Hello, stranger (James Potter Fanfiction)
Summary: A stranger sends you the an accidental love confession to the wrong number, but you can't let it go, what happens when you two cross paths later?
Pairing: James Potter + Reader (modern au)
Warnings: James being hung up on Lily, meeting strangers, Sirius being Sirius, James being hot AND a hockey player Reader has some anxiety when it comes to new things and new people. I think that's all but if you find something else, lmk.
Word count: 4.5k (I know I promised that this series would be 2k each plss)
Hello, Lily, itās me James. I know that itās been a while, but I still havenāt stopped thinking about you. I love you, I know itās getting crazy repetitive after all these years, but I canāt help it, itās true. I love you. I love everything about you from your hair to your clothes and especially the way you act, even when youāre yelling at me. Call me if you get this, or text or send a pigeon, anything.Ā
I look at the message again for the fourth time since Iāve received it this morning, the message that I got on my new phone after I changed my number, a message very clearly not intended for me. I shouldnāt meddle, whoever this James is, he will surely understand sooner or later that he sent this (sweet) message to the wrong number. My phone dings.
Iām sorry, that was too forward, but itās nothing you didnāt already know, right? Ha, well Iām making a fool of myself here, Iāll talk to you at the reunion in a few weeks alright?
Oh, I sure hope everything ends up well from him. I lean over my phone, shielding it with my body, moving side to side on my chair, avoiding all the work thatās glaring at me from my computerās screen. My chair swivels around quickly to the other side, someoneās hand twirling it on its base, making me face them.Ā
āWhat are you looking at?āĀ
Lizzy asks, taking my phone away from my hands, even after I desperately clutch it in between my fingers, accidentally pressing all the buttons. The screen turns black, but Lizzy only inserts my password to turn it on. I can never escape her. I groan, āCome on, Lizzy. Weāve talked about this. Not at home and at work-āĀ
āYou didnāt tell me your name is Lily,ā she says, furrowing an eyebrow at me in question. She pushes and probes at the screen as if itās going to give her any more answers other than the heartfelt text that was sent. I shake my head, āItās not.āĀ
āItās an endearing message, are you going to reply?ā she says, handing me back my phone by the tips of her fingers, carelessly. I clutch it in my lap and quickly look at the messages before looking at her, her body leaning on her desk, arms crossed. I shake my head again and say, āno, definitely not. Itās none of my business.āĀ
She nods but then she bites her lip the way she always does when sheās plotting something, most of the time, that something is not tasteful. She explains, āBut what if he mentions the text at this reunion and completely embarrasses himself?ā
āI didnāt think of that partā¦ā I mumbled, my heart launched itself in my throat like a rocket when I saw the message. I couldnāt remember when was the last time someone told me something even close to that. Lizzy continues, āExactly, and he seems nice enough, just give him a call and let him know that itās the wrong number.āĀ
āMaybe a text would be better,ā I say, I canāt imagine what a conversation on the phone would even look like, itāll be easier to break the news via text. Lizzy rolls her eyes at me, taking my phone away from my hands again, this time I donāt resist. She clicks a few times before asking, āDo you think heās hot?āĀ
āWhat?āĀ
āHe sounds like heās hot.āĀ
āHow would I know-ā I say, the first thing I checked when I received the message was the profile picture, that didnāt have any picture present. Our boss yells out from the door to her office, and Lizzy sprints back to her desk, and I turn, fast, hitting my knees on the desk beside me as I turn to face my computer, moving the mouse, haphazardly, acting as though work was the thing on my mind.Ā
Hey, James. I text as soon as our boss turns around after I looked behind me to make sure that she isnāt looking. I put my phone on my desk, and clear my head of all this nonsense. There are still six more hours to this workday and one hour till lunch, I need to get all this work done.Ā
My phone rings, loudly, echoing through the walls of the office. I rush to mute the ring before looking to find my boss glaring at me. I look at the caller, and- oh, god, itās James. Caller ID showing his name in full James Potter, I donāt know any other James but him. I stand up abruptly, and whisper an apology to my boss, āIām sorry, I have to take this.āĀ
I walk out to the office, and stand outside the glass doors, finding Lizzy looking at me, curiously. I take a breath before sliding my finger on my phone, answering the call.Ā
āLily?āĀ
