Jan 23, 2019
Hey, Judge? If I have both Pyromancer's Gauntlet and Angrath's Marauders on the battlefield, how do I determine which effect applies first?
It's not up to you to determine which effect applies first unless your spell (e.g. Lightning Strike) is targeting yourself or a permanent you control.When multiple replacement effects want to modify the amount of damage dealt to something, the affected player or the controller of the affected object gets to choose the order in which those effects are applied. In the situation you describe, this means that your opponent will probably choose to have the Lightning Strike deal eight damage to them or their creature or planeswalker (double first then add two) rather than ten damage (add two then double).
