You know, that fic reminded me... Qrow, Robyn, and the Ace Ops (sans Vine) were in an airship overlooking the crash at the end of V8 right? Did Qrow just... Not try to search for his nieces in the wreckage?
In fairness to Qrow (gotta throw him a bone sometimes lol) we left him right after the crash. So he fights Harriet, Vine dies with the bomb, and then last we see theyâre all staring down at Atlas currently falling/the kingdom currently flooding, frantically trying to get one of the girls on the comm system. So we wonât know whether he tried to search for them or not until we next see him.Â
Though really, RWBYâs continuing ambiguity doesnât help matters. Meaning, we know that Winter ran into Qrow and Weiss spoke with Winter, so the assumption then, when theyâre fighting the Ace Ops, is that everyone is in on Team RWBYâs plan: save Penny and then evacuate everyone to Vacuo. So... why doesnât a portal appear somewhere near Qrow? Why arenât he and Robyn worried about whether theyâll miss the evacuation when theyâre unexpectedly chasing an escaped Harriet? Like Winter does, are they supposed to head to the vault after snagging the Ace Ops? And why is Qrow looking for his nieces in Mantle/Atlas if he knows theyâre leading the evacuation to Vacuo? The only detail that works for me here (that Iâve seen others criticize) is Qrow trying to call them because thatâs just a natural reaction. He instinctively wants to check in and doesnât know that the system is down. If theyâre not picking up it may just mean they successfully got to Vacuo (no CCT across kingdoms anymore)... or, if theyâre still here, from his perspective it might mean theyâre dead.Â
(Which, you know, they kind of are.)Â
But otherwise itâs another scene that just expects the viewer to come up with an explanation to fit all the pieces together. Like Qrowâs incredibly strange maybe prayer/maybe development in his semblance, the lack of details regarding how this portal plan works and why Qrow doesnât seem to be a part of it are things weâre not supposed to think too hard about. In the same way we shouldnât think too hard about why his nieces donât want to search for a missing Qrow, donât want to break him out of jail, and generally donât remember he exists until theyâre hoping he can solve their problems. Donât think too hard because applying what you see on screen interrupts the general assumption that they adore one another completely! Yang doesnât remember she fought with her sister and instead is worried about a nonexistent fight with Blake. Weissâ abusive father is framed as a joke and her victim brother framed as a legitimate threat. At no point post-Amity does Penny remember that she has a father who may have crashed in the tundra, dead of cold, grimm, or who knows what else. The relationships nowadays are so broken, so at least Qrow remembered that his nieces are somewhere and is worried for their safety. Messy as the plot otherwise is, big props for that at least.Â