James says, his voice soft and hopeful. I scrunch up my nose, this is exactly why I didnāt want to do this on call. I clear my throat and I say, āNo, actually this isā¦um well, you can call me Birdie, everyone does.āĀ
āIs this not Lily Evanās phone?ā he says, deflated. I shake my head, and my face flushes, I reply, āNo-I uh I just got this number a few weeks ago, she mustāve changed herās.āĀ
Thereās silence on the other end of the line, it stays for a few seconds and I have to check if the call wasnāt cut off. Thereās a long sigh before he asks, āSo you read the message that I sent?āĀ
āYeah, Iām sorry, I didnāt mean to intrude or anything-āĀ
āItās okay, Iām glad I found this out before the reunion or else I wouldāve completely humiliated myself trying to talk to her about the text,ā he whispers, his words all breathy. The disappointment must be astronomical. I try to lift the burden by saying, āIt was a really sweet message, maybe try to find her number and tell her again.ā
āNahh, I donāt think sheād want to hear it again,ā he says. It must not be the first time heās told her his feelings, though I gathered that much from the message. But why would he tell her again? No, no, this is none of my business, though James rambles, āI mean, itās been years and Iāve been asking for a sign, maybe this is my sign. Do you think this is a sign?āĀ
āI-uhā
āIām sorry, I shouldnāt involve you in this,ā he says, saving me from having to answer. I shrug, āItās okay.ā I support my weight on the brick wall next to me and look inside the office through the glass doors. Lizzy, still looking at me curiously and our boss, still glaring. Another moment passes, and I hear shuffling on the other end of the phone. He says, āI think itās a sign.āĀ
āI donāt know whatās happened between the both of you, but if this isnāt the first time youāve confessed your feelings and all the times before they werenāt reciprocatedā¦then as much as I hate to say itā¦it might not be meant to be,ā I say, offering the advice that he didnāt ask for. My face turns red, who am I to act all high and mighty involving relationships when Iāve never had one?
āIāll think about it,ā his voice quivers at the end, āyou said your name was Birdie?āĀ
āNickname- uh, yes.āĀ
āWell, thank you, Birdie, I donāt want to waste any more of your day. Thank you for replying,ā he says, and I bite my lip and roll my shoulders, trying to ease out the tension. That wasnāt as bad as I thought it might be. I stand up, straightening, tearing my body off the wall, and walking the few steps to the door of the office. I say, āItās okay, I donāt mind.āĀ
***Ā
āWe do not need name brand cereal,ā I say, convincing Lizzy to put the expensive sugary breakfast back on the shelves. She points her finger at me, threatening, āIf we donāt get the name brand cereal, then we should splurge on our hair.āĀ
She fails to realise that throwing money at cereal is much less costly than throwing money on a bunch of hair care products. Unconsciously, I twirl the ends of my hair around my fingers and I straighten my face to stop myself from wincing. I reach out my hand and shake hers, āDeal.āĀ
The storeās bell rings and a noisy group starts to walk through the aisles. I push our trolley away to the other side, heading to the personal items section. Lizzy starts to pick out specific products for her tightly coiled hair while I try to find a shampoo that will suit us both.Ā
āSirius, just try not to waste all our time here,ā someone says a few feet away from us. Thereās a group of men that are also searching for shampoos of their own. The one named serious (?) replies, āCome on mooney, one doesnāt just wake up looking this good.āĀ
He flips his hair while doing so, his friends roll their eyes and continue to peruse the rows of products. I turn back to Lizzy, seeing her attention drawn to the boisterous group next to us, her eyes trained on the one named Sirius? She leaves the bottle of gel on the shelf and whispers in my ear, āHeās gorgeous, isnāt he?āĀ
I look back at the group, focusing on their appearance. Thereās three of them. The first, the one who was referred to as moony, is much taller than the other two and he has brown hair. The second, Sirius, whoās caught Lizzy's fancy has longer black hair and is dressed in a leather jacket. The last one is more muscular than the other two with dark curly hair and glasses perched on his nose.Ā
āWell you sure do try,ā the last one teases, with a beautiful smile on his face. Sirius ribs him in his stomach, but it doesnāt bother him that much. Sirius flips his hair over his shoulder, overdramatically, saying, āShut up, James. Maybe if you gave in a little more effort the ladies would like you as much as they do me.āĀ
James? Funny how that name has been popping up so much in the last few months. He actually does sound kind of likeā¦Lizzy continues that thought, āHow funny would it be if it were James that texted you his un-dying love?āĀ
