3:55 PM
pairing: Niki x afab reader | small town au
synopsis: Niki and you have your first argument at a cutesy frozen yogurt shop surrounded by unset boundaries, sudden unfamiliarity, and the cashier hiding in the storage room.
themes/elements: Y/N's POV, unlabeled/non monogamous relationship, mentions of underage drinking, Niki a year younger than reader, angst, homesickness, making fun of high schoolers, college, poor communication, small time jumps (bear with me), insecurity, cursing, arguing, let me know if i missed something
ft: Maki (&team), Taki (&team), and Soul/Shota (p1harmony) included all the Rikis & my Japanese maknaes lol
word count: ~4K
a/n: i almost didn't finish this, but inspiration overcame me again. funny writing for Niki after Hyunjin; feels like i have a type lol. i wrote them so different tho :o Y/n and Niki are lowkey nuanced. shout out @rrradduh for test reading n’ inspiring some dialogue
likes, comments, and or reblogs are immensely appreciated.
part one, part two, part three, epilogue
--------------------------------------------------------------
You never fight. You’ve never fought.
It’s your first time fighting with him. The first time he yelled at you. The first time you yelled back. The first time he couldn’t look at you… The first time there was absolutely nothing to smile about.
You two weren't even official yet. Trapped in the perpetual cycle known as the talking stage. Supposedly safe and familiar. Its like you’ll die here. Like becoming official was never a part of the plan. Like there’s no way out or at least there wasn’t before this fight.
This stupid ugly fight. You hate this fight. You would do anything to stop this fight. Because its uncomfortable and new and the first time he’s mentioned leaving and you don’t know if he’s talking about this annoyingly pastel frozen yogurt shop or you.
He can’t leave yet. You haven’t even started. You're not even his girlfriend.
——
Things just kind of happened. Before this summer you hadn’t seen each other since winter recess. You’re in college. You weren’t around; you left. Not that he mattered to you before then.
You didn’t apply to any schools within two hours of where you’re from. Curiosity fueled you. What’s it like in a city? Who would you be friends with if you lived somewhere else? How would you feel about yourself if you didn’t live here? So you left.
Turns out curiosity does not kill the cat. Just makes it a little meek and anxious. You went from being an introvert in an extrovert’s clothing (get it like a wolf in sheep’s clothing?) to being unbearably introverted. You hadn’t had to make new friends since second grade. Then you moved into a shitty dorm building 3 hours away from what actually felt like home. A cocoon with an open door policy and neighbors who make their headboard play patty cake with your wall. It was… different.
You went home for winter recess.
Houses decorated with Christmas decorations. Bathrooms without stalls. Cable. You almost talked yourself into taking a gap year. It was great.
That’s at least what you told yourself. You got bored after two weeks.
So you went outside. Let the cold lick your face and visited your old favorite cafe, walked through barren parks. Even visited your old high school. As cringe as it was, that was were you ran into Niki.
God. You almost shot yourself into space without a helmet when your realized you were visiting a high school with underclassmen who still actively remember you. Former student body president visiting the past like the glory days escaped you. Not very inspiring.
Niki made fun of you. Well, you think he did.
He was snickering and vaguely pointing with his friends like an asshole. Him and his bumbling entourage with matching names, Maki and Taki, stood down the hall from you in their coordinated oversized fits. They weren’t so uncool to girls their age, but you’re a college girl now. You have no business affirming a high schooler as anything other than awkward. Even though you’re barely better than them (if at all).
That should’ve been your first fight. Instead his tickled expression reminded you that you had no business being there. You already visited your favorite social studies teacher; you could’ve left immediately after. Instead you were looking at your reflection in a spotless trophy case like you’ve played a sport before.
It was silly, but it was familiar. Like him.
You didn’t talk that day.
You spoke when you ran into each other outside a liquor store a week later. Technically, you’re not legal but you had an il-legal fake ID, a car, and a hoodie that fell nicely over your eyes. The plan was to buy a bottle small enough to dispose of seamlessly and strong enough to not buy two. Simple.
