THE WEIGHT OF STILL WATER [Single Dad! Bucky Barnes]
✦ Paring: Reader × Single Dad! Bucky
✦ Summary: You’ve returned to Hartwell, a small coastal town in Maine—for the summer to look after your grandmother’s house while she recovers from surgery. You thought you’d find some peace and quiet. Instead, you find James Barnes: the owner of the only fishing charter in town.
✦ AU pairings: Fishing charter AU · Coastal town AU · Single Dad!Bucky
✦ Tropes: Grumpy × grumpier · Emotional hurt/comfort ·
✦ Word count: x
✧ Bucky's masterlist
Join a Taglist: Leave a comment or send an ask to be added to my oneshots | series | all writing
Hartwell in July smelled of salt, boat diesel and something sweet that came from the bakery on the main street, a smell you had forgotten and that came back to you all at once as soon as you opened the car door, like a gentle slap.You picked up the bag from the passenger seat. You looked at Marge's house.It needed a coat of paint. The gutter on the north side was hanging slightly. The garden had kept growing without supervision, which meant the hydrangeas had now colonized the side passage and you'd have to negotiate with them to reach the back door.You took out your phone. You called Marge.She picked up on the second ring.
"You're here," she said.
"I'm here. The gutter is dead."
"It was dead in May. I told you not to look at the gutter."
"You told me not to stress about the gutter. That's different."
Marge's smile passing through her voice even when she tries to hold it back.
"The freezer's full. I asked Lou to stop by before you."
"Lou Tran?"
"There's only one Lou in Hartwell."
"He's still there."
"Everyone's still there. This is Hartwell.How was the drive?"
"Long."
"This is Maine, honey."
You looked at the hydrangeas. They looked pleased with themselves.
"I'm fine, Marge."
"I know you're fine. I didn't ask if you were fine."
"You were going to."
"I was going to ask if you'd eaten on the road."
"I ate on the road."
"Good.Lou also left some coffee beans on the counter. Not the powder stuff you drink on weekdays."
"I can hear the judgment in your voice."
"I'm not judging. I'm observing."
You smiled despite yourself. You grabbed your bag and went into your grandmother's house, which smelled of lavender and old wood and slightly of the dust of a house that hasn't been aired out in three weeks.
"I'll call you tonight," you said.
"Don't call too late. They turn the lights off at nine here."
"It's a rehabilitation center, not a prison."
"You haven't met my roommate."
You hung up. You put your bag on the kitchen table. And you looked at the inside of Marge's house, the photos on the wall, the floral sofa she's refused to change since 2003, the window that looks onto the garden and the victorious hydrangeas, and you took a long breath.
Six weeks.You could do six weeks.
The End of the Dock was seven minutes on foot, which you had verified at sixteen and which hadn't changed. The town hadn't really changed either, a few facades repainted, a souvenir shop that had replaced the old grocery, but the dock was the same, the boats were the same, and the smell of low tide at seven in the evening was exactly the one you remembered.Lou Tran was behind his counter when you came in.He looked up. He smiled.
"Marge told me you were coming today."
"Did she tell you what time?"
"She said in the afternoon. I figured out the rest."
You sat down on a stool. The bar smelled of beer and damp wood and something frying in the kitchen, not unpleasant, on the contrary, the kind of smell that says it's time to eat and that you're somewhere real.
"You've grown," said Lou.
"I was twenty last time. It was inevitable."
"In your head I mean. You have the face of someone who has grown."
"Is that a compliment or an observation?"
"Both."
He put a glass of soda in front of you without asking, he'd retained that too apparently, that you didn't drink alcohol, and he rested his elbows on the counter with the ease of someone who has spent twenty years in this bar and no longer needs to pretend to be busy.
"Marge doing well?" he asked.
"She's complaining about her roommate. So yes."
"Good sign." He looked toward the window. "Did you see the dock when you came in?"
"Briefly."
"There's a good crowd this summer. The charter's doing well."
"What charter?"
"Barnes."
He said it with the neutrality of someone saying an ordinary name while watching at the same time how you receive it.
"James Barnes. He bought Danny's old charter four years ago. Now he's the only one around."
"I don't remember a Barnes."
"He came after you. His wife was from here.Rebecca Hartley. You must have known her."
Becca Hartley. You remembered her, red hair, easy laughs, she was in the year below at the summer school you did here every July.
"Was she doing well?" you asked, and you knew from the way Lou moved his head that it was the wrong tense.
"She died three years ago. Cancer."
You said nothing for a moment. You drank your soda.
"He has a daughter," Lou continued, quietly. "Gracie. Six years old. She's everywhere."
As if to confirm it, the door of the bar opened.The little girl had dark hair and clear eyes and the energy of a person who hasn't yet learned that strangers require an observation period before being approached.She stopped in front of you.She looked at you.
"You're new," she said.
"I'm not new. I was coming back."
"What's the difference?"
"I've been here before."
She thought about that with the seriousness of a child who takes information at face value.
"I wasn't here before," she said. "So for me you're new."
"That's solid logic."
"My name's Gracie."
"I know. Lou just told me about you."
She looked at Lou with an expression half proud half suspicious.
"What did you say about me?"
"That you were everywhere," said Lou.
"That's true," admitted Gracie with absolute simplicity. She turned back to you. "What's your name?"
You told her.She repeated your name once, as if testing it.
"It's good," she concluded. "Where do you live?"
"Marge Kowalski's house. On Pine Street."
"I know that house. It has big blue flowers out front."
"The hydrangeas, yes."
"My dad says they grow too much."
She climbed onto the stool beside you with the agility of a child accustomed to this bar.
"Do you like crabs?"
"Eating them or looking at them?"
"Both."
"Eating yes. Looking depends on the crab."
She nodded with a knowing air, as if you had just confirmed something important about your character.
"My dad catches crabs sometimes. When customers want them."
"Is your dad the one with the charter?"
"Yeah." She looked toward the door. "He's coming. He's putting stuff away."
As if she'd called him, the door opened.He was tall, that was the first thing you noticed, because he filled the doorframe in a way that wasn't aggressive but that took up space all the same. Dark hair, a little long. A fishing jacket over a t-shirt. Hands that looked like they'd worked.He saw Gracie. He saw Lou. He saw you.His expression didn't change, but something in his posture adjusted slightly, the way people do when they notice someone they hadn't anticipated.
"Gracie," he said. "I told you to wait outside."
"It was hot."
"It wasn't hot."
"It was hot for me."
He looked at Lou with an expression that silently asked if everything was all right. Lou made a hand gesture that meant yes, yes.
"Who's that?" asked Gracie, pointing at you, as if you weren't there.
"I don't know," said her father.
"It's the girl from Marge Kowalski's house," said Gracie. "She likes crabs. Well eating them. Looking depends."
He looked at you. You looked at him.
"Hello," you said.
"Hello."
"James Barnes," said Lou, who was clearly loving his role.
"I can read a face," said James without looking at Lou.
"What do you read on mine?" you asked, because something in his tone had slightly irritated you and you were tired from the drive and you hadn't had time to compose a polite version of yourself.
He looked at you a second longer than necessary.
"Someone who's come from far away and was expecting something else," he said.
He wasn't wrong. You said nothing.He put a hand on top of Gracie's head.
"We're going home," he said.
"But I haven't finished talking..."
"You're finished for tonight."
Gracie looked at you with the tragic expression of a child interrupted in the middle of something important.
"See you tomorrow," she told you, as if it were a given.
"See you tomorrow," you answered.
They left. The door closed.Lou wiped a glass with the quiet satisfaction of someone who has watched a scene unfold exactly as expected.
"So," he said.
"So nothing," you answered.
"Just saying."
"You didn't say anything."
"I was going to say dinner's ready if you want to stay."
You looked at the door. You looked at your empty glass.
"I'm staying," you said.
