His House (2)
Summary: You are in trouble and need fast cash. For the longest time you tried to be a good girl, now you need to break the rules all over again.
Pairing: Mobster!Dean Winchester x Thief!Reader
Characters: Jimmy “Cas” Novak, Sam Winchester, Crowley, Carson Brady
Warnings: angst, language, breaking and entering, criminal reader, mafia au, implied sexual harassment (not Dean), threats, scared reader, kind of hostage situation, there is a tiny hint of fluff, mentions of characters death/murder/crimes
Words: 2,1 k
Divider by @firefly-graphics
<< Part 1
Wrong House masterlist
“Sit over there, and don’t talk,” you nod silently as Dean points at the chair next to his. He brought you to a large room with a large table and twelve chairs around the table. “I don’t want to explain the rules again.”
He smirks darkly as you dare not to meet his gaze. Dean Winchester has this effect on people. If he enters a room, all eyes are on him before they drop their gaze and wait for him to take the lead.
“You will only talk if I ask you a question,” he lifts your chin with his index finger to search your face. “Do you understand?”
“Yes,” it’s a whimpered plea, nothing else. Gone is the self-confident woman. She got replaced by a scared little bunny standing in front of the big bad wolf named Dean Winchester, “I understand the rules.”
“Good girl,” his praises leave a bad taste in your mouth. You don’t want the mafia boss to call you a good girl or be proud of you. All you want is to get your life back and hide under the biggest rock and never come out again. “Now sit down, and just look pretty.”
He doesn’t wait for you to sit down before he leaves the room. At least you get a few moments on your own now to sort your thoughts and forget your life doesn’t belong to you anymore.
“Oh, hello there,” a man you didn’t meet so far steps inside the room, stealing the silent moments you longed for. “Dean outdid himself with the entertainment today, huh? What are you going to do for me, baby?” He purrs and you stumble back as he tries to cup your face.
“Hands off, Brady,” Dean grunts as the blonde tries to touch your cheek. “She’s not here for your entertainment. Wait for the girls at Ellen’s club tonight. If you need to get your dick wet, look for someone else. That one is my secretary, and no one touches what’s mine.”
It’s a relief that Dean at least doesn’t force you to entertain his guests, or rather business partners. Your life is not yours any longer, but you want to decide who touches you.
“Sit over there,” he grabs your arm to guide you toward the chair next to his. “If anyone ever tries to touch you against your will again, you say my name. You will tell them that you are mine. Got it.” Dean looks down at you. There is something in his eyes that you didn’t see before. His features soften and you almost believe he can be a good man if he only wants to. “Got it, Y/N?”
“I got it,” you weakly reply. What else can you do? Dean Winchester, the leader of his own syndicate towers over you, making you shrink in yourself.
“Say it,” he leans closer to bump his nose against yours. He breathes against you, searching your eyes as you try to find your voice. “I want to hear it, sweetheart.”
“I’ll tell them that I’m yours,” Dean smirks now. His eyes drop to your chest, and he hums as you breathe heavily close to him. “Why would you want to protect me?”
“You’ll always be safe as long as you know that you belong with me now,” he boobs your nose with his index finger. There is playfulness in his demeanor as he looks you all over as if he’s afraid the other man touched a hair on your head. “I only keep you safe as you are a talented little thief. I want you to clamp your mouth shut and just sit next to me. Maybe you can take some notes.”
“Notes?” you glance up at Dean. “I’m not some secretary.”
“You are everything I want you to be, sweetheart,” damn, you dared to huff at his words. He smirks, amused that you flinch as he cups your chin roughly. “I’m going to turn you into my loyal little thief. I love bending people to my will.”
“I bet you do,” fuck, sometimes you just can’t stop yourself from running your mouth. “I’ll just sit down now and take some notes, Sir.” You offer to not eat a bullet too soon.
“Sir now, huh?” that fucker smiles wildly as you struggle to keep a straight face. You’d like to tell him all the things swirling in your mind or call him a jerk. Of course, no one is stupid enough to call a man like Dean Winchester a jerk.
“Dean, can we begin,” Dean looks down at you, still that stupid smirk on his face as his brother tries to get his attention. “DEAN! Did you even listen?”
“What?” the mobster snaps his head toward his brother to give Sam a bitch face. “I was in the middle of something here.”
“Yeah, I can see that. Stop flirting with your newest toy. We’ve got a conference in five,” Sam sighs as Dean sits on the table to run his index finger up and down your arm. “Dean, can you focus on business now.”
“She’s business too,” your captor chuckles as you cross your arms over your chest. You don’t hide you’d like to run out of the room and try to get away from Dean Winchester. “Our little thief will be useful.”
“How?” Sam presses on. “She’s only a pretty face. I don’t think—” sighing deeply at his big brother’s antics Sam sits on his chair, the one to Dean’s right. “Fine, have it your way.”
“Did you not read her file?” Dean leans closer to get a good look at the necklace you are wearing. “She was one of the best cat burglars not so long ago. I bet her big brother taught her everything, just like I did with you.”
“He should’ve kept her out of this business,” Sam sneers as you glance at him. He doesn’t seem to be too fond of you, or your presence in this room. “That girl doesn’t belong here, Dean.”
“Sammy, thanks to her we got rid of Cole Trenton. That little thief will be useful and a great addition to our gang,” Dean chuckles as you frown. “What? Don’t you want to be part of my gang?”
