After All Is Said and Done
Summary - Your plans for an idyllic week at the beach with Conrad are suddenly thrown into chaos when you run into Belly, his first love. When you find a ring box in his bag, you worry that Conradâs planned proposal may be ruined.
Pairing - Conrad Fisher/Reader
Tags - future fic, aged-up characters, romance, fluff, proposal, grief, loss of parents, kissing, light angst, emotional hurt/comfort, fix-it
Words - 3k
Authorâs Note - This one is mainly for those of us who feel that Conrad may be better off away from all the drama surrounding Belly (whom I also love, just to be clear). Girl needs a break from the mess, too, but weâre focusing on Con for now.
read below or on AO3
The loss of a parent connected you and Conrad before youâd truly gotten to know him. Your dad passed when you were six years old, taken by a different form of the illness that also left Conrad bereft of his mom. It was something you discovered you had in common very early on; you even discussed it on your first date. Youâd carefully picked your moment to mention that youâd grown up with a single parentâand why.
You dropped it into the conversation as casually as possible, hoping for the best. To your relief, Conrad was kind, listening to your story without the flicker of judgment that you often caught in other peopleâs eyes, betraying their true feelings when you revealed this fundamental aspect of who you are as a person, who your circumstances have forced you to become.
In the past, youâd received reactions to the information about your upbringing that had made your heart sink. Where you grew up, it wasnât standard for people to have an unconventional family set-up. But instead of reacting badly, Conrad let you speak; let you explain without interruptions, and never appeared to be negatively affected by the revelation. Then he told you he understood what youâd been through, to a certain degree, and you realised that he was different from anyone youâd ever dated.
Of course, heâd had longer with Susannahâhis momâthan you were afforded with your dad. Conrad was essentially an adult when she died. But, in truth, that didnât matter. Your grief was comparable enough that a bond was forged between you, despite having only begun chatting properly a week earlier, after running into one another a few times in your favourite campus cafe.
Even when his mom was still alive, Conrad had felt the absence of his dad, who heâd described at the time as cold and dismissive. Youâd since confirmed that assessment for yourself. So Conrad did get it, and it helped you understand one anotherâs occasional dips into melancholy as your relationship progressed. After your first date, you couldnât stop spending time together, even though you were both busy taking the first steps forward into your chosen careers.
Conrad aimed to become a doctor, and you were studying law. That was four years ago, and youâd both graduated and found jobs you were happy with. It was a tiring life, but you were content together in your cosy little apartment. In fact, youâd reached the stage within the last year where youâd been seriously thinking about what your future would look like⊠and whether or not that future was together.
You werenât the type to hint about that kind of thing. One random Tuesday night, you decided to ask Conrad outright. You were cuddled together on the couch and had just finished a less-than-memorable movie that barely held your wandering attention.
âDo you see us getting married someday?â you asked. âI mean, is that something you ever think about?â
He smiled shyly and sipped his glass of water. Heâd grown his hair a little longer than usual. Some of it fell over his eyes as he nodded with a cute little dip of the head.
âI think about that a lot, actually.â
He didnât elaborate, so you left it there. You knew Conrad well enough to appreciate that he didnât like to be pushed into things. And then, six months ago at Christmas, youâd had the strangest feeling that he would propose to you. A passing comment from your mom during dinner about how your dad would have loved to have Conrad as a son-in-law added fuel to the already flickering fire. But nothing came of it.
You almost went so far as to scroll through his email inbox, itching to check for a ring receipt, but you stopped yourself. You knew he wouldnât have minded, but you didnât want to become someone who would invade their partnerâs privacy. So youâve been waiting. Itâs finally summer and time for your annual visit to Conradâs beach house. Youâre staying there for a week before you both travel back to your momâs to attend a small family gathering. You do this yearly in late June to commemorate your dadâs passing.
Conrad shares the beach house with his brother and his momâs best friend, Laurel, along with Laurelâs kids, Steven and Isabel. You donât know them very well. In the years you and Conrad have been together, youâve only met them once or twice in passing. Thereâs tension there, especially with Isabel, or rather Bellyâthe youngest. Not only was she Conradâs first love, but she was also briefly engaged to his younger brother, Jeremiah. They were almost married, but it ended in tears, largely due to Conradâs self-confessed interference. The two families are still dealing with some trauma around it all, and it sometimes feels to you as though the cracks have been hastily papered over.
Despite all that, Laurel has always been kind to you. You can sense how much she loves Conrad and how she just wants him to be happy. And yet, you donât know when youâll see her next. Conrad has his week at the Cousins house, and everyone generally leaves him and you to it. Conrad is fine with his brother, but Jeremiah keeps busy and has an active social life. Conrad once commented that his little brother will never settle downâheâs too restless. As for Belly, she doesnât even live in the country. Sheâs currently in Paris, as far as youâre aware. And that suits you fine, if youâre being honest with yourself.