You discovered the problem with the boiler the next morning at six forty-five, in the shower, when the water went from lukewarm to icy in the space of three seconds.You said a word Marge would not have appreciated.You called Lou at seven because it was the only local number you had.
"The boiler," you said when he picked up.
"Good morning to you too."
"Lou. The boiler."
He exhaled, not irritated, more the sigh of someone who had anticipated this moment.
"Marge told me it had been making noises since April."
"She didn't tell me that."
"She didn't want you to stress."
"The gutter and now the boiler. What's the next surprise?"
"The shutter in the back bedroom bangs when there's an east wind."
You closed your eyes.
"Is there someone who can come look at it today?"
"There's Barnes."
You opened your eyes.
"There's no one else?"
"The local plumber is in Portland until Thursday. Barnes does everything. Boilers, gutters, whatever you need. He learned doing up his house."
"He seems like the type to want to help."
"He doesn't seem like any type at all. But he does it anyway.Should I tell him to stop by?"
You looked at the cold bathroom. You looked at your feet on the tile.
"Tell him to stop by," you said.
He arrived at nine with a toolbox and Gracie, who was wearing a pink backpack with stars on it and who walked into Marge's house as if she had her own habits there.
"Can she wait outside?" you asked.
"She never waits outside."
"I'm just looking," said Gracie from the entryway where she was already examining the photos on Marge's wall with methodical attention.
"The boiler's in the basement," you said to James.
"I know where boilers are."
"I was just showing you the way."
"I know this house."
You looked at him. He looked at you. It wasn't hostility, it was subtler than that, two people who hadn't yet decided what to do with each other and who were keeping their distance in the meantime.
"Fine," you said. "Then go ahead."
He went to the basement.Gracie settled at the kitchen table with her colored pencils, she had them in her backpack, with a pad of white paper and a pencil case shaped like a dinosaur, and she drew with the concentration of a child who doesn't need anyone to find something for her to do.You made coffee.
"Have you lived here long?" she asked without looking up from her drawing.
"Until August. Then I go back."
"Where?"
"Boston."
She thought about it.
"Is Boston big?"
"Big enough."
"Here it's small." She changed pencils. "But my dad says small is good. He says you can see the stars."
"He's right."
"You can't see the stars in Boston?"
"Not all of them. Too many lights."
She looked up at you with an expression that said this was serious information.
"That's sad."
"You get used to it."
"I wouldn't get used to it." She went back to her drawing. "I love stars. My dad shows me the names sometimes. When we go out in the evening on the boat."
"He takes you on the boat at night?"
"When the customers have gone. Just the two of us." She smiled at her drawing without looking at you. "It's my favorite time."
You drank your coffee. You watched this six-year-old drawing at your grandmother's table with her pencils and her dinosaur case, and you thought Lou was right, she was everywhere, and it wasn't a flaw.James came back up from the basement forty minutes later.
"The burner," he said. "I can adjust it now but it'll need replacing before winter."
"Can you replace it this summer?"
"If you find the part."
"Where is it?"
"Hardware store in Rockport."
He put his tools on the floor, opened his box, took something out.
"I won't be able to go get it before Friday. The charter's full this week."
"I can go."
He looked at you.
"You have a car?"
"I rented something at the airport."
"Rockport is forty minutes away."
"I can read a map."
He gave a brief nod, not approving, just neutral, the kind that says fine.
"I'll make you a list of what you need."
"I can write too."
Gracie looked up from her drawing, looked at her father, looked at you. She had the expression of a referee waiting to see if someone was going to score a point.Nobody scored a point.James took a pen from his pocket and wrote the references on a scrap of paper that he set on the counter.
"The boiler will hold until Friday," he said. "If it starts making noises again call Lou."
"Not you directly?"
"Lou finds me faster than you can."
"Do I have your number?"
"No."
A silence.
"You don't want to give me your number," you said, and it was an observation, not a question.
"If you need me, go through Lou."
You looked at the list on the counter. You looked at Barnes putting his tools away with methodical, economical movements, the kind of movements that say the conversation is over because he has decided it is.
"How much do I owe you?" you asked.
"Nothing."
"I owe you something."
"It's Marge's house."
"Marge isn't here."
"I know." He closed his box. "It's still Marge's house."
You wanted to insist. You held back, not out of politeness, but because something in his tone said it would do no good and you didn't have the energy to fight on that ground this morning.
"Gracie," he said.
"I'm almost done."
"You're almost always done."
"Because I like to finish what I start." She looked up at you. "This is for you."
She pushed the drawing across the table toward you.It was a house, Marge's house, recognizable by the big blue flowers out front, with two figures outside. A tall one with dark hair and a small one with dark hair too. And beside them, a third smaller figure with what looked like hair the color you had told her yours was.
"That's the three of us," she explained. "In front of your house. Because that's where we met."
You looked at the drawing.
You looked at James.He was looking at the ceiling with the expression of a man who had learned not to comment on his daughter's social initiatives.
"Thank you Gracie," you said. "It's very good."
"I know," she said simply.
She put her pencils away. She put her dinosaur case back in her backpack. She jumped off her chair.James picked up the toolbox. He looked at the drawing on the table for a second, just one, and something in his expression moved, imperceptibly, before going neutral again.
"The list is on the counter," he said.
"I saw it."
"Have a good day."
"You too."
They left. The door closed. You drank the rest of your cold coffee standing in Marge's kitchen, with Gracie's drawing on the table and the list of spare parts on the counter, and the boiler running again downstairs, steady and quiet.You took the drawing.You put it on the refrigerator with a lobster-shaped magnet that had been there since at least 2009.You weren't quite sure why.You didn't ask yourself the question.
The storm arrived on Wednesday without warning, without warning you at least. Lou seemed to have known since the day before, and Gracie too, and probably everyone in Hartwell who lived close enough to the water to read the sky like a familiar text.You found out when the rain started at seven in the morning and didn't stop.You stayed in Marge's house until noon. You went through two cupboards, fixed the banging shutter with strong adhesive tape you'd found in Marge's tool drawer, a temporary solution, an effective one, and reread the same chapter of your book three times without retaining a word.
At noon you went to the End of the Dock.It was busy for a Wednesday, fishermen whose outings had been cancelled, two or three faces you didn't recognize, and him at the far end of the counter with a coffee and something that looked like paperwork.Gracie wasn't there.You sat at the other end of the counter. Lou brought you a soda without you asking.
"How long will the storm last?" you asked.
"Until tomorrow morning." He looked toward the window. "Good storm. Not dangerous, just persistent."
"Poetic."
"I'm full of surprises."
You drank your soda. The rain hit the window steadily. Someone had put on music, something old, a radio, not a playlist, and it gave the bar that particular quality of places that don't try to be anything other than what they are.
"Where's Gracie?" you asked Lou, because the child's absence was almost as notable as her presence.
"School. She finishes at three."
"There's a school here?"
"Small one. Eight kids. The teacher comes from Rockport."
You nodded. You were watching the rain.
"You look bored," said a voice to your left.
You turned your head.He had moved his paperwork. He was now two stools closer, without you having heard him move.
"I'm not bored," you said. "I'm watching the rain."
"Same thing."
"It's not the same thing." You looked at his coffee. "Your outing got cancelled?"
"All outings until tomorrow."
"That's bad for business."
"It's the weather." He shrugged one shoulder. "It happens."
A silence. Not uncomfortable, just present, the kind that arrives between two people who haven't yet found the register that suits them.
"Do your customers complain?"
"Sometimes. People who come for a weekend and were counting on fishing Saturday."
"Do you refund them?"
"I reschedule if I can. If I can't, I refund." He drank his coffee. "It's in the terms."
"Do you have many regulars?"
He looked at you sideways, not suspicious, just surprised, as if it wasn't the question he was expecting.
"A few. People from Rockport, from Portland. A guy from Boston who comes every summer, three years running."
"Boston," you repeated.
"Yeah."
"I live in Boston."
"I know."
You looked at him.
"Gracie," he said simply.
"Obviously."