“I’ve got no choice,” you mumble as the room fills with more men. All eyes are on you and Dean when he hops off the table to pat your head. “Hey, I’m not some dog you can pet.”
“I told you before,” his hand wraps around your throat and you gasp as he looks down on you, his face cold and stoic now, “you are what I want you to be. If I say you are a dog, you are.”
The meeting dragged on. Dean, Sam, and the men you don’t know talked about business, money, weapons, and their latest conquests.
“Why again do you want me to listen to this?” you whisper as Dean nods at something a blue-eyed man in a trench coat said. You think he called him Cas, but you are not sure.
“Why is the girl here?” a smaller guy, with dark hair and an accent asks. “What?” the man cocks his head as Dean gives him a dirty look. “Why did no one ask before? I mean, she’s a cute little thing, but I prefer doing business without having a pretty dame around.”
“She’s my secretary,” Dean dips his head to look at you. He furrows his brows, daring you to say something stupid again. “You made notes for me, didn’t you?”
“Mental notes,” Sam rolls his eyes at your reply. “I forgot my notebook, Sir. I’m sorry.”
“Darling, you are much too forgetful for a secretary. Shouldn’t you help Dean and not make his life harder?” the man sneers now. “Dean, what is she really doing here?”
“Y/N is not your problem, Crowley,” you flinch at Dean’s harsh tone. He jumped up and slammed his hands onto the table to get everyone’s attention. “I bring whoever I want to with me. She’s here to learn.”
“Learn to spy on us?” the man responds. He looks at you again, making you feel unease as his eyes darken. “Winchester, I want answers.”
“She’s new and I’m showing her the ropes. Y/N belongs with me,” Dean cocks his head to look directly at Crowley. “Do we have a problem here?”
“No,” you furrow your brows as the man arguing not moments ago shrink into himself. Dean seems to be an even more dangerous man than you thought. If all these men in the room fear him, what can you do to escape him?
“How did you end up becoming a thief?” Dean places a plate with food and a beer in front of you. “Sweetheart, I expect you to answer my questions.” He hands you a fork. “Now.”
“After my mom died, dad lost his job,” you poke the food with the fork. “He—well.” You sigh deeply, shaking your head. “He had to take care of two kids. I was two, and my brother was barely six. Dad borrowed money from the wrong guy and…”
“He had to pay his debts somehow,” the mobster asks, and you nod silently. Dean watches you like a hawk, wanting to find out if everything he found out about your past was the truth. “How?”
“One day my dad was a caring father, and the next he become the hitter for some mafia boss. My father was a strong and tall man. He did the dirty work for more and more gangsters. It was only natural that my brother and I ended up in the same business,” you wipe your eyes. “It was a one-way ticket to hell, though.”
“Your father got shot. A shame. He was a good man,” Dean places a manila folder onto the table. He opens the folder to place pictures of the man killing your father in front of you. “His killer.”
Your eyes widen and you swallow thickly as you look at the pictures again. “No one knows who killed my father and brother…no one.”
“No one wanted to know,” he places another picture on top of the other, showing the very same man, just a little more dead. “Well, no one but me. You know, I like knowing what’s going on in my territory. Your father was a damn good hitter, and your brother had very talented hands.”
“What? I-I don’t understand,” you grasp Dean’s hand. He doesn’t fight you when you harshly tug at it. “What does this mean?”
“Your father used to work for my father,” the mobster casually says. “John Winchester, does this name ring a bell?”
“Dad never told us about the people he was working for. One of many rules. No asking questions. No talking about his clients.”
“Well, my father appreciated your father’s work, I did too. One day, that bastard Styne dared to put an end to your daddy’s life,” he shrugs as you look up at him with wide eyes. “No one kills people working for me, sweetheart.”
“What about my brother? Did he work for you too?” you sniffle, wiping your eyes. “Did they die because of your kind of business?”
“You should learn to not push boundaries all the time. Your father and brother died as your daddy got involved with the wrong people. He chose this path. No one did it for him,” Dean angrily slams the folder shut. “At least I avenged your family. All you did was sit around, and sulk like an angry child. You turned your back on the life you had and became…I don’t even know what you are right now…”
“You’re an intensive asshole,” you jump up from your chair to ram the fork into his chest. Sadly, Dean is fast, too fast for you. He grabs your wrist midair and easily takes the fork out of your hand. “Monster! BASTARD! Kidnapper.”
“Yeah, that I am,” he wraps his arms around you and lets you slam your fists into his chest until you are out of breath and too weak to fight his embrace. “You know, Cole never was a nice guy. He was the one ratting your brother out. Just like he did with you that night. For the right amount of money, he would’ve gladly sold his mother to me.”
“I hate you,” Dean presses your head into his chest, smirking as you squirm in his hold. “You’re a—sonofabitch!”
“Language, sweetheart. My mother wasn’t a bitch,” the mobster holds you a little tighter when you start to fight him again. “You should know, you belong with me now. I don’t care what you want.”
“Asshole.”
“An asshole or a bastard would’ve just shot you. A monster would’ve done much worse to you for breaking into their house. I offered a warm bed, food, and protection to you, little thief,” he whispers lowly. “Maybe you should rethink your behavior. One thing is for sure, you will not leave my house, Y/N…never…”
>> Part 3
Tags in reblog.










