If we value the importance of #ownvoices representation, it should start with pride colours. Promoting designs made by someone of or commissioned by someone of the identity in question is vital to keep in mind in a world where flag variants and alternate flags are becoming increasingly popular.
Thereâs only a few allo-aro pride art pieces on this blog, compared to multiple and regular aro-ace pride art pieces. Unlike aro-ace, which has a visual shorthand in various ways of combining asexual and aromantic pride colours, allo-aro has nothing as a whole. Sometimes the aro flag is combined with allosexual pride flags, but that still doesnât group allo-aros together in the sense of having shared experiences both within the aro-spec community and outside it. Pride colours give us an immediate visual representation, easily reproduced, and for this reason they are an important step in recognition and validation.
Since much of my reblogged content is visual art based around pride colours, I can see the creation of an allo-aro pride theme/flag helping to fill that lack. Iâd really like allo-aros to get together and discuss pride colour/flag options and symbolism so that I can feature more visual representation for us on this blog. I want to be clear that I see it as more as an addition to our pride; I donât mean it to replace our aromantic pride colours or our sexual orientation pride colours. (And Iâd love to see more pride art posts that combine allosexual orientation identities with aro-spec identities!) Just as many aro-aces use the ace, aro and combined flag variants depending on situation, we can and should use our sexual orientation, aro-spec and allo-aro flags as suits us.
I see an allo-aro flag as an additional shorthand to give us a sense of connection and community, particularly in the sense of a currently-lacked visual presence in aro-spec and a-spec spaces. Without something to represent us, itâs harder for us to be seen, and my hope is that a flag can and will change that.
Iâll be honest: I want an allo-aro flag that veers away from current a-spec flag approaches to colour, design and symbolism/meaning. My thinking is that we need a flag with colour stripes relating to sexual attraction in addition to our aromanticism, as our experiences of allosexual attraction as shaped by our aromanticism is so often an afterthought in a-spec spaces. Itâs worth considering that we already have the aro flag representing our aromanticism, often with references to things like friendship and platonic/queerplatonic attraction in the colour stripes. The allo-aro flag shouldnât, in my opinion, reproduce what already exists. It should represent the allo-aro experience, specifically focusing on those things that arenât covered by current aromantic pride interpretations and meanings--and for me, thatâs the intersection of allosexual attraction and aromanticism.
The flag idea I have in mind has a pink stripe for attraction to femininity, a blue stripe for attraction to masculinity, a white stripe for attraction to gender and genderless identities unaligned to the binary, and a yellow stripe for attraction irrespective of gender, with narrower aro-pride-green stripes placed above and between these four coloured stripes. My thinking is that the sexual attraction stripes with green aro stripes interspersed between them will show that our aromanticism is the thing that connects our diverse experiences of allosexual attraction. I suspect using pastel variations of those colours would be easiest on the eyes and I have no knowledge of colour theory and what hues go comfortably together. This idea is based more on colour symbolism than colour theory, so I suspect it may not work that well in practice.
This is only a suggestion and Iâd love to see what other allo-aros come up with. Iâm posting this as an example for how Iâd like to see a flag that isnât similar in meaning and design to pre-existing flags, but Iâd gladly toss it for any better ideas!
My feeling is, though, that an allo-aro pride flag will fill a gap in the visual media on this blog, and Iâd love to kick-start a discussion on making, together, the pride colours that represent us.