The quorra problem | Programs, isos and the real world
Disclaimer: This has nothing to do with Quorra as a character! Itâs more of a story element critique if anything, please read and donât jump on me for the title. Quorra is adorable and I enjoy legacy- even if it doesnât look like it from how I keep tearing it apart.
Itâs a damned if you do damned if you donât situation. On one hand you canât leave her inside the grid when Flynn decides to literally go nuclear but you canât leave her in the real world either. They have to because they wanted Flynnâs self sacrificing ending or wrote themselves into a corner (this isnât about reintegration but I will still complain) and this was there way out. But they didnât consider the implications of it at all.
Iâve made several posts about it and still want to write something with this idea but to a programâ the real world wouldnât be so miraculous like how we see theirs. The minute youâre outside youâre ïżŒImediately bombarded with sensory overload and just too much information to process. The grid, which is much more human in its design than the ENCOM system, is still infinitely more minimalist than our world. One of the best scenes is Clu and his team raiding the hideout and not knowing what a single thing is and freaking out, she seems too well adjusted for someone whoâs spent a few hours max hereâ look I know itâs the end of a movie and they canât do that whole arc, but I digress.
Also donât get me started on the rumored Ares plot and how they totally forgot quorra is already a program(technically iso) in our world- also itâs not really a âtronâ movie plotâ whereâs the allegory?! The metaphor?! The symbolism?!
Another thing is thatâŠSam canât tell anyone about her. Maybe Alan but her mere existence in our world is brain shattering. Trying to explain a advanced humanoid being thatâs not here to harm us and is totally cool guys almost never goes well. It also leaves people a LOT to grapple withâŠlike everything we know being forever altered.
This whole situation should be terrifying from both perspectives, however I love the theory that the only reason she was able to get out into the real world at all was because of Flynnâs data stored in the beam. Thatâs a great thought that almost makes me like her being in the real world just from how much impact that is.
What happens now? She canât be revealed to the world (yet) and to put her back in the remains of the grid would be cruel. Putting her in another system would be wildly irresponsible because- do we even know what ISOs do? Across all media its âtheyâre specialâ but absolutely squat on their actual function or what theyâre capable of. We see they have some kind of digital dna thatâs literally a miraculous occurrence but thatâs about it. Did Flynn even know? Are they just there- existing but not effecting/having a real world computer impact? Or worse - what if clu was right and they did contribute to the crumbling state of the grid? (I think it was a combination of his own fear and scapegoatingâIâm just tossing the idea out there).
Sam transferring her over to another system without knowing what she does or how she could effect it would be disastrous. Am I saying sheâs dangerous or would have any intent to harm? No not at all thatâs now who she is, but itâs sort of a âreleasing a domestic cat into the woods a state overâ you donât do that.
Does she get a regular job now, does Sam hire her at ENCOM? Sheâd likely be some sort of computer smartâŠin that she come from one. Or does he like â- set her up at a McDonaldâs? Howâs she get energy does she get plugged in- being in the real world isnât going to magically give her a stomach. Sam just takes her to a power grid and she causes SoCal to blackout lmao.
Iâm aware most of this post is just me overthinking the implications of everything they didnât intend us to think to hard about. Itâs supposed to be âyippee theyâre safeâ and Iâm worried about digital ecosystems and what the human brain can handle. I think my problem mainly strives from this trope where the character brings home their friend from the other world/ is the reverse situation and no one bats an eye at all. Itâs because they want the characters to still be friends no matter how many rules it breaks or sense it makes. It happens most commonly in cartoons. (Thereâs at least 3 in recent memory)
Iâm not saying I want quorra to have been caught in the blast but that thereâs a way they couldâve kept communication without world breaking. Open portal situation where he goes back to visit, he chats with her on the screen, both stay in their own worlds its sad but logical etc (Iâm not writing a new ending but you get the pointïżŒ).
I guess it annoys me so much because itâs left so open ended, ride off into the sunrise while ignoring the implicationsâąïž. âI guess, Weâre going to change the worldâ ok how đ§ââïž. The movie did not nearly give me enough information about ISOâs to see what changes they exactly do besides taking over ENCOM. âThey[Isoâs] changed everythingâ ok howđ§ââïž. Yeah itâs immaculate conception but what do they do I am shaking your shoulders Disney what do they do!
Itâs not quorra Iâm mad about or even the concept of ISOâs but itâs how the writing just falls short in these HUGE areas that require a lot of lore and information to be given that they just do not. And consistently donât In the other media forms like betrayal (I havenât seen uprising maybe they explain something). If youâre going to have beings that shatter your ideas of reality you sort of have to explain that!