Something in his expression shifted, not a smile, just a lightening, like a tension releasing one notch.
"Did she tell you anything else about me?" you asked.
"That you liked crabs. Well, eating them."
"Looking depends on the crab."
"That's what she said."
Lou was moving behind the counter with the air of someone who didn't want to intrude but was listening anyway.You talked about the weather a little longer, not because it was fascinating, but because it was neutral, ground on which neither of you had a position to defend. He explained how he read the sky in the morning before an outing, the signs that didn't lie, what clouds to the west meant in summer versus autumn. He talked about it with a calm precision that wasn't pedagogical, he wasn't teaching you something, he was just saying what he knew.You listened.It wasn't something you had planned to do.
"Did you grow up near the water?" you asked.
"No. Brooklyn."
"How do you get from Brooklyn to Hartwell?"
A silence. Not long, two seconds maybe, but perceptible.
"Rebecca was from here," he said. "We came to spend a summer. We stayed."
He'd said it with the economy of someone who has learned to summarize a complex story in one sentence, so as not to have to say more.You didn't ask more.
"What's Hartwell like in winter?" you said instead.
He looked at you, and something in his gaze said he'd noticed you hadn't followed the thread, and that it was fine.
"Quiet," he said. "The people who stay for winter are the ones who like it that way."
"And you like it."
"I like Hartwell."
"That's not the same thing."
He thought about it seriously, as if it deserved a real answer.
"No," he said. "It's not the same thing. But both are true."
Gracie arrived at twenty past three with her backpack and her dripping yellow raincoat, she pushed the bar door open with both hands and she saw you before she'd even taken off her hood.
"You're here!" she said, as if it were a planned surprise.
"It's raining," you answered. "I came to get dry."
"We came to get dry too." She looked at her father. "We're the same."
"We're not the same," he said.
"We're both here."
"That doesn't mean we're the same."
"It means we had the same idea."
He looked at the ceiling with the expression of a man who had this conversation several times a week and had stopped trying to win it.Gracie climbed onto the stool between you two, the empty one, exactly in the middle, with the satisfaction of a child taking her rightful place.
"I want a hot chocolate," she announced to Lou.
"Please," said her father without looking at her.
"Please Lou."
"There we go," said Lou.
She turned to you.
"What did you do today?"
"I fixed a shutter."
"By yourself?"
"With adhesive tape."
She thought about it.
"My dad would have used real tools."
"Your dad has real tools."
"That's true," she admitted. She looked at her hot chocolate arriving. "Do you have tools?"
"Not here."
"We can lend you some."
"Gracie," said her father.
"What? We have lots of tools." She blew on her chocolate. "It's normal to lend things."
You looked at the profile of this man beside his daughter, the way he wasn't smiling but something around his eyes was less closed than an hour before, and you thought that Lou might have been right about certain things without needing to say them.The rain kept going outside.You stayed until five.
It happened on a Thursday evening, by accident.He had left to pick up Gracie from a friend's house, he'd said that on the way out, briefly, to Lou, not to you, and you'd stayed at the bar because you didn't feel like going back to Marge's house and looking at the gutter.Lou wiped the counter. He set a glass in front of you. He looked at you with the expression of someone who has something to say and is just waiting for the right moment.
"Say what you have to say," you said.
"I didn't say anything."
"You were about to."
"I was just observing you."
"That's worse."
He smiled. He put his elbows on the counter.
"Rebecca," he said. "Had you heard of her?"
You took a sip of your soda.
"A little. We'd cross paths in summer at school. We didn't really know each other."
"She was good." He said it simply, like a fact. "Luminous. The kind of person who made places more alive just by being there."
He looked at the counter.
"James met her here, one summer. He must have been twenty-six. She was twenty-four. He left for Brooklyn in September and came back in October."
"For her."
"For her." He lifted his head. "He didn't hesitate. He's the kind of man who decides and does.When she got sick, he stopped everything. The work in New York, the plans, everything. He spent two years just being there."
You said nothing.
"Gracie was three when Rebecca died," Lou continued. "Three and a half."
He unhooked a glass from the rack above him, started wiping it for no particular reason.
"She remembers her mother. Not everything. But things. Sometimes she says something and James gets that look, you know the kind, like someone has pressed on something."
"Does he show it?"
"No. That's why you need to know him to see it."
You looked at the window. Outside Hartwell was getting on with its Thursday evening, a few cars, the lighthouse in the distance, the black water under the sky.
"Why are you telling me this?" you asked.
Lou set down the glass.
"Because you seem like someone who prefers to know," he said. "And because he'll never say anything about himself unless you ask. And if you ask he'll say the minimum."
He shrugged.
"It's just useful to have the context."
"Context for what?"
"Nothing in particular. To understand why he is the way he is."
"How is he?"
Lou thought seriously about the question.
"Solid," he said. "But the kind of solid that cost something."
He picked up his cloth again.
"He's a good father. Really good. Gracie is happy, she's stable, she wants for nothing. He's built something here.But sometimes I look at him and I think he's put so much energy into staying upright that he's forgotten to check whether he still likes it."
You said nothing for a moment.
"Is that an observation or a worry?" you asked.
"Both."
You thought that word sounded familiar.He came back at eight with Gracie asleep on his shoulder, truly asleep, deeply, the way children sleep when they've spent everything they had and have nothing left to give. He was also carrying her backpack and her coat on the same arm, with the automatic balance of someone who has done this hundreds of times.He saw you.Something crossed his face, not surprise, more a reconfiguration, like someone adjusting their settings.
"She fell asleep in the car," he said quietly so as not to wake her.
"I see."
"I just came to say good night to Lou."
"Good night Lou," said Lou from the kitchen without appearing.
He looked at his sleeping daughter. He looked at the bar. There was something particular in his expression, not embarrassment, more that sharp awareness of people who aren't used to being seen in ordinary moments.
"I'll put her to bed," he said.
"Go ahead."
He didn't move right away.
"Did she tell you about her drawing?" he asked.
"Which one? She made me three drawings."
Something shifted around his eyes.
"The first one. The one with the house."
"Yes. It's on Marge's fridge."
A silence.
"She does that," he said. "With people she likes." He looked at Gracie. "She decides quickly."
"I see that."
"It's not a flaw."
"I didn't say it was."
"No." He adjusted Gracie on his shoulder. "Just saying."
You watched him carry his sleeping daughter, with her backpack and her coat and that way he had of holding it all without making a show of it, and you thought about what Lou had just told you, solid, but the kind of solid that cost something, and you found it was an exact description.
"Good night," you said.
"Good night."
He left.Lou came out of the kitchen with a bowl he set in front of you.
"You haven't eaten," he said.
"What is it?"
"Clam chowder. Leftover from tonight."
You ate the clam chowder without protesting.Lou wiped the counter in silence for a moment.
"He looked at you," he said.
"He was looking at Gracie."
"He looked at you first."
"Lou."
"Just saying what I saw."
"This is a bar, not a therapist's office."
"I can be both."
You finished your soup. You put down the spoon.
"He seems lonely," you said despite yourself.
Lou didn't answer. He just wiped the counter.Which was an answer in itself.You walked back to Marge's house under a sky that had stopped raining but hadn't yet decided whether it would start again. The air smelled of tide and wet earth. The dock was empty at this hour, the boats moored, their red and green navigation lights reflected in the black water.You looked at the charter moored at the far end, Barnes Fishing Co., painted in white on the hull, clean and maintained with that same economical attention he put into everything.You thought about a six-year-old girl who made drawings for people she liked and who decided quickly.You thought that quick decisions might be hereditary in this family. That maybe he decided quickly too, except that for three years he had learned not to.You went into Marge's house.You looked at the drawing on the fridge.Three figures in front of a house with blue flowers.You went to bed.