Niki, Maki, Taki, and some squeamish kid stood outside the store picking at their nails. Niki noticed you as your car door clanked shut and started nonchalantly nudging the guy who was obviously uncomfortable.
He looked up and saw you. The poor boy’s face paled upon locking eye contact.
Niki and Maki whispered to the boy the whole time you strolled up. Taki just kept looking around anxiously.
The boy approached and you were quick to ask, “are you okay?” You covered you mouth, spoke in a hushed tone. The situation was sketchy. It wasn’t in the cards to watch someone get peer pressured right in front of you tonight.
He looked taken aback. He nodded and gave a smile too jittery to be reassuring. Maybe he was just cold. He had on relaxed fit jeans and two hoodies like it was too un-swag to wear a jacket. It was January.
“What’s your name?” You asked.
“Shota.”
“Okay Shota… Are you here to ask me to buy you alcohol?”
He shook his head violently and started to speak, cutting himself off multiple times. Too many "umms” and "wells.” You weren’t oblivious. Underage people standing outside of a liquor store at a strip mall where that was the only place left open meant one thing.
“Yes, but you don’t have to if you don’t want to.”
He looked up at you helplessly. You could almost make out someone sucking their teeth in the distance.
“Do you have money?”
He dug into his pocket and pulled out a crumbled twenty.
Long story short you bought them a six-pack. Shota groveled at your feet. Maki called you “beautiful and kind.” Taki insisted you keep the change. Niki was the only one who threw you off with his reaction.
“You remember me?”
You nodded. Was he talking about the other day?
You did sort of remember him. From that day and before that. You knew all of their names (well except Shota). You were student body president. You remember a lot of people. A wave of embarrassment overcame you when you realized they might’ve recognized you despite your pseudo disguise. You weren’t setting the best example for post-high school life.
He nodded and looked away.
“You used to friends with my sister.”
He said it like he didn’t believe you actually remembered him. And you indeed did not. You forgot all about his sister.
You were friends in like elementary school when they first moved to town. It was in your nature to gravitate towards new people. She was fun and exciting. You guys were actually pretty close. You’d been to her house a handful of times up until around high school. That was when you decided you’d work harder than anything to make sure you went to college far far away. When new people stopped showing up. When things got stale.
“Of course I remember you,” you lied.
He searched your eyes for something. You didn’t know what. It made you squirm.
Without clearance from his posse, he reached into the pack of beers Maki was cradling and passed you one with a nod. You accepted. His eye contact wavered.
“Thank you, Niki.”
He nodded again.
Taki eagerly elbowed him in the ribs with wide shifting eyes. Maki pushed Taki a little harder than he needed to and nudged Niki. Shota was just happy to be there.
“Walk her to her car,” Maki grinned at Niki blankly.
“I can walk myself. Its right there” you pointed.
“I insist” Maki said.
“Why are you insisting for him? I said its alright.”
“You’re pretty and its lat—“
“If he wants to walk me he’ll walk me.” It came out a little sharper than intended. “Stop peer pressuring. Please.”
Finally Niki made a sound. He chuckled. Nothing too serious, something small and boyish.
You looked at him a little annoyed. In your head he was part of the problem. Did he want to walk you to your car? He was pressuring Shota earlier. You should just leave while your free beer is cold. Would it still be cold by the time you got home?
Niki snapped you out of your train of thought. He had his arm extended towards you with his phone lazily in his palm. He had a contact open with “Y/N” written as the contact name.
“Just text me when you get home.”
It was too nonchalant to be nonchalant. He wasn’t really looking at you. Kind of around you and at your eyes for seconds at a time. He could’ve been annoyed or bored, but you knew better. Things were mathing. This was an excuse to get your number.
You nodded and entered your number.
You didn’t need to really. Maybe you shouldn’t have. This dude had homeroom on Monday. It was just… really interesting. A balance between new and old. A good balance.
——
Thank God this places is empty. The poor cashier fled to the back room once you sighed a little too loudly. The fight hadn’t even started then.
Now it was in full swing. You both were standing. About an arms length apart from each other. Looking directly at each other.
“We’re not exclusive, Y/N!”