āHe didnāt text me-ā I start but my eyes fall to the group coming closer towards us and thatās how I notice the shelves of menās shampoo right next to me. They toss us a few smiles before standing in front of the shelves picking up the strong smelling shampoos. Lizzyās eyes trail over Siriusā body before she grabs my hand for us to head over to the conditioners. She says, āCome on, Birdie.āĀ
āBirdie? James isnāt that the same-āĀ
Someone taps my shoulder. I turned around to face them, Lizzyās fingers still wrapped tightly around my wrist, my shoulder tugged towards her. Sirius is standing with a wide inquisitive grin on his face. James hides behind āmoonyā, his face burning. Sirius clears his throat before asking, āExcuse me, this might sound a bit odd, but do you happen to be the Bridie that my dear James confused his undying love to mistakenly three months ago?āĀ
Lizzy shoves me to the side, and peeks her face from behind me. She places both her hands on my shoulders and shakes me. Lizzy answers for me, āYup, thatās her.āĀ
James perks up from behind his tall friend, and before I can question anything, Sirius is on his knees on the ground, with his palms clutched together, as if he were pleading. He starts to say, āThank you, thank you, after years, and years, you finally got it into prongsā head that Lily doesnāt want him. Thank you!āĀ
āProngs?ā
āThatās Jamesā lilā nickname. Anyways, thank you for doing what none of us could. THANK YOU!ā he ends with his forehead landing on his clasped hands with his hair falling from behind his shoulders. My eyes flicker to Lizzy in questioning, what is happening? āMoonyā steps up and lifts Sirius up from the ground and he has an apologetic look on his face.Ā
āIām not really sure I did much, maybe he just had that revelation on his own,ā I mumble, my ears are red, people from the store are already watching this encounter. James finally speaks up, shoving Sirius to the side, giving him a tiny glare, āIām really sorry about him, Birdie.āĀ
āItās okay,ā I say, trying not to flush under his gaze. I guess Lizzy was right, James is more handsome than I imagined. Sirius bounces on his feet and he says, looking back at āmoonyā for a second, āWe have to thank them, we should go buy them drinks.āĀ
āSirius, we really shouldnāt-āĀ
āOh, Remy, donāt worry-ā he turns back to look at us, āYou pick the place obviously, whatever makes you both comfortable.āĀ
I look back at Lizzy, weāre still doing our shopping despite how this situation is, we couldnāt just go out with them? She has a smile on her face, and she lifts her finger, while she pulls me behind, "Excuse us for a moment.āĀ
āSo what are you thinking?ā Lizzy says, as soon as weāre out of ear-shot, hidden behind one of the aisles. I take a peak back to where we were standing and notice James giving Sirius a heated talk while Remy watches in amusement. I answer, āI donāt knowā¦āĀ
āI think we should go. I know we donāt know them, but weāll just pick our regular coffee shop, the people there know us, and itās bright out, and I canāt imagine us staying out for long. We can finally do something spontaneous and not spend the day arguing about what to spend on. Plus, theyāre really hot,ā Lizzy concludes, this time her head turning back for her to take a look.
She doesnāt say it, but I know she wants to, she wants me to finally go out and do something else, something new. She wants me to date, and she thinks this will be a stepping stone, though I donāt know how this will help with that. I shrug my shoulders and mumble, āAlright.āĀ
She grins and we walk back to them. Remy notices first, clearing his throat loudly, alerting the other two of our presence and they both look away, straightening up. Lizzy says, āI know this great spot for coffee, you alright with coffee?āĀ
They all nod and we head on our way.Ā
***
āWhat do you want, gorgeous?ā Sirius asks as soon as Lizzy and I sit down on the couch, giving Lizzy a sly grin. She mirrors the expression and slides her hair behind her shoulder, she replies, coyly, āA shaken espresso with oat milk.āĀ
I shove her playfully as soon as Sirius is out of view and her cheeks flush a light pink that I rarely see. James juts his bottom lip out and asks, āWhat about you Birdie? And Remus?āĀ
āItās okay I donāt mind anything,ā I reply shrugging my shoulders, avoiding looking directly into his beautiful brown eyes. Remy? No- Remus says, āYou really donāt mind anything?āĀ
Iām about to repeat the same statement as before when Lizzy nudges me with a look. I flush and say, āMy favorite is actually a caramel latte please, if you donāt mind.āĀ
āYour wish is my command,ā James jokes with a pretty smile before turning to Remus, āThe usual?āĀ
Remus nods, and he sits down on the chair beside the couch weāre on. Lizzyās too busy staring at Siriusā back to notice Remus wanting to say something. I turn to the brunette and he starts, āI hope youāre not feeling too uncomfortable, Sirius always means well even if he doesnāt always get the social cues.āĀ