Sam arrived on a Friday afternoon in a rental car too large for Hartwell, which he parked diagonally in the dock parking lot with the nonchalance of someone who had never had a parking problem in their life.You saw him from the terrace of the End of the Dock where you were reading, or holding a book, which wasn't exactly the same thing.He got out of the car. He looked at the dock. He looked at the water. He smiled the way someone does when they arrive somewhere they like and don't need to say so out loud.Then he saw you.His smile didn't change but it took on a different shade, more attentive, more calculating, the kind of smile of someone filing away a piece of information carefully.He crossed the parking lot.
"You must be the girl from Marge's house," he said.
"And you must be Sam."
"Did Gracie tell you about me?"
"Lou."
"Both probably." He held out his hand. "Sam Wilson."
You shook it. He had a frank handshake, the kind that has nothing to prove.
"Where is he?" you asked.
"On the boat. He's finishing a trip." He looked at the book on the table. "How long have you been here?"
"Three weeks."
"And you're planning to stay until?"
"Early August."
He nodded slowly, with the air of someone doing a calculation.
"Sit down if you want," you said, because standing there while he calculated something about you was slightly uncomfortable.
He sat down.Lou brought him a beer without him asking, they clearly knew each other well enough that ordering was unnecessary, and Sam looked at the dock with the calm of someone who never needs to fill silence.
"Is he doing well?" you asked.
Sam looked at you.
"James."
"I don't see who else you'd be talking about," he said.
He drank his beer.
"He's doing. It's complicated to know whether that means anything, with him."
"Why?"
"Because doing well for him is a pretty wide spectrum. He can be doing well and be completely beside himself at the same time."
"That's a way to describe someone."
"It's an exact way." He put down his beer. "Lou told me you two get along."
"Lou exaggerates."
"Lou observes. That's different." He watched you with quiet attention. "What did he tell you about Rebecca?"
"Nothing."
"That's what I thought." He looked at the water. "He doesn't talk about that with people he doesn't know well. And with people he knows well he doesn't talk about it either because he doesn't want to weigh them down."
"So who does he talk to about it?"
"Nobody." A pause. "Well, Gracie sometimes. In her way."
You put your book on the table.
"Doesn't it bother you, telling me all this?" you asked.
Sam thought about it honestly.
"No," he said. "Because you seem like someone who would do something useful with the information. And because he'll never say it himself."
"Do something useful like what exactly?"
"Like nothing specific. Like just, be there without pretending everything's fine when it isn't."
You looked at the dock. The charter was coming back in the distance, you recognized the hull now, Barnes Fishing Co. in white on the side.
"Does he know you're here?" you asked.
"I sent him a message this morning. He replied ok."
"That's enthusiastic."
"That's him being enthusiastic. Ok from him is roughly I was thinking about you and I'm glad you're coming."
You looked at Sam. He looked at you with those eyes that clearly saw a great deal.
"What," you said.
"Nothing. Just observing."
"Do you have a habit of observing things out loud?"
"Only when it's useful."
He arrived thirty minutes later, with Gracie on his heels who had spent the afternoon at her friend Célia's and had made it to the dock at the exact moment the charter came in, as if she had an internal clock calibrated to her father's outings.He saw Sam. Something opened in his face, really opened, in a way you hadn't yet seen from him, a direct and unguarded warmth that said this man was someone important.They shook hands and grabbed each other's shoulder at the same time, that brief, solid gesture of people who have known each other a long time and don't need to do more.
"You're late," said Sam.
"I have customers."
"You always have customers. That's an excuse."
"It's my job."
"Technically—"
"Sam."
"Ok." Sam looked at Gracie. "Hey beautiful."
"Uncle Sammy." She jumped on him with the enthusiasm of a child who reserved that kind of welcome for very few people. "Did you bring candy?"
"In the car."
"Which ones?"
"The red ones you like."
“Tagada strawberries?”
“Tagada strawberries.”
She ran off toward the rental car. He watched her go with that smile, the real one, not the polite smile, and something in his expression said this child had loved him for a long time and it was mutual.Then he looked at you.
"Did she talk to you?" he asked Sam.
"We chatted," said Sam.
"About what?"
"Hartwell. Fishing. The weather."
They looked at each other with the economy of two people communicating in a register you didn't have the full vocabulary for.
"I'm going to get changed," he said.
He went to his car.Sam drank his beer.
"He looked at you last," he said.
"So?"
"With him that's the reverse order. He usually looks at the exits first."
You didn't answer.Sam smiled into his beer.
That evening there were four of you at the End of the Dock, you, him, Sam, and Gracie who was gradually falling asleep on the bench beside her father with her half-eaten Fraises Tagada in her hand.Sam was talking, easily, naturally, he had that gift of making conversations light without emptying them of substance. He was telling a story about Washington, about an absurd situation at work, and you were listening and laughing and at some point you looked up and he was looking at you.Not Sam. The other one.He was watching the way you laughed.He looked away immediately, not abruptly, just gently, like someone putting something back in its place, and he looked at Sam and said something about the Washington story that was pretending to be a response.But you had seen.And Sam had seen that you had seen, because Sam saw everything, and he continued his story without smiling but with that something around his eyes.Gracie slid off the bench in her sleep and he caught her without looking, an automatic and gentle gesture, and he tucked her against him with one hand in her hair.You looked at your glass.Lou, from the counter, had been wiping a glass for five minutes that didn't need it.
The dock festival took place every last Saturday in July since Lou had taken over the bar, he had explained this to Sam the evening before with the discreet pride of someone who has created a tradition and doesn't want to make too much of it.Tables outside on the terrace, string lights between the posts, a group of three musicians set up in the corner, guitar, double bass, accordion, playing a mix of folk and old coastal jazz that nobody could have properly named but that went well with the evening air and the smell of the sea.You had arrived with Marge on the phone in your ear.
"You're outside," she had said. "I can hear the wind."
"The dock festival."
"Ah." A pleased silence. "Are you going with someone?"
"I'm going to the bar Marge, it's not a social event."
"Everything is a social event if you choose to see it that way."
"Good night Marge."
"Give Lou a kiss from me."
You had hung up.Gracie had found you in thirty seconds, she had that radar for people she had decided to adopt, and she had taken your hand without asking to bring you closer to the string lights, as if you hadn't been able to see them from where you were standing.
"Lou put them up," she had explained. "Every year. He climbs up the stepladder by himself and my dad holds the stepladder because Lou isn't steady on it."
"Lou isn't steady on a stepladder?"
"He says it's because of his knees. My dad says it's because he looks at his phone at the same time."
"Who's right?"
She had thought about it seriously.
"Both probably."
You had smiled.She had let go of your hand to go toward Sam who was arriving with two glasses and the expression of someone who found the situation generally satisfying.The evening had that particular quality of summer evenings on the coast, the air just cool enough to feel good, the light from the string lights making everything slightly golden, the music present enough to cover the silences without filling them completely.You had talked with people you didn't know, Hartwell residents who knew Marge, who knew who you were, who asked polite questions about Boston and talked about the summer with the familiarity of people for whom summer wasn't a vacation but just the warm season.He was there, on the periphery of all of it, not isolated, he knew everyone, but holding back all the same, with that way of occupying spaces without claiming them.Sam was beside you when you watched him talking with an old fisherman whose name you didn't know.
"He's good here," said Sam.
"I see that."
"No I mean, he's good here specifically. In places where people have known him for a long time." He took a sip. "Elsewhere he doesn't quite know what to do with himself."
"And here he does?"
"Here he has Gracie. He has Lou. He has the charter." A pause. "It's enough to stay upright. But staying upright isn't the same as living."
You didn't answer because you didn't know what to answer and Sam wasn't really expecting one, he was observing, as always.Gracie fell asleep around ten.Not in her bed, on the bar bench, curled up on her jacket folded into a pillow, with her Fraises Tagada in her hand and the music from the three musicians still going outside. He had watched her fall asleep with that particular attention of parents who know exactly the moment it tips over, and he had laid his jacket over her without making a sound.The musicians had changed register.Something slower, a waltz maybe, or something that resembled one, with the accordion in the foreground and the double bass underneath like a pulse.On the terrace, two or three couples had stood up.Lou had looked at the scene. He had looked at Gracie asleep. He had looked at the terrace. He had said, loudly enough for everyone to hear but in the tone of someone just making an observation:
"Shame to leave a slow dance without dancers."