That was when he yelled. It wasn’t an angry yell as much as it was an exasperated cry for attention. And it was successful.
You stopped in your tracks. Mouth closing before a response could recklessly escape you. He was right. Both of you knew you weren’t exclusive. And it was all your fault.
He told you he liked you. Not very charismatically or romantically but he told you. Smack deed in the middle of mid terms week. Over FaceTime. At like two o’clock in the morning. He confessed. And you told him you should wait to see how you both felt when you got back home for the summer. That was four months ago and things have been seamless ever since.
He had a date of his choosing to prom. You went to a few parties. Both of you talked all the time. Its fun to talk to him. He makes you laugh. He makes you feel safe. All that time you were apart, he had a way of holding your hand without holding your hand. Giving you a reason to get through the semester. A reason to go home.
Now you are home and you haven’t talked about making things official or being exclusive. It just hasn’t come up yet. There was no rush. You just got back.
Its just… you didn’t know he would actively flirt with people when he was in front of you. It started off subtle. You blamed it on him being around Maki and other teenage boys. But you’re a teenage girl and you’d be careless to let what happened today slide.
The shop wasn’t always empty.
——
There was a group of girls in here before. Around five crowed a table in the back by the froyo machines when you first walked in. Too giggly to be older than you. Too many purses and handbags to be too much younger than you.
They were staring at him. Staring at Niki. Giggling about Niki. Chatting about Niki. Thinking about Niki. You weren’t amused.
Niki ate that shit up. Peeking over his shoulder while serving hisself frozen yogurt. Stretching his arms over his head for no reason. Paying for your treat without even looking at you. Just put his phone out and tapped. One of the young ladies essentially turned into one of those moaning emojis.
No big deal. You survived.
Then, that same moany one walked up to you and Niki’s table. She tapped his shoulder with a twinkle in her eye and said:
“I really like your style—“
He’s wearing sweatpants.
“—I actually got the Mint chocolate too—”
Of course she likes that.
“—I’m not from this side of town, but I have a car and—“
WHY THE FUCK IS SHE GIVING HER WHOLE LIFE STORY?!
You were jealous. Its a strange, agitating feeling, but there was no denying it was there. The urge to be territorial over Niki was suddenly insistent. So you chimed in.
“Can you please get to your question?”
She looked at you for the first time. Like a deer caught in headlights. You almost immediately regretted saying something when she gave you a sad, shy smile like you really messed up her momentum. Then you remembered she was flirting with your date.
“Sorry um, is this— am I— was I interrupting?”
You peeked at Niki, expecting him to say something. He just looked at you and shrugged.
“Depends…”
That’s all he said. He was looked between you and that girl like someone was bound to give him the answers. But to what exactly?
You squinted at him. “On what?”
The girl cleared her throat, regaining both your attention.
“Can I speak to you— him— as in you, privately?”
Niki nodded. Reassuringly. He got out of his seat, walked with this stranger outside of the shop, and they started talking.
The entire table of her peers went ballistic.
Then there you were, left alone by your date who you’d been talking to for several months. He actually left. Nothing like this has ever happened before.
Outside, Niki and the girl didn’t touch or smile much. But Niki was nodding, looking down at her with his sharp eyes and quiet expression. He nodded nearly every time she took a breathe. Like he was couching her through interacting with him.
She seemed a little anxious. Or overwhelmed. She had wavering eye contact and twiddling thumbs.
In a moment notice, she was digging in her purse and pulling out a notepad. She pulled out a pen, and tried passing it over. He rejected the pen and notepad and started gesturing at her. She nodded and jotted her name and number. Ripped the page off, and handed it to him. He took it, shook her hand, and walked back inside.
She gave a thumbs up to her peers and they all flocked outside with overly polite good-byes to you, Niki, and the cashier. Then, they were gone.
——
And now you’re here.
“So what?!” You spat. “We don’t have to be exclusive for you to not disrespect me to my face like that!”
“It had nothing to do with you.”
“It had everything to do with me!”
“She came up to me!”
“Yet you left with her!”
Niki lets out an astonished “wow.” This isn’t going well.