āOh, itās okay, whatās wrong with a little bit of spontaneity?" a reply with a grimace at the last part, I canāt remember the last time I did something without extensive planning, Lizzy squeezes my thigh under the table in comfort. I thank her with a smile. My eyes glance over to where James and Sirius are getting drinks, and I mumble, āIām not sure James wants to do this though.āĀ
āOh-I I think he does, heās mentioned you a few times, I think itās a surprise-ā he stutters before Lizzy turns to him quickly as soon as she sees the two men walking over hands filled with drinks. She asks, āIs Sirius dating anyone?āĀ
āNo-āĀ
āPerfect,ā she says, before leaning forward on the table, forcing her chest out. I chuckle under my breath at my friendās antics, and even Remusā lips quirk upwards. Sirius sets down Lizzyās drink in front of her with a wink and she wraps her lips around the straw and sets her eyes on him. I look away, Lizzy sure is bold.Ā
James looks away from the ongoing interaction and clears his throat. He sets down Remusā drink from his left hand and my own with his right, then he grabs his cup that was suffocating between his bicep and forearm. I try not to look at the condensation dripping on his muscles from the cold drink. The only difference between Lizzy and I is that I keep the thoughts in my head.Ā
James sits opposite to me and Sirius next to him. I sip my drink quietly enjoying the sugar flavor on my tongue. I look to my left and notice the espresso shot that Remus is drinking, I ask, āYou donāt drink it with any sugar or cream?āĀ
Remus gulps down the sip he was taking and sets the small paper cup down with a small clunk. He shakes his head and explains, āI like coffee, I donāt need anything to drown the taste.āĀ
I nod my head and feel the awkwardness to seep in, what was there to talk about? I barely know a thing about these people, and as I face the right and find Lizzy still making eyes at Sirius, I feel the urge to say anything. As seamlessly as possible I try to open my phone, and scroll the chat between James and I, trying to find a clue on what to say, looking up every few seconds to make sure that Iām not offending anyone- yes, okay this is good.Ā
āYou mentioned that you had a high school reunion or something like that?āĀ
āAh yes, it was uh- a few weeks ago,ā James answers, connecting the dots since he mentioned it to me around a month ago. That pulls Siriusā attention and he slams his hand on his friends shoulder, a strong hand that doesnāt move James in the slightest, must be all the muscles. Sirius says, āIt was exactly seventy two days ago, I will remember that historical day for all my life.āĀ
āWhy exactly is it historical again?ā Lizzy asks, and just as Sirius beams, James sags. Sirius leans back in his chair and tangles his fingers on the table in front of him. He explains, boistrously, āThe day that James finally proved that he moved on from Lily.āĀ
āAn ex girlfriend?ā Lizzy asks, I musnāt have filled her in on all the details. Sirius repeats all the information that I already know to Lizzy with every explanation and facial expression flirtatious. Itās a special talent to make a simple conversation flirtatious. I feel someoneās eyes on me and I find James, watching me. I flush and look away again while he inconspiciously grabs his cup and starts to suck on the straw.Ā
I stare out of the window and think, what is the goal here again? Obviously, Lizzy and Sirius have it figured out, but what am I doing here? Iām definelty not going to ask James out, he seems embaressed by the whole ordeal actually. I know I would be if the roles were reversed.Ā
āHey, Biride, can you go get me a cookie?ā Lizzy interupts my thoughts and bats her eyelashes at me. I purse my lips, suspiciously but nod anyways. After I stand, Sirius looks to James and says, āHey, mate, can you go get me a cookie too?āĀ
Sirius also bats his eyelashes at James. It only makes me look at Lizzy with more suspicioun. When did they plan this? James doesnāt give his friend a response, he instead stands and tilts his head to ask me, āCome with me?āĀ
I nod my head and scoot between the table and couch and behind Remusā chair. We walk the two feet together, but not before I shot Lizzy a look, she instead gives me two excited thumbs up. My face heats up and I hear James saying, āTwo cookies please.ā
He hands his card over to Charles the cachier, and I stumble over my words, āOh, you donāt have to-āĀ
āCome on, Birdie, let your handsome date pay for your things,ā Charles interupts, and I glare at him and ignore the way he eyes James, not that Iāve been any better. James says, āI forgot you were a regular here.āĀ
I nod my head and internally beg Charles to stop talking but he starts to- oh, god- threaten James, āI see Birdie here every few days, if you so much as even look at her the wrong way, I will have your head. I might not look it, but I can swing a nice punch.āĀ
āItās not-āĀ