Gracie had opened one eye, just one, from her bench.
"Dad has to dance," she had said in a sleepy but surprisingly firm voice.
"Gracie—"
"With her." She had pointed in your direction without lifting her head. "It's polite."
"It's not a question of politeness—"
"Yes it is." She had closed her eye again. "Grandma Kowalski says refusing to dance is rude."
Sam was looking at the ceiling with the expression of someone trying very hard not to smile.You had looked at the man across from you. He was looking at you with something between resignation and something else you couldn't have named.
"Does your grandmother really say that?" he had asked.
"Marge says a lot of things," you had answered.
"Is that a yes or a no?"
"It's a if you don't want to we don't have to."
A silence.
"I'd like to," he had said.
On the terrace, under the string lights, with the double bass and the accordion and the air that smelled of salt and grilled mussels that Lou was making in the kitchen, you danced.Not spectacularly, neither of you was a dancer, it showed, but it didn't matter because it wasn't a competition. It was just two people moving slowly in the same space, with one hand in the other's and the other somewhere on a shoulder or a waist, and the music lasting as long as it lasted.He wasn't looking at you directly, he was looking slightly above, or to the side, the way people do when they don't yet know where to put their eyes in a new situation.You were doing the same.
"Gracie is going to be pleased," you said, because saying something was simpler than the silence.
"She's been manipulating everyone for six years," he said. "She's very good at it."
"It works."
"Yes."
A silence. The music kept going.
"Do you normally know how to dance?" he asked.
"Not really. You?"
"No."
"We're managing anyway."
"We're managing."
The hand on your waist had moved one centimeter, not intentionally, just the natural movement of someone adjusting their balance, and you were imperceptibly closer than at the beginning.Neither of you stepped back.The music stopped.You separated with the same quiet neutrality you had brought to drawing closer, not abruptly, not with embarrassment, just naturally, like two people who had gone somewhere together and were coming back.
"Thank you," you said.
"You're welcome."
Inside, through the window, you could see Sam looking elsewhere with far too much deliberateness.On the way out that evening, Sam had caught up with you in the parking lot.
"He talked to me about you," he had said.
You had stopped.
"When?"
"This morning. While he was getting the boat ready." He had his hands in his pockets, he was looking at the dock. "He didn't say anything specific. He just mentioned your name twice without me asking."
"That's all?"
"With him that's a lot."
You had looked at the Barnes Fishing Co. moored at the end of the dock, its navigation lights in the dark.
"I go back to Boston in three weeks," you had said.
"I know." Sam had looked at you. "I'm not telling you what to do with that. I'm just saying what I observed."
He had gone back to the bar.You had walked to Marge's house in the silence of Hartwell at midnight, the crickets, the water, the wind in the pines, with the hand that had held his still slightly aware of itself.Three weeks.You didn't quite know what to do with that either.
The real storm arrived on a Tuesday evening.Not the small one from last Wednesday, that one had been persistent but domestic, the kind you waited out under a roof with a coffee. This one was different. You had felt it coming in the afternoon, in the way the sky had gradually changed color, from pale blue to grey-green, and in the wind that had picked up around five with an intention that Hartwell's wind didn't usually have.Lou had sent you a message at six.
Get home before eight. It's going to hit hard.
You had gotten back at seven-thirty.The power went out at eight ten.You had found Marge's candles in the bottom kitchen drawer, she had an impressive collection, the kind of woman who prepared for disasters with absolute serenity, and you had lit the three biggest ones on the counter.Then you had heard the noise.Not the wind, not the rain, something more localized, a cracking in the back wall, where the gutter had been hanging since you arrived. You had taken a candle and gone to look.Water was coming in.Not much, not yet, but the gutter had given way under the weight of the rain and the water was running down the outside wall and finding its way in through the corner of the hallway window.You had looked at it for ten seconds.You had taken your phone.Lou wasn't answering, he was probably at the bar with a dozen people waiting for it to pass. You had searched your contacts. You didn't have his number. You had sent a message to Lou:
water coming in north side, gutter, what do I do.
The reply had come two minutes later.
Call Barnes. I'm sending him your number.
Thirty seconds after that, your phone had rung.
"Where exactly?" he had asked without preamble.
"Back hallway. Corner of the window on the north side."
"Do you have towels?"
"Yes."
"Put them against the edge of the window for now. I'm coming."
"You don't have to—"
"I'm coming," he had repeated, and he had hung up.
You had put down the towels.He arrived twenty minutes later soaked from shoulder to foot, with a headlamp on his forehead and a toolbox in his hand, and Gracie asleep in his arms.You had opened the door.
"She was asleep," he had said before you could ask. "I couldn't leave her alone."
"Of course."
"Can I put her somewhere?"
You had led him to the living room sofa. He had laid Gracie down with an economy of movement that said he had done it hundreds of times in less practical circumstances, she hadn't stirred, sunk into that deep sleep of children that nothing disturbs.He had looked at the hallway.
"Show me."
He had worked in the hallway for forty minutes with his headlamp and his tools, while the rain kept hammering the windows and the wind made the shutters vibrate, and you had stayed nearby because holding the extra lamp was useful and not because you wanted to stay nearby.He didn't talk much while working. Occasional requests, pass me the tape, hold that, and the rest in silence, a working silence, focused and without discomfort.At one point his elbow had brushed your shoulder and neither of you had moved back, and you had kept holding the lamp as if nothing had happened because nothing had happened, objectively.
"It'll hold until tomorrow," he had said, putting his tools away. "The gutter will need to be properly fixed."
"I know. Lou told me about the gutter."
"Lou says a lot of things."
"He observes."
He had looked at you with something that resembled amusement, discreet and brief.
"What else did he tell you?"
"Things."
"Useful things?"
You had thought honestly.
"Yes," you had said.
He had nodded, not to approve, just to register.In the kitchen, you had made tea because it was something to do and because he was soaked and offering tea to someone soaked was the most elementary thing in the world.He had accepted without protesting, which was in itself notable.You had sat at Marge's table with your cups, and the storm outside, and the candle between you, and Gracie asleep on the sofa in the other room whose steady breathing you could hear in the silence.
"When do you go back to Boston?" he had asked.
"In two weeks."
He had drunk his tea.
"Marge will be alone."
"She manages. She always manages."
"I know." A pause. "I used to check in on her from time to time. Before you arrived. After too if you want."
You had looked at him.
"Did she ask you to?"
"No." He had looked at his cup. "It's Hartwell. People do that."
"You were raised in Brooklyn."
"I learned it here."
The candle cast a light that moved slightly with the drafts and made the shadows unsteady. The rain on the roof had something regular about it now, less rage, just persistence.
"Did Rebecca teach you that?" you had asked.
It had come out without you quite having decided it. You had felt the risk of the question in your mouth half a second too late to take it back.He hadn't changed expression. But he had taken a breath slightly longer than the ones before.
"Rebecca taught me a lot of things," he had said.
"I'm sorry. I didn't mean to—"
"No." He had looked up at you. "It's good to be able to talk about it."
A silence.
"You don't talk about it often," you had said quietly.
"No."
"Why?"
He had thought about it. Really thought, not to find a way to deflect, to find the exact answer.
"Because people don't know what to do with it. They make a face. Or they say things that are well-intentioned but useless."
He had looked at the candle flame.
"And then I end up putting them at ease about something that concerns me."
"That's exhausting."
"Yes."
"So you say nothing."
"So I say nothing."
You had drunk your tea. Outside the wind had dropped a notch, not finished, just less urgent.
"You miss her," you had said.