“If I left with her how can I be standing here, with you, right now?”
You roll your eyes. That wasn’t the point. Why did he leave in the first place? He is staring at you like you’re stupid. Like you’re the one not make sense. Him walking out earlier with her was weird. It struck a nerve. The whole situation was annoying. He was in the wrong not you.
“You asked for her number, Niki.”
“I didn’t— I took her number so she couldn’t call me.”
Its your turn to stare at him like he’s stupid.
He rolled his eyes, “If I gave her my number she’d call me literally tonight.”
“Well are you gonna call her tonight?!”
Niki titled his head at you. He almost looks offended. For a moment you both just stare at each other in disbelief. No one says anything. Just silence.
He turns away first.
“No,” he starts. “We have plans.” There’s a pregnant pause.
He faces you. His eyes are downturn. He looks a lot older than you recall. “Remember?”
You nod and search his eyes for any signs that he believes you. You remember. Of course your remember. He’s your date. You remember plans. You pay attention to him.
And right now you’re paying enough attention to him to notice how uncertain he looks.
“Why would you say that? Of course I remember.”
The plan was frozen yogurt, feed the ducks, followed by a drive in movie. That’s why you’re in this senseless side of town anyway. The drive in theater is around here. You decided to come to this side of town to kill time and beat any potential rush hour traffic. This way you can arrive at the theater early to snatch a good spot.
Each of you picked an activity.
Niki wanted to go to a drive in for the first time and have a main character moment. You immediately agreed since you’ve never been either. It sounded awesome. You made some sandwiches, so you wouldn’t suffer egregious snack prices (you’ll probably buy snacks anyway).
You wanted to go to the lake, play swanky music, and feed the birds with a soon-to-be moldy loaf of bread. Niki didn’t really like that idea, he thought it was weird and dangerous. He did some research in the middle of the night and came back with a list of seeds to feed geese and ducks instead.
Going to get frozen yogurt was a joint decision based on proximity and a weather report. A nearby sweet treat to keep you both cool on a hot day. This was planned in advance with thought and care. This was supposed to be a chill start to a day of choosing each other. Now it feels like he chose someone else.
“Why did you take her number?”
“I already told you.”
“... Are you going to call her?” He furrowed his brows. You bet he was thinking he already answered that too. “I mean, in general.”
“I—“ Suddenly he couldn’t look at you. “I don’t know.”
A sigh rips through you.
“When will you know?”
“Y/n.”
“How long does it usually take you to decide between upholding my dignity and making a quick play? You know, on average.”
Apparently, that’s what it takes for him to look at you again. Not just any look, to glare. He walks up to you stopping less than an arms length apart.
“That’s not fair.”
Your tongue prods at your cheek. Your eyebrows raise quizzically.
“Right I came up the the whole not exclusive thing, so I can’t be petty when you follow my rules right?”
Niki rolls his eyes. He let a breathe through his nose that sounded scarily similar to that of a bull.
“So I have to just sit here an eat it, right? Even when the boy who is supposed to like me looks for his next target in front of me? When he looks at people who are younger than me. People who are nothing like me.”
Your voice cracked. You aren’t going to cry. You’re just a little worked up. Its hard to say what came over you.
Niki’s prom date looked nothing like you. And now that bold girl acted the complete opposite of you.
She spoke more timidly, more cutely than you. More often than not you were mannerly yet serious and direct. Very assertive. You didn’t stutter like her, or bend to accommodate him. Maybe that was your problem.
The wave of insecurity sobered you like you didn’t already know it was the backbone of this entire argument.
“She came to me, Y/n.”
“And you left with her!” You’re going in circles.
He steps closer. “Its not like that!” He sighs. “Do you know how long I’ve liked you?!”
“And now you’re love bombing me…”
“No— I just— What is wrong with you?”
“How long have you liked me Niki?”
He really looks at you for the first time in minutes. So sincere. Almost comforting. Like a timid hug.
“Second time you came to my house. I was in first grade.” He looked left to right shyly and cleared his throat.
There’s a pause… You did expect him to say some absurd moment from a while ago. Just not that long ago. It didn’t feel like it mattered right now.