āIāll take good care of her, donāt worry,ā James says, and Charlies smiles, genuinly and wishes him a nice day while giving him his receipt, reverting back to his customer service voice. We move aside away from the line waiting at the cachier and stand to the side to receive our order. I lift my hands up to my face and press the back of my fingers to my cheeks trying to cool down the heat.Ā
āIām sorry about him,ā I say, giving Charles a glare while he takes the order of the next customer. James chuckles deep with his chest, and says, āItās okay, Iām sorry about this whole thing too.āĀ
āItās okay,ā I mirror his words, and he leans on the ceramic table. His arms bulging under his weight, I move my eyes back to his face quickly, hoping that he didnāt catch me oogling his arms for the millionth time in the last hour. He asks, āwhen you called me, you were at work,Ā right?āĀ
I nod my head and remember the stern talking to that my boss gave me after I hung up the phone. Iām not in the mood to talk about my own job, so I turn the question around, āWhat do you do?āĀ Ā
āIām a hockey player,ā James replies, and my mouth forms an āOā in understanding. I say before I can stop myself, āWell, that explains it.āĀ
āExplains what?ā James asks, innocently but with his lips turned upwards. Oh my god, what am I supposed to say? That explains your amazing muscular body, I canāt- I swear I see his pecs flex under his shirt. I ramble, āI- I mean, youāre just- I donāt know, well, you know, you seem-āĀ
āIām just messing with you,ā James laughs, and I cover my face with my hands. This couldnāt be going any worse. My face must be burning. James leans down, and through my fingers I can see him. I pull my hands away from my face, and he grins, oh, heās going to kill me, instinctivly, I look away, my eyes falling on my friend who is pulling out all her moves right before my eyes; the lip bite, the hair toss, the works.Ā
I also notice that Siriusā hand is itching to grab herās over the table. They seem to be really hitting it off. To the other end of the table, there is Remus sitting, phone face down, and espresso cup empty, looking anywhere but at the sight in front of him. I say, āwe should go save Remus.āĀ
āYouāre very kind, but heās used to it by now,ā James says, and I frown slightly. Does Sirius do this sort of thing a lot? I wouldnāt want Lizzy to get too invested and have her heart broken. James adds, āDonāt worry about your friend, Sirius acts all flirtatious but he has a good heart.āĀ
I nod my head and look away from the table. Marjorie slides two plates over to us, gliding over the ceramic counter, each with a cookie on top of them. James grabs both before I can act, and we start walking towards the table. Just two feet away, still out of earshot because of the chatter in the cafe. He stops and says, āBirdie.āĀ
I hum, and turn to face him, I notice the tight grip he has on the small circular plates. He stares at his shoes and then looks me in the eye. I press my lips together and he starts, āExcuse me if Iām being too-uh forward, but are you seeing anyone right now?āĀ
I accidentally slightly bite my lip in surprise. I let out a small pained noise, and James takes a step forward qujickly apologizeing, āIām sorry I asked, itās none of my business-āĀ
I wave him off and take a moment to let the sting in my mouth quiet down. I explain, āSorry, I just bit my tongue,ā James laughs and I canāt help but chuckle too as the pain simmers down, āno, Iām not seeing anyone, right now.āĀ
He smiles and nods his head, sheepishly. We take another step towards the table when he adds, āYou wouldnāt mind if I called you sometime?āĀ
I shake my head, and say, āNot at all,ā his smile widens, and his eyes crinkle at the sides. I look at the wooden boards, feeling my own grin on my face. Lizzy notices, of course and her eye brows quirk up with a knowing expression. We sit back down on the table, and itās only an hour before we have to leave to go on with our own days.Ā
I try not to think about James calling, most men say they will, but donāt, or say they will and actually call many days or even a week later. Still, I canāt help but make sure that my phone is on the maximum volume, making sure I donāt miss the phone when it does ring. On our way home Lizzy says, āItās sort of like fate, isnāt it? A sign?āĀ
I shrug my shoulders, the words simillar to what I heard from James three months ago. I try not to get my hopes up, but I have a good feeling about all this. Lizzy gave Sirius her number too. Later in the day, just an hour after the sun went down, my phone rings, Lizzy laughs when I jump to where it is. Caller ID says, James Potter.
He called so quickly, this has got to be a good sign, right? I take in a deep breath and let it ring for an extra second before I pick it up, āHello?āĀ
āHey, Birdie.āĀ
a/n: I hope you enjoyed reading! If you think this didnāt completely suck, feel free to check out my other masterlists. You can also support the blog or buy me a coffee here.
Birdie Masterlist here
Marauders masterlist here
Harry Potter masterlist here