"Every day," he had said. "Differently than before. At first it was sharp. Now it's more, present. Like something that's part of the landscape."
"Is that better or worse?"
"It's different. Both at the same time."
You had nodded.
"Does Gracie look like her?" you had asked.
And something had really opened in his face, not pain, something more complex, softer and heavier at the same time.
"In the way she decides quickly," he had said. "And in the laugh. She has exactly her laugh."
He had said it with a tenderness that wasn't trying to hide itself, and you had thought that maybe it was the first time you had seen him without any defenses at all, just there, at Marge's table with his tea and the storm outside and his daughter asleep in the other room.
"That's good," you had said quietly. "That she has her laugh."
He had looked at you.
"Yes," he had said. "It is."
You had talked some more, not long, nothing grand, just what came naturally when you were tired of maintaining distances and the storm made distances less defensible. You had talked to him about Boston, about your work, about why you had come back to Hartwell beyond Marge. He had listened in that way he had of listening, completely, without preparing his answer at the same time.At some point the candle had burned lower and you had moved slightly closer without noticing, the way you do around sources of light.
"You should have left before the storm," you had said.
"Probably."
"The road is bad now."
"Yes."
A silence.
"You have a sofa," he had said. "If that's not a problem."
You had looked at the living room sofa where Gracie was sleeping.
"There's the back bedroom," you had said. "The bed is made."
"The sofa is fine."
"The back bedroom is better."
He had looked at you for a second.
"Alright," he had said.
You woke up with something heavy on your feet.It took you a second to realize it was Gracie,she’d migrated from the living room couch to your bed during the night, with the unstoppable logic of children who go where it’s warm, and she was sleeping across your ankles like a cat pleased with herself.You looked up at the ceiling.You looked beside you.He was there.Not in the bed—on the bedspread, fully dressed, with one arm folded under his head. He must have come to check on Gracie during the night and fallen asleep there without meaning to, or perhaps half-intentionally, in that liminal state between wakefulness and sleep where parents apparently lived permanently.His shoulder was touching yours.Not much just the light touch of two people who had occupied the same space during the night and whose bodies had done what bodies do, which is to seek warmth.You hadn’t moved.Gracie had woken up ten minutes later with the energy of a child who had no memory of having moved and who found the situation she was in perfectly natural.
She had looked at both of you.She had said:
“Good.”
Just that. Good. With the quiet satisfaction of a general inspecting a position and finding it satisfactory.Then she had jumped out of bed and headed for the kitchen. He had woken up at the sound—his eyes open immediately, without transition, the way parents wake up and he had looked at the ceiling, then at Gracie disappearing down the hallway, then at you.
“She’s wandered off,” you’d said.
“She always does that.”
“At your place too?”
“Every night.”
“And do you wander off too?”
He’d looked at you. Something in his eyes said he knew exactly where he was and how he’d ended up there, and that he had no explanation to offer that wouldn’t be the real explanation.
“Apparently,” he had said.
From the kitchen came the sound of Gracie opening the fridge with the determination of someone who was hungry and was going to take care of it herself. You had gotten up.The morning after the storm had that particular quality of mornings that follow something intense—the air washed clean, the sky an almost offensive blue, the dock still glistening with the night’s water. Hartwell seemed to have been rinsed and put back in place.Gracie was eating cereal at Marge’s table with the drawing she’d made three weeks earlier still on the fridge above her, and she was looking out the window at the garden with the satisfaction of someone who found the world, on the whole, well-ordered.You were making coffee.He was standing by the window, looking out at the dock—the charter boat was intact; you’d seen him check that first from the window, that automatic reflex.
“It held up,” you’d said.
“It’s still holding up.”
“You’re still worried, though.”
“Always.”
Gracie had looked up from her cereal.
“Dad checks the boat first thing in the morning,” she’d said. “Before he even looks at his phone.”
“I know,” you’d said.
“How do you know?”
“I watch.”
She’d looked at her father. She’d looked at you. She’d gone back to her cereal with an expression that said this information satisfied her.You’d set a cup of coffee in front of him without asking. He’d taken it without asking either that natural, unceremonious gesture of people who were starting to settle into a space.Your fingers had brushed against each other over the cup.Neither of you had commented.After tea, silence had settled like a warm blanket—not heavy, just there. You’d set your cup in the sink. So had he. Your movements fell into sync without either of you saying a word.
Gracie was breathing softly in the living room, still asleep on the couch, one arm dangling, cheek squashed against Marge’s floral cushion. Early-afternoon light filtered through the window, golden, almost too gentle for reality.He came up behind you—not to wrap his arms around you right away. Just to be there. His chest against your back, hands planted on either side of the sink, caging you without trapping you. You felt his breath in your hair, steady, just a little faster than usual.He turned your face toward him with one finger under your chin—gentle, but firm. He kissed you. Slowly. Almost painfully slowly. His lips brushed yours, lingered, came back, like someone tasting something they know is fragile.You slid a hand to the back of his neck. He let out a soft growl against your mouth—a low, almost involuntary sound.Then he pulled back just enough to look at you. His eyes were darker than usual, almost black in the kitchen light.
“Not here,” he murmured. “Not with her in the next room.”
You nodded.
“I know.”
But neither of you moved.
He rested his forehead against yours.
“Come tonight. My place. After she’s asleep.”
“What if she wakes up?”
“She sleeps like a rock after a big day. I’ve got the baby monitor.”
You smiled despite yourself.
“You’ve thought of everything.”
“No. I’m terrible at improvising.”
He kissed you once more—brief, almost chaste—then straightened. He went to get Gracie from the living room, lifting her with the ease that spoke of hundreds of nights carrying her while she slept. She mumbled something unintelligible, curled into his shoulder without opening her eyes.
He looked at you over her head.
“Nine thirty. My place. If you want.”
“I’ll come.”
He gave a single nod. Then he left, the little girl in his arms, the screen door closing softly behind them.
The rest of the afternoon dragged. You tidied Marge’s kitchen, washed the cups, folded the blanket where Gracie had slept. You stood at the window looking out at the garden drenched in light, the hydrangeas still bowed under yesterday’s rain but refusing to break. You thought about Boston. The noisy streets, the lights that drowned out the stars, the nights you came home alone to an apartment that was too quiet.And you thought about him. The way he filled space without ever crowding it. About Gracie deciding things with the certainty of children who haven’t yet learned doubt.At nine twenty-five you put on a light coat, locked Marge’s door, and walked to his place. Ten minutes along the coastal path. The night was clear, stars visible despite the few dock lamps. You heard the waves before you saw his house—small gray wooden building, faded blue shutters, warm light glowing in the living-room window.He opened the door before you knocked. He must have been watching.
“She asleep?” you asked quietly.
“Half an hour now. Baby monitor on.”
He closed the door behind you. The living room was small, cozy, cluttered with hastily tidied toys, a blanket thrown over the couch, an open book lying upside-down on the coffee table. Photos on the walls—Rebecca smiling with baby Gracie, a younger James on a boat, captured moments without pretense.He didn’t turn on the overhead light. Just the side lamp that threw soft shadows.He looked at you for a long moment without speaking, as though making sure you had really come, that you hadn’t changed your mind.Then he took one step. His hand slid to the back of your neck—not rough, just sure—and he kissed you.It was different from Marge’s kitchen. There it had been restrained, careful. Here, in his house, he let go a little more. His mouth was demanding without being harsh—lips pressing, tongue seeking yours, a low growl vibrating against your lips when you answered. You wrapped your arms around his neck, fingers in his still-damp hair.