“Why not the first time?”
“Y/N.”
“Please stop saying my name like that.” Like he was begging. \
It was clear he didn’t want to fight either.
It is unclear if you’re fighting anymore. The cashier still hasn’t come out from the backroom, but neither of you are yelling anymore. There’s less space for anger. Unanticipated confusion, vague upset, and inklings of pettiness are already taking up most of the room. Is this a fight? Your voices are lower now. You sound less… desperate. This is definitely still a fight.
“You’re out in college.”
How are you supposed to respond to that?
“I’m just here,” he adds. “I’m always here.”
The power is shifting between you two. He made you feel guilty. You wanted to shrink. He keeps painting himself as the victim.
He humiliated you. He made fun of you when you visited the school. He didn’t want to walk you to your car. He confessed to you during one of the most stressful weeks of the semester. He took a girls phone number right in front of you.
“Just because I’m away at college doesn’t mean I’m not me. I’m not throwing myself at other people for the fun of it.” A pause, “you’re the only person I’m talking to.”
Niki’s eyes widen. He searches your face for any signs you could be lying.
“I didn’t know.”
“You didn’t ask.”
“You could’ve told me.”
“Yes, you’re right.”
“You didn’t even tell me you like me back.”
You freeze. Your shoulders lock up uncomfortably high, but you don’t really notice. He’s right about that too.
This isn’t a fight anymore. Its a vulnerable conversation.
“I— I do like you. You’re the only person I talk to, like I said.”
“That doesn’t mean you like me.”
“Can we please finish this conversation somewhere el—“
“Do you like me?”
“Yes!”
He doesn’t look happy like how you thought he would. In hind site you did yell, but you thought saying that would fix things. Fix the broken air between you two. The space cluttered with remnants of words that were pried out of you.
“Why didn’t you just say that when I confessed?”
“I don’t know!”
“Did you not like me the—“
“You talk to other people Niki!”
Silence. It crowds the room like toxic gas. Maybe that’s why you’re breathing so heavy. Short, shallow breathes with knowing eyes. You were tired of the questions.
“Maybe I should go.”
“Why?!”
“I don’t know!” He flinched at his own tone.
More silence. You hear the cashier drop something and curse under their breath.
“You wanna leave again? Left before because… A girl asked you to? Or was it because you didn’t know I like you and needed a security net when this falls through?”
He licks his teeth.
“Now what Niki? You should leave because now I like you, but you hurt me?”
The anger is back. He’s angry, although you’re not angry. Maybe you are. You’re more annoyed. Spiteful. Amused.
“I should go.”
This is less amusing.
He grabs his bag from the back of his chair. The chair that was abandoned early on in the scream match. The bag that was in your back seat on the drive here.
He politely tucks the chair into the table and slings the cross body bag over his broad shoulder. He stops and looks down at you with tight lips and furrowed brows. Hands clinging to the strap of his bag. You can still see the note with the girls number in his left pocket.
He can’t leave yet. You’ve barely even started. You weren't even official yet. He's not even your boyfriend.
This stupid, god-forsaken, ugly fight. You hate this fight. Because its uncomfortable and new and semi public and repetitive and vulnerable. This is the first time he’s mentioned leaving and you don’t know if he’s talking about this annoyingly pastel frozen yogurt shop or you. There was no way out before this fight. But if he wants to leave you won’t make him stay. In this shop or in this situation. He can go.
And he does.
Now, you stand alone. Dizzy. Disoriented. Disgruntled. Deadass?
You grab the two unfinished cups and throw them away. You tidy up what used to be your table. Leave it better than you found it.
You grab your tote and tuck your chair just like he did.
You check the time. 3:54 PM.
Without any sort of doubt, today didn’t go as expected. It ended early in an argument neither of you were emotionally skilled or empathetic enough to navigate. It might’ve ended.
A minute passes. Its 3:55 PM now.
Your phone lights up with a notification.
Niki: text me when you get home
done! if you followed along with the story, thank you for your time and dedication lol. hope you guys liked it :3 let me know if you want a Niki version