Itâs not that you feel threatened by her, but you try to acknowledge that most people view their first love in a certain light. Conrad feels everything deeply, and you wouldnât be surprised if he still holds a little fondness for Belly. Thatâs fine, only because Conrad has sworn that he learned his lesson. Belly and he are bad for one another. You believe itâ you can tell by the way he talks about it all that she hurt him deeply. And in fairness to Belly, he admits to having hurt her, too. Above all, theyâre both old enough now to have realised that sometimes love just isnât enough to make a situation work.
Itâs early evening as you and Conrad pull into the driveway of the summer house. Suddenly, your stomach flips, your anxiety stoked by the car sitting at the head of the drive, just in front of the house. What if itâs Belly? As much as youâve accepted her past with Conrad, you donât necessarily want to spend time with her, especially when you havenât prepared yourself to do so.
âWho else is here?â you ask. You dislike the fraught tone of your voice, but you couldnât have covered it up. âYou didnât tell me we wouldnât be alone.â
Conrad shakes his head, frowning. âNo, I didnât know we wouldnât. Nobody said anything to me.â He peers at the license plate of the vehicle parked ahead of you. âI donât recognise the car.â
He brakes and turns in his seat to look at you. âAre you okay? You seemââ
âI know, Iâm sorry,â you rush to say. You donât want to admit it, but youâre terrified that Belly is here. Youâre not even sure why the thought scares you so much, but it does. You force yourself to smile. âWhoever it is canât be planning to stay, right? Everyone knows itâs your week?â
âYeah, I mean, theyâre supposed to,â Conrad agrees. He reaches for your hand and squeezes it. âDonât worry, kay?â
You nod but say nothing. As youâre exiting the car, you hear the front door of the house creak open. Footfalls on the steps indicate that whoever was inside is coming down to say hello. You take a deep breath, plaster on a grin, and raise your head. You immediately lock eyes with Belly, and she falters. She looks the same as always, her long dark hair falling over her shoulders in a way that you try to admire rather than covet.
âOh, hey!â she calls to you, recovering quickly. She takes a few steps forward. âLong time no see.â
âItâs you,â Conrad utters to her, cutting you off before you get a word out. Thereâs uncertainty in his voice, but he tries to mask it with shaky laughter.
You watch as Belly takes him in, her eyes wide. She folds her arms across her middle protectively. You can see that sheâs feeling vulnerable, and you experience a pang of guilt. Although you donât see yourself and Conrad as particularly threatening, Belly is clearly uncomfortable. Perhaps she wasnât expecting you. According to Conrad, theyâre on okay terms now, despite all the complicated history. Then again, he hasnât exactly offered her a warm greeting.
âIâm sorry,â she begins. âIâve totally messed up. I thought Steven was here this week. I was going to surprise him.â
âHeâs next week,â Conrad smiles politely. Then, after a pause, he says, âI didnât know you were back.â
Belly shrugs. âJust for summer.â
They observe each other in silence for several seconds. Youâre frozen, feeling as though youâre intruding on the stilted reunion. Then, thankfully, Conrad breaks the tension.
âWell, uh, weâve had this week planned for a while. Do you have somewhere else to stay?â
âNo, wait,â you begin. âBelly, you can stay here. I donât want to kick you out of your own house.â
She angles her body towards you, and her expression reveals her gratitude. âPlease, Iâm the one intruding. Of course, I can figure something out.â
Youâre already shaking your head. Despite everything, it doesnât feel right to ask her to go. âHonestly, stay. Itâll be fine.â
Belly pulls her phone from her pocket, checking the time. âIt is kinda late for me to find somewhere now, but Iâll only stay for tonight. Iâm out of here first thing in the morning.â She looks back at Conrad. âIs that okay?â
He raises one shoulder in an attempt to seem nonchalant. âI guess.â
âOkay, uh⊠Iâm going to head outâgrab myself dinner. Iâll be back later. Enjoy your evening, guys.â
With that, Belly makes a somewhat awkward exit. You gather your things from the car and head inside, leaving Conrad to follow you to his room with most of the luggage. You watch him deposit bags onto the bed from your spot in the chair by his dresser. You hope heâs not upset with you.
âI thought itâd be best to let her stay,â you say quietly, looking up at him.
âNo, I know. I just⊠Itâs unexpected. I donât like surprises.â
You stand and shuffle towards him, wrapping your arms around his body. You feel the soft cotton of his shirt on your cheek as you press your head against him. His chin comes to rest on top of your head, and his arms encircle you, holding you tight.
âI know you donât,â you say.
He sighs, leaning a little heavier on you.
âYouâre so heavy! Can we lie down?â you request with a chuckle.
He grabs you by the hand and falls onto the bed, sending bags bouncing in all directions. He pulls you down and proceeds to enclose you in another bear hug.
âYouâre going to fall asleep,â you mumble. âIâll never get away.â
Conrad yawns. You know for a fact heâs gearing up for a nap, which heâll only regret when he canât sleep later on.
âWe should have something to eat,â you suggest.
âWhat do you want?â he asks.
