Best Mother: Finalists - Round 2:Â Battle of the Live Action Moms
Emma Swan (OUAT)
Joyce Byers (ST)
Voting ended onDec 21, 2024
Propaganda Under Cut:
Emma Swan (Mother of Henry Mills): Emma always wanted what was best for Henry whether she was in her life or not. She did everything to protect and nuture him from when he came back into her life.
Joyce Byers (Mother of Jonathan + Mike): Joyce encouraged Will's interests and hobbies. When Will was taken into the Upside Down she fought to find him even going into the Upside Down to rescue him. She was very protective of him afterwards rarely letting him out of her sight.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
After the events of Cherry Wine Emma gives birth to a little boy, Luke David Swan Charming. When heâs three months old she goes to a mommy and baby group, she finds that she hates nearly everyone there, she shares her sarcastic comments with a woman called Iz who has a son the same age as Luke.Â
Later that week Henry sets his mom up with the new illustrator of his book, to her surprise its the same woman from the mommy and baby, itâs awkward at first but they hit it off.Â
They have many more dates, Emma starts to study social work at the Storybrooke Collage, after some time Emma and Iz move in with their collective three kids (Hope, Luke, and Dante respectively).Â
Iz proposed to Emma on a family trip to Italy, Emma says yes with absolutely no reservations, this time.Â
They marry when the boys are five and Hope is ten. Their family and friends are around them when they marry.
(if you think Emma had a happy ending, please read to your own risk)
The show has ended like over a year ago, but this has been on my mind for a while so...
A lot of us like to complain about Emma's so called "happy ending" in season 6. How out of character it is, how the character has been ruined from what once had been... And else.
Well, I think that (outside of being bitter for SQ) I liked Emma's character development. No, not in that way. It shows us that people can get better AND worse through time. In Emma's case, we have the story of a woman that has always been alone, then she gets a family and a boyfriend, so she tries to do everything to satisfy them, even though it makes her lose herself.
It's sold to us as a Happy Endingâą. I don't agree, clearly, but the story is believable and shows accurate development. Emma changed in the six seasons she's a main character, that doesn't mean it was for the good. Yet, the story of how a woman became a shadow of herself... That's a story that actually interests me.
David sat on the staircase lacing up his sneakers, waiting for Jake to bound down the stairs, inevitably telling David to hurry up as though the child had been the one waiting.
He stood up as he heard feet descending the staircase, but when he turned around and looked up he realised that it wasnât just Jake coming down the stairs, but Emma too. She would often wake up early, nowadays, but she would normally watch cartoons or play with some toys (which she didnât admit to doing) or sheâd go and wake Snow or Ben to keep her company. But it was unusual for her to be dressed to do any of those things, let alone in shorts and a tshirt hoodie along with sneakers she had obviously slipped on in a hurry as they were still undone. He reached his arms out to catch her as she nearly fell down the stairs.
âIâm coming running too.â She announced to him with a big smile.
Davidâs eyebrows flickered down into a frown for a half a second, he glanced to Jake who shrugged clearly he had nothing to do with it, he looked back at his daughter giving her a sympathetic smile. âEm, sweetie, why donât you stay here, itâs early and Jakey and I run a really far way, if you still want to run later Iâll take you and Benny to the beach, okay?â
âNo!â Emma whined her foot colliding with stair, her dad gave her a look but she was too frustrated to be ashamed or embarrassed. Instead she just looked at her father imploringly. âI wanna go with you and Jakey.â
âEmma.â David sighed deeply. He looked over at Jake.
âI donât mind Em coming too.â
David wished Jake had insisted on having this time with just him, Emma had been sick a month ago and while she had made a full recovery the memory of her unconscious in a hospital bed would haunt him forever. But Jake acted like an older brother to Emma since she showed up, helping her adjust to the changes in the town, year, and her life, and he was just a kind big brother to her than he was to Ben. But right now David wished that Jake was a bit more selfish, if only to appease Davidâs own worries about his daughter. He sighed again. âOkay, but weâre not going to be running as far or as fast. Jake go grab us all a granola bar to have before our run, we can have breakfast laster.â He watched Jake dash off and stopped Emma from following him. âSit down.â She did as she was told and he knelt in front of her, doing up her laces.
âThanks Daddy.â
âNo problem sunshine.â He helped her stand back up. âYou need to take it easy, no going too fast, it wasnât that long ago you were sick, if you need to take a break or a drink you let me know, okay?â
âIâll be fine.â
â Emma? â
âOkay.â She agreed.
She and Jake wolfed down their granola bar and David led them out of the house, leaving a note for Snow to let him know that he had two of the three kids with him.
He led his kids down the trail from their house which led into the forest, it was the route he and Jake often went on, but David was going to cut it in half for Emmaâs sake, he knew that she was always full of energy, and perhaps this run would help, but he was taking it easy her first time out.
