headcanon reaction game: "divine mandate of heaven" style Primacy
π Neutral. I donβt love it, but I donβt hate it either.
Okay, so rather than neutral this is something that varies depending on continuity.
Like, in TFP (and others) this is not a headcanon, this is simply a part of the worldbuilding and sure, I'll go along with it for the sake of being told a story. Unicron is right fucking there, I'll buy Primus.
For Sunbow I really do prefer the Quintesson origin backstory, no matter how much spin-off media retcons it. This requires no Primus, so no divine to mandate. In this case, I rather headcanon the Matrix which holds "the wisdom of the primes" as some repository computer that holds an imprint of all the Primes that have bonded with it, it connects to the mind of possible holders and uses that collective wisdom to judge if they have the qualities for a good leader. Kinda like Psycho-pass but you know, less dystopian.
But if I'm reading a G1-inspired thing and we're going by a "divine right of Primes as ordained by Primus" thing, it's fine. I'll go along.
However, if we're talking IDW1 then I absolutely loathe it. It not only goes against the canon text, but also against the themes and basically everything I like about this continuity. There's nothing special about being Prime, this was one of the things both Barber and Robert's works agreed on. Literally all of exRID/OP was about how no one should have that kind of power. It ruins the OP ending, it ruins Optimus' character, it ruins Rodimus' character, it ruins the "good enough" speech. Rung was A Guy, he has special powers but he is not divine, he is A Guy. The 13 Primes, with whom this whole idea started, sucked. The Legacy of the Primes cannot be salvaged. The Primacy as we know it today started with Nova Prime, who majorly sucked, who was also a true matrix bearer. Given that last point I don't think we should pretend that bauble is really a judge of some vague quality of nobility, instead of just something that reacts to whether you yourself think you're worthy.