He lifted you without effort—your legs wound around his waist as though your body already knew the motion. He carried you to his bedroom without breaking the kiss, kicking the door shut behind you. The room was simple: king-size bed with gray sheets, a dresser cluttered with framed photos, an open window letting in the night and the distant sound of waves.He set you on the bed, stood to yank his t-shirt off in one sharp motion. His chest bore the marks of physical work—thin scars along the ribs, sun- and salt-faded tattoos, muscles taut but not bulky.He leaned over you, pulled your sweater over your head. Your bra followed—unhooked one-handed without looking, like someone who had done that gesture hundreds of times in another life. He cupped one breast in his calloused palm, thumb on the nipple, pinched just enough to make you gasp sharply. Then he lowered his head and took it into his mouth—hot tongue, strong suction, teeth grazing without really biting.You arched, hands in his hair. A moan slipped out—not loud, but enough for him to lift his head and look at you.
“Shh,” he whispered against your skin. “Not too loud.”
You nodded, biting your lip.He drew your jeans and panties down together, slowly, as though memorizing every inch of skin he uncovered. When you were bare, he paused for a second to look—really look. Breath a little ragged, eyes dark.
“You’re beautiful,” he said, voice low, almost hoarse.
He shed his jeans and boxers. His cock was hard, thick, the head already glistening. He settled between your thighs, rubbed slowly against your entrance without pushing in, just letting you feel the pressure.
“Look at me.”
You opened your eyes.
“You sure?”
“Yes.”
He pushed in. Slowly. Very slowly. You felt the stretch, the sweet-deep burn. He was big. You moaned long and low, nails digging into his shoulders.He stopped halfway, forehead against yours, breathing hard.
“You okay?”
“Keep going… please…”
He sank to the hilt in one controlled thrust. You cried out softly—not in pain, just too much, too many sensations at once. He stayed still for a moment, letting your body adjust, hands braced on either side of your head.
“Fuck… you’re so tight…” he breathed.
Then he began to move. At first slow, deep, almost torturous. Every withdrawal left you almost empty, every thrust filled you again. You felt everything: the vein dragging against your sensitive spot, the pressure against your clit each time he bottomed out, the way your walls clung to him.He gradually sped up. The strokes grew harder. The bed creaked beneath you. The headboard tapped the wall at a steady rhythm, but not too loud—he was careful.He caught both your wrists in one hand, pinned them above your head.
“Keep them there,” he said, voice rough.
You obeyed.He slid his other hand under your thigh, hooked it higher against his side. The new angle was devastating. Every thrust hit exactly where you needed.You moaned his name.
“Again,” he growled. “Say it again.”
“James…”
He lost rhythm for a second a harder, almost sloppy thrust. Then he found it again, deeper, stronger.
“You feel so fucking good like this…” he murmured against your ear, voice low and gravelly. “So perfect… take it all…”
The words made you clench around him. He swore under his breath, a low, frustrated sound.
“Do that again.”
You did. On purpose.
He sped up even more, hips snapping against yours. You felt the sweat on his back, on your stomach, between you. Your second orgasm hit without warning violent, legs shaking, body arching under him. You cried out not loud, but enough that he pressed a hand over your mouth, not to smother, just to muffle the sound.He followed almost right after—a low, guttural groan, hips driving deep one last time as he came inside you, hot, thick, pulsing hard.He collapsed onto you, dead weight for a few seconds, breath harsh against your neck. Then he rolled to the side, pulled you against him without a word.You stayed like that a long time. Skin to skin. Sweat mingling. Heartbeats slowly calming.
Afterward, you had been in the kitchen again.He was making tea.
"I go back to Boston in two weeks," you had said.
"I know."
"Don't you have anything to say about that?"
He had put down the kettle. He had turned toward you.
"What would you want me to say?"
"I don't know. Something."
A silence. He had looked at you with that direct attention he had, the kind that didn't try to deflect.
"Do you want to leave?" he had asked.
You had thought honestly.
"Less than before," you had said.
"Is that good or complicated?"
"Both."
He had made a brief, almost imperceptible movement of his head, like someone recognizing an answer they had given themselves in another conversation.
"Boston is five hours by road," he had said.
"I can count."
"I'm just saying it's not the moon."
You had looked at him. He was looking at you with his clear eyes and that quiet way of being there that asked for nothing and said everything at the same time.
"Are you trying to tell me something?" you had asked.
"I'm saying that five hours by road isn't the moon."
"That's all?"
"For now."
You had drunk your tea. He had too. Outside Marge's garden was still glistening from the night and the hydrangeas looked like they had survived the storm without damage, which suited them.
"Gracie is going to be pleased," you had said.
"Gracie is always pleased when things go the way she decided they would."
"She had decided this?"
"She made a drawing with three people in front of the house on the second day." He had looked at the fridge. "Gracie decides quickly."
"It's hereditary," you had said quietly.
He had looked at you.He hadn't answered.But he hadn't denied it either.Marge had come home on a Thursday morning with her cane, her rolling suitcase and an opinion on everything you had done to the house during her absence.
"The gutter," she had said from the path, looking at the north side.
"It's been temporarily repaired. He's coming back Friday to do it properly."
"He." She had said it with a neutrality too perfect to be innocent. "Barnes."
"He was here during the storm. He sealed the corner."
"The Tuesday storm."
"Yes."
"And he stayed."
You had taken her suitcase without answering.
"I'm not saying it's bad," Marge had said behind you as she came into the house. "I'm just saying I notice."
"You have a habit of noticing things out loud."
"Lou too. Same school."
You had put the suitcase in her room. She had gone around the living room with the meticulous attention of someone looking for what had changed. She had stopped in front of the fridge.She had looked at Gracie's drawing.She had said nothing, which was worse than anything she could have said.You had eaten lunch together at the small kitchen table, with the window open onto the garden and the hydrangeas which had indeed survived everything, and Marge had told you about her rehabilitation with the detail of a war correspondent, the physiotherapist who had hands that were too cold, the man at the end of the corridor who watched television too loudly, the Friday menu which was the establishment's only real success.You had listened with the simple pleasure of listening to someone you loved recount ordinary things.
"Is he doing well?" she had asked at some point, between the physiotherapist and the man at the end of the corridor.
"Who?"
She had looked at you.
"Marge."
"I'm asking a question."
"You said he without specifying who."
"You understood who I was talking about."
You had drunk your coffee.
"He's doing well," you had said.
"And Gracie?"
"Gracie is always doing well. Gracie is a force of nature."
Marge had smiled, not the smile that tried to hold itself back, the real one, the one she kept for things that truly pleased her.
"Rebecca was just like that at that age," she had said. "Exactly like that."
She had looked at her plate.
"I knew her since she was little. Her mother and I were friends." A pause. "When she got sick I prayed he would hold on. For Gracie. For him." She had looked up at you. "He held on."
"I know."
"He's a good person."
"I know Marge."
"Just saying."
"You never just say."
She had laughed, short and sincere, and she had gone back to her plate.He came on Friday as planned for the gutter.Marge was in the garden when he arrived with his ladder and his toolbox, and they had greeted each other with the familiarity of two people who had known each other for a long time and didn't need to warm up the conversation.
"The hip," he had said, looking at her cane.
"The knee. The hip is in two years if I keep not listening to the doctor."
"You never listen to the doctor."
"The doctor is thirty. He doesn't know how knees work yet."
He had smiled, really, the full smile, and Marge had looked at him with an expression you had only seen on her face for people she truly loved.You had pretended to weed the side passage.
"I can hear you," Marge had said from her garden chair.
"I'm weeding."
"You've been weeding the same patch for twenty minutes."
You had moved to a different patch.He repaired the gutter in two hours, properly this time, not a temporary fix, and came down the ladder with dust on his hands and the look of someone who had done what he came to do.Marge had brought him a lemonade without him asking.The three of you were in the garden, in the late afternoon light that made the blue hydrangeas even bluer, and the conversation had been easy and ordinary, the gutter, the summer, Gracie starting back at school in September, Marge's plans for autumn.At some point he had looked at his watch.
"I'm going to get Gracie," he had said.
"Bring her for dinner," Marge had said.
He had looked at Marge. He had looked at you.
"Are you sure?"
"I made clam chowder this morning. It's better than Lou's, but don't repeat that."
He had that smile again.
"We'll be here at seven," he had said.