He found himself chuckling as he jogged beside his kids, Jake kept pace, he was a swimmer and jogged in the same steady way he swam warm up lengths, Emma reminding David of a bee, she kept darting ahead and falling back, before darting ahead or behind once more.
David chatted to Jake as they jogged together, the boy was chattering about school, books he was desperate to buy, his friends, and his upcoming swim meet, and David happily asked him questions, he loved being able to be so involved with his sonsâ lives, his father had never bothered to be in his before he had died, and he had missed out on so much of Emmaâs that he was determined to play an active role in his sons, and his daughterâs now that she was back.
âCan we still go to the beach later?âJake asked his father, sending him a grin; for the most part Jake was like his mother, but he had inherited his eyes, his protective nature, and his smile from his father. âMe and Ben and Emma can have a sandcastle building competition.â
There were few things he loved more than the fact that his kids got along with each other so well. âI donât see why not. What do you think Em, you wanna-â he turned back to look at Emma but his smile dropped when he realised that Emma was a little way back, stood still, but hunched other. âEMMA!â He quickly turned direction and shot back as fast as he could, Jake hot on his heels.
âEmmy!â Jakes eyes were on his sister as their father tried to get her to look at him. He could see Emmaâs entire body moving as she panted. âDad she canât breathe!â
He knew that Jake was correct but he didnât know why. âWere we going too fast? Did you get winded?â
Emma shook her head but that was all she could do, she was trying to suck in air through her mouth but she couldnât get enough, her chest felt like it had a hundred elastic bands wrapped around it, squeezing it tight.
âO-Okay.â David frowned he didnât understand. He pulled his backpack off and handed it to Jake. âJakey find a drink in there for your sister for me.â He carefully took hold of Emma and helped her to the ground. She tried to slump down but he placed his hand on her back. âKeep sat up straight Emma.â He told her firmly, he still had no idea what was happening but he had been around men and women on battlefields who couldnât breathe, he had a vague idea of how to help, but it was only a vague idea . âYouâre going to copy my breathing, okay, nice and slow, just copy me.â He made sure that his own breathing was slow and steady, as calm as possible but exaggerated so that Emma could see him doing so, as he did he told her when to breathe in and out.
Jake passed the bottle of juice to his father, he bit his lip as he watched his sister sip the juice but it was clear that she was struggling to breathe. âD-DadâŠ?â
âYeah bud?â David asked but he kept his eyes on Emma. âHey, slower breathing, Em, just a bit slower.â
âWe, me and Ben, we found an inhaler in her bag when she moved in, like Nick in my class has⊠is she having an asthma attack?â
Davidâs head snapped up to look at his son before looking looking back at his daughter wearily. âEmma Ruth, do you have asthma?â
Emma looked away from him, giving him an answer. She shrank in on herself when he practically growled her name, out of frustration, she had never really thought about tell them, and hadnât planned on unless she needed to⊠apparently that had been a bad plan.
Asthma, why hadnât he thought about asthma before? Why had Emma never told him she had it? Had she told Snow when his wife was cursed? He was so mad at her keeping this to herself, she must know how dangerous it was was. He couldnât think about that right now. âOkay, okay,â He reassured both himself and his kids, âokay, Jakey get my phone out of my backpack, I need you to ring 911, tell them where we are, say that your sisterâs having an asthma attack, Emma I need you to stay nice and calm, weâre going to try and breathe slow again, in through your nose, and out through your mouth. Just copy me, kiddo.â
As David tried his best to keep his head and to keep his breathing steady and helping Emma to try and control her breathing. He could also hear that Jake was worrying, on the phone 911, he reached over to squeeze his hand, trying to comfort both of his kids at the same time.
It wasnât long before the ambulance was so close that David could hear it. He finally took his eyes off of Emma. âJakey, you remember your way back home from here, donât you?â
âYeah, itâs just straight back down the trail.â
âGood boy, I need you to run back home, if momâs not up then wake her up and tell her whatâs happened with your sister, that Iâm going to the hospital with her. Can you do that for me?â
âI can do that.â Jake agreed quickly, he wasnât really one to kick up a fuss anyway, but he could tell how scared his sister was, and he had a feeling that his dad was pretty scared too. âFeel better Emmy.â He offered to his sister, he handed back his fatherâs backpack to him, before taking off at full speed back down the path which led to their family home.
The ambulance ride had passed in a blur for Emma, she felt exhausted, despite having been running for about 10 minutes and having woken up feeling fine. In the ambulance she tried her best to stay awake but only because she kept being told to do so by the paramedic. There was a oxygen mask over her face obstructing her view every time her eyes blinked shut she opened them fast to try and tried taking her mask off to find her father, she kept being stopped from doing it and Davidâs voice would reassure her that he was there.