You yawn as well, hopeless to suppress it. âI have absolutely no idea.â
In the end, you settle for staying in the bedroom, picking at the snack bag you brought with you for the car journey. Conrad isnât much of a snacker, but he occasionally partakes. With a handful of Doritos, he looks across the bed at you and smiles.
âIâm glad weâre here.â
âMe too,â you reply. âDonât make crumbs.â
He begins to laugh. Heâs about to say something when you hear the sound of the front door opening downstairs. Belly must be back.
âIâm sorry this hasnât gone to plan,â Conrad says.
âItâs just one night,â you reassure him.
For some reason, he looks particularly sad. You donât want to push him to talk. Instead, you reach across, brushing his hair away from his face.
âI love you,â you tell him.
He puts his chips back in the bag, then licks his fingers in a way that he definitely didnât intend to seem seductive. However, you canât help but enjoy a little thrill. He somehow manages to make the most mundane things attractive.
âI love you too,â he replies.
When he kisses you, all of your tension eases, the stress from earlier in the day seeming to melt away. And then, you remember that Belly is here. You tense up and pull back.
Conrad looks as uncomfortable as you feel. âThis isnât happening tonight, is it?â
Your laughter is genuine, if a little strained. âI donât think so. Iâm sorry.â
âNo, I totally get it,â Conrad replies. âTrust me.â
âOkay,â you say. You peck him quickly on the cheek. âIâm going to shower.â
When you return, Conrad is grabbing his towel. âBack in five,â he says.
You dry off and put on your pyjamas while casting about to determine whether or not Conrad has a hairbrush on his dresser or nightstand. You donât see one, so you go in search of your own. You donât remember exactly where you packed it, but get down onto your hands and knees, unzipping the first of the bags that fell when you and Conrad jumped on the bed earlier. Youâre rummaging through the contents when your hand brushes against an unfamiliar texture. Itâs soft, velvety.
Your heart beats faster as your fingers close around a box. A ring box. You tuck it into the sleeve of your pyjama shirt without looking at it, and sit down heavily on the bed. Thatâs how Conrad finds you when he returns a few minutes later. He rushes straight to your side, even though heâs dripping wet, and kneels beside you.
âWhatâs wrong? Has something happened?â
You stare at him and extend your arm, pulling back your sleeve with your empty hand. You and Conrad both look down at the ring box at the same time.
âAh,â he breathes. âYou found it.â
You nod slowly. âI couldnât find my hairbrush.â
âThis wasnât what Iâd planned⊠at all.â
âI guess nothing is going to plan these days,â you respond quietly.
âAre you upset?â Conrad asks, his brows knitting together.
âNo!â you hurry to reassure him. âI just⊠this isnât what Iâd imagined. I didnât thinkâŠâ You sigh, âI didnât think Belly would be here.â
Conradâs eyes widen, and he stares off into space. âMe either.â He gives himself a little shake. âI wish you hadnât found it,â he says.
âWhat do you mean?â
All of a sudden, you feel dizzy. What is he saying? Has he changed his mind about proposing? Is it because of Belly?
He focuses, his eyes fixing on you. âI was going to wait. Your mom asked me to. When I told her I was going to propose this week, she suggested I hold off. She thought it might be nice if I did it at your dadâs memorial.â
You feel a pain in your chest at the mention of your dad, but your eyes fill with tears of relief. Itâs perfect, really. Youâre reminded of how well your mom knows you; she knows how meaningful it will be to have your dad be part of such a pivotal moment in your life, especially as he will never get to join you for your wedding.
Conrad looks concerned. He reaches out to thumb away your tears. âDid we get it wrong?â
You shake your head profusely. âNo! Not at all.â You hand him the small blue box. âYou should probably pack this away again, so you can do what my mom suggested. Itâs really thoughtful.â You smile at him, and a laugh escapes you. âI thought you were going to tell me youâd decided not to ask after seeing Belly.â
Instead of laughing, as you expected he would, Conrad appears alarmed at the thought. âNo. Belly was my best friend for so long. And we tried so hard to love each other the way we thought we were supposed toâthe way my mom probably hoped we would.â He pushes his hair back, sighing. âBut something always felt⊠off. There was Jere, and it just hurt too much. It always felt like a push and pull between the three of us. Itâs not love if you have to fight that hard just to feel okay. Itâs not supposed to be painful all the time.â
âNo, itâs not,â you agree.
Conrad gazes at you. âWhen I met you, I finally understood what itâs supposed to feel like, without all the mixed messages and the confusion, or expectations that can never be met. Love is about acceptance and understanding. You and I have always had that.â
âAnd we always will.â
You throw your arms around his neck, not caring that his hair is still damp. Eventually, he stands, pulling you gently to your feet. When he turns you towards the bed, you try to forget that Belly is still in the house, but you canât. As soon as Conrad speaks, itâs as if heâs read your mind.
âWe should get some sleep. Itâs been a full-on day.â
Your heart swells with love for him, and with appreciation for his ability to read you so well. âSleep is exactly what I need.â















