hadestown has inspired so much angst in me.. after watching jordan fisher live thereās just so many pent up writing ideasā¦.
so hereās an idea i have going for nalu angst inspired by hadestown:
a fic where natsu and lucy reunite post tartaros in hell, except itās because after lucy was abandonedāinstead of her usual tenacity, in this au she loses her will to go on. natsu didnāt come back soon enough here, so she loses the last shred of hope and per severance she has when zeref begins approaching her in her dreams.
natsu didnāt appear at the grand magic arena. and lucy came home in the same low spirits. and thereās continuous slow news about anyone in the guild.
it starts slow. out of no where he begins to haunt her, constantly barraging her dreams with dark magic, convincing her that her friends wonāt come back for her. they left her with no hesitation, why would they come back? lucy, our strong willed girl, still doesnāt fall to this until zeref starts targeting her memories of natsu. he twists them, makes natsuās teasing a little harsher. a bit less funny, and more sharp. then he replays these memories to lucy.
he then starts darkening lucyās dreams and barrages her with dream sequences of doubts of natsu ever returning, making up scenes of natsu writing her the letter while saying horrible things like: āiām only writing this so she wonāt bother usā or āeveryoneās leaving and i donāt need her coming with us and slowing us downā (which natsu would never ever say) . he goes as far as to show a scenes of natsu out in the woods meeting with erza, gray, and wendy, and them speaking about how easy their lives had been since leaving the guild (and inferring that itās because lucy was left behind too) . zeref starts incorporating repeat sequences of lucy breaking aquariusās key, and adds whispers of āweakā, or āuselessā, every time she relives the scene in her dreams.
she no longer has the strength to call her spirits for comfort, and she pushes loke away out of fear that heāll begin to see her as a burden too. she canāt close her eyes without seeing the backs of her guild mates walking away, or hearing natsuās voice speaking about her like sheās a burden. it sounds almost distinctly like how her father used to speak to her all those years ago.
zeref takes the final push in one final appearance in her dreams. this time heās there as himself, and speaks to her kindly. āi know. youāre tired arenāt you? i know somewhere where you wonāt be alone like this ever againā
having gone so long without a kind voice leaves lucy vulnerable, and it doesnāt help that she hasnāt slept or ate in weeks
lucy, unable to think past her ptsd, and broken mental fortitude takes zerefās hand. and suddenly her real body is teleported to hell. zerefās plan to use her as bait to finally get natsu has worked.
itās at this point that natsu has finally decided to return, that heās strong enough to protect lucy from any future danger. that he can now make sure something like tartaros will never happen again.
he finds out where sheās living, and has just snuck through the window when he watches her body vanish in a black smoke, dark magic lingering, and her keys left behind.
zerefās voice echos around her old bedroom āif you want to find her, come to the alvarez empireā and so ofc. natsu goes. and when he arrives, heās brought to the gates of hell itself.
he journeys through the underworld, blazing and fighting with the same fairy tail spirit heās always had, and the heated passionate protective love heās always had for lucy heartfilia. except, when he finally gets to the underworld, blessing, bruised, and with a few broken bones he meets soulless eyes, and bony, brittle hands mining coal.
gone are the sunshine warmth of her brown eyes. her hair is duller, fine golden locks faded to lifeless and brittle gray. her skin is an unsettling pallor of pale. and the freckles she had gained over the years as a fairy tail wizard have faded like sheād never been in the light.
lucyās eyes donāt even look at natsu like a stranger, they donāt see him. and he thinks that is what hurts the most.
it isnāt until his temper rises, and with it his flames does she start to come back to life. the ire of his fire spreads out all over hell, and when lucy feels the heat, itās too familiar for her to ignore and she snaps back to the past where sheās meeting natsu for the first time in hargeon, and feeling the warmth and safety of his fire for the first time. after all this time, sheās still not scared of his fire. her eyes regain her brown, and she remembers natsu, recognizes him again.
they embrace, and she cries, yelling at him for leaving her behind but canāt keep it up for long, too relieved to see him after being separated for so long.
itās then that zeref appears. threatening natsu with erasing lucy completely if he didnāt fight him now. natsu, justifiably angered, accepts the fight easilyā and is quickly humbled.
and so they strike a bargain, zeref thinks itās not their time to fight, and he still needs natsu to get the will and strength to kill him. itās still too early unfortunately, and he canāt let natsu dies without killing him. and so he gives natsu a test. he can try and rescue lucy, he can bring her back up from hellā but like orpheus he canāt look back, they will not be walking hand and hand side by side. and if he did look back? lucy dies forever, and goes back to the underworld, blank, and forgotten to the dreams of her once full life.
contemplating how iād end this. tragedy like hadestown where natsu canāt help but look back, worried she wasnāt there⦠or if iād give them the happy ending. who knows. just thinking :p will save for a future writing project