Gracie arrived at seven with a new drawing in her bag, she apparently made one per visit, like a calling card, and she had given it to Marge with the ceremony of a child offering something important.Marge had looked at it through her glasses.It was the house again, with the hydrangeas, as always, but this time with four figures.
"Who's the fourth one?" Marge had asked.
"You," said Gracie. "Grandma Kowalski. Lou told me you were mama's mama's friend."
Marge had lowered the drawing.She had looked at Gracie with something in her eyes you hadn't often seen from her, an emotion she was letting through without holding it back.
"That's exactly right," she had said quietly.
Gracie had nodded with satisfaction and gone to look at the hydrangeas more closely because she had never seen any so large.You had looked at the man standing in your grandmother's garden, in the evening light, watching his daughter examine blue flowers with that expression, that particular expression he had for Gracie, light and heavy at the same time, all the love and everything else together.He had felt your gaze.He had turned around.You had looked at each other in Marge's garden, between the hydrangeas and the repaired gutter and the drawing with four figures, and you had thought that you were leaving in a week and that Boston was five hours by road and that it wasn't the moon.You had also thought that some things didn't need to be resolved tonight.
"Soup's ready," Marge had called from the kitchen.
Gracie had run to the door.You had followed her.
The night before you left, you hadn't slept.Not dramatic insomnia, just the kind of night where your brain refuses to be quiet, where you stare at the ceiling and take stock of something without knowing exactly what. Marge's house was silent. Outside the water was calm, no wind, the kind of coastal night that felt like a held breath.You had gotten up at six.You had made coffee.You had looked at Gracie's drawing on the fridge, the four figures, the house, the hydrangeas, and you had wondered whether you could take it with you or whether that was ridiculous.You had taken it.You had put it back.You had taken it again and slipped it into your bag before you could change your mind.Marge had watched you pack your suitcase with the look of someone who was saying nothing because she had learned when to be quiet.That was new. Marge was rarely quiet.
"Say what you have to say," you had said without turning around.
"I have nothing to say."
"You always have something to say."
"I'm getting old. I'm becoming wise."
You had smiled despite yourself.
"Are you planning to come back at Christmas?" she had asked after a silence.
"Probably."
"Probably is good."
"Better than no."
"Yes." A pause. "And in between."
"In between what?"
"It's an open question."
You had folded a shirt. You had put it in the suitcase. You had thought about a sentence said in the kitchen one morning after a storm, five hours by road isn't the moon, and you hadn't known what to do with it at the time and you still hadn't a week later.
"I don't know yet," you had said honestly.
Marge had nodded.
"That's honest," she had said. "That's good."
You had spent the afternoon finishing putting the house in order, the sheets, the cupboards, things in their place so Marge wouldn't have to deal with it with her knee. Practical, useful work that kept the hands busy and let the mind run on empty.Lou had sent you a message at four.
Come to the End of the Dock tonight. Last night.
You had replied :
okay.
The bar was quiet for a Friday, a few regulars, the music low, Lou behind his counter with his usual expression of someone who knew everything and chose what he said.He was there.Not with Gracie, she was at her friend Célia's for the night, you would learn later, which was maybe a coincidence and maybe not.He had seen you come in. He had given a brief nod, not cold, just him, that economy of gestures that didn't mean absence.You had sat beside him at the counter.Lou had set a soda in front of you and moved toward the kitchen with a sense of timing you were beginning to find suspicious.
"You leave tomorrow morning?" he had asked.
"Seven o'clock. To avoid traffic in Portland."
"That's early."
"Yes."
A silence. The kind of silence you had learned to inhabit together, which no longer needed to be filled to be comfortable.
"Gracie wanted to come say goodbye," he had said. "Célia offered her a sleepover and it was stronger than she was."
"That's good. Sleepovers are important at six."
"She left you something."
He had taken a folded piece of paper from his pocket. You had taken it.It was a drawing, the house again, the hydrangeas again, but this time with a single figure in front. Small, with hair your color. And below, in the careful letters of a child still learning to write:
COME BACK!!!!
You had looked at the drawing for a moment.
"She spelled it correctly," you had said.
"She asked Marge how to write it."
You had folded the paper carefully. You had put it in your pocket.
"I'm going to come back," you had said.
"I know."
"Gracie probably knows too."
"Gracie knew from the first drawing."
You had drunk your soda. He his coffee. The music was playing something slow and old, a radio somewhere, and outside the dock was orange in the evening light.You had gone out around eight, not planned, just the two of you at the same time, with that same need for air that people sometimes have when a conversation is approaching something.The dock was empty. The water was flat, that perfect mirror it sometimes had in the evening when there was no wind, and the sky was reflected in it with its colors from before nightfall, orange, pink, a blue darkening toward the open sea.
The Barnes Fishing Co. was moored at the end, its navigation lights on, red and green in the still water.You had walked to the end of the dock without planning to. You had stopped.You were looking at the water.
"Five hours by road," you had said.
"Yes."
"You said it wasn't the moon."
"It isn't the moon."
"And yet you're not saying anything more."
He had turned toward you. The evening light gave him that warm tone you had learned to associate with Hartwell in July, with the terrace of the End of the Dock, with late afternoons on the quay.
"I don't know how to do this," he had said.
Not as an excuse, as a fact, said with that direct honesty that was his way.
"Do what?"
"Say things. Ask for things." He had looked at the water. "I haven't done this in a long time."
"I know."
"Does that bother you?"
"That you haven't done this in a long time?"
"That I don't know how yet."
You had thought honestly. The dock under your feet, the water below, the sky still changing color above.
"No," you had said. "Because I don't really know how either."
He had looked at you.
"Neither of us knows."
"Neither of us knows."
A silence. Not heavy, almost light actually, the kind that arrives when you've said something true and don't need to add anything.He had looked at the charter. He had looked at you.
"I love you," he had said.
Said like that, not with a big breath before it, not with a preamble, just set there in the evening air with the same quiet economy he put into everything he said. As if it had been true for a while and he had just finally said it out loud.You had looked at his clear eyes in the evening light.You had thought about six weeks, about a gutter, about a storm, about tea at Marge's table, about a six-year-old girl who made drawings for people she liked and who decided quickly.You had thought that some decisions get made before you know you've made them.
"Me too," you had said.
He hadn't smiled immediately. He had looked at you first, really looked, in that way he had of registering important things, and then something had opened in his face, slowly, like a light gradually coming up.You had moved closer.He had put a hand on your cheek, large, warm, with the faint scar at the base of his thumb that you now knew by heart.
"You're still leaving tomorrow," he had said.
"I'm leaving tomorrow. And I'm coming back."
"When?"
"Soon." You had put your hand over his. "Gracie said come back. I'm not going to disappoint Gracie."
He had laughed, short, real, that laugh he kept for things that pleasantly surprised him.
"No," he had said. "We don't disappoint Gracie."
You had gotten back to Marge's at ten.Marge was reading on the sofa. She had looked up. She had seen your face. She had put down her book.
"Good," she had said.
"You don't even know what happened."
"I can see your face." She had picked up her book again. "There's clam chowder if you're hungry."
"I don't know if I'm hungry."
"Eat anyway. It's good soup."
You had eaten the soup standing at the counter, looking at the garden in the dark, and you had thought that Hartwell in July smelled of salt and boat diesel and something sweet that came from the bakery on the main street, and that you would remember it for a long time.The next morning at seven, you had loaded the car.Marge had kissed you on the forehead, weighted, brief, solid.On the passenger seat, you had placed two drawings.The one with four figures.And the one with just one, and COME BACK!!!! in a child's letters.
You had started the car.At the edge of Hartwell, on the road that ran along the dock, the Barnes Fishing Co. was leaving the harbor for its first trip of the day.You had honked once.The figure on the deck had raised a hand.You had taken the road toward Portland, toward the 95, toward Boston.
Five hours.
Not the moon.
✏️: @lokisgirlie