The oxygen helped a lot, she was already feeling better by the time she got to the hospital but the mask was kept on as tests were performed on her. Her dad kept soothing her but other than that he was quiet, not quite his usual self, not that Emma was alert enough to realise this.
âIâm looking for my daughter, Emma, she came in with my husband-.â
âSnow!â
Snowâs head snapped away from the nursesâ station to her husband who was walking towards her. She smiled at the nurse she had been about to asked then allowed herself to show her true worried face to her husband. âHow is she?â
âSheâs a lot better, they gave her oxygen in the ambulance and a nebuliser here to help her with her breathing, as well as some steroids which she nearly threw up taking. When you were cursed, the first time when you were living in the lost with Em, did she mention having asthma?â
Snowâs lips set in a thin line as they always did when she was truly angry. âNo. The first I heard of it was when Jake ran home and told me about it.â
âIf he hadnât known about her old inhalerâŠâ He shook his head in frustration. âI would have still brought her here but not so quickly, anything could have happened in that time. I canât believe sheâd be so, so stupid.â
âMe neither.â She shook her own head as she tried not to storm over, to the curtained area David had come from, and read her daughter the riot act.
David took her hand and gently squeezed it as he looked down at her. âTrust me, Iâm beyond mad at her too, but letâs wait to talk to her about it until sheâs fully better, itâs not like sheâll be leaving our sights for a while anyway, sheâll be safe.â
âI agree. Weâll stress how dangerous her not telling us was and how weâre disappointed.â
David nodded his head. He let out a sigh. âI was just hoping that she was finally over this sort of thing. Sheâs been doing so well recently. Itâs like two steps forward, one step back.â
Snow squeezed his hand. âThatâs still one step forward.â
The corners of Davidâs lips tugged up into a small smile. He had been married to his wife for nearly 20 years yet her hope and positive attitude still took him by surprise every now and again. âYouâre right. We should get back over to her before she takes it upon herself to find us. I think sheâll be sent home soon, the medicine worked, they were just waiting for the treatment to finish and a doctor to check her over. Weâre over here.â He tilted his head towards the closed curtains then led his wife in the same direction.
As soon as Snow saw Emma her anger melted away, temporarily at least, she wrapped her arms around her daughter and held her as tight as she dared. They stayed like that until the doctor came over to unhook her from the mask and check her over.
âCan I go home now?â
Her begging the second the mask came off made David and Snow laugh a little, they were relieved that she was still in fairly good spirits, even if she wasnât yet completely back to her old self.
âYouâre not moving from here until the doctor tells us you can, baby, so hush so we can hear what she has to say.â
The doctor bit back a smile. âWell by the looks of it Emma is ready to go home, Iâll prescribe new inhalers for you and steroid tablets, eight twice a day for two weeks, once youâve finished them itâs important you come back for a checkup, we need to make sure that your asthma is well managed so that this doesnât occur again.â
âThank you so much.â
âYouâre grounded to the couch until youâre completely better.â David wrapped his arm around his daughter cuddling her into his side.
âBy our standards better.â Snow added signing one of Emmaâs forms to discharge her.
âThat means Iâm never getting off the couch.â
David shrugged. âShame.â He smirked then dropped a kiss onto her head.
âYou can watch movies.â Snow suggested, Emma being on the couch forever sounded good to her right about then, at least Snow would know where she was and that she was safe.
Emma was about to mumble about them being overprotective, or hover-parents, but she remembered how David looked and sounded when he found out about her asthma, she decided to stay quiet and just cuddle into his side.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch âą No registration required âą HD streaming
And AU Headcanons for Detective Red Snowing? PLEASSEEEEEEE
Ooooooooh yes! (literally who sees this please send me even more for this ship as I love them)
Often when they go out on dates everyone assumes theyâre on a double date, they are always stressing that theyâre all together.
Rogers is actually an amazing cook, a few times heâs cooked for his family if he got home before them, he claims he just follows recipes but heâs overjoyed that his spouses love it.Â
They chose their wedding rings together and all have engagement rings from each other (David to Snow, Rogers to Ruby, Snow to Rogers, and Ruby to David). Some idiots  people try to make out that David likes Snow best and Rogers likes Ruby best etcetera, they have no insecurities about it at all, they know they love each other fully and completely.Â
They try to go out on date nights at least once a month, but mostly theyâre homebodies and have âdatesâ at home when the kids are asleep.
Theyâre often caught in the kitchen dancing with each other along to the songs on the radio - they are amazing gestures of love and do them constantly (from flowers, mixtapes, chocolates, dancing, to big gestures like romantic nights away at hotels).
I accidentally started to do like five for each of themâŠ. and for their kids (I have like a million more HC honestly)
Rogers:
They all met after Hook got back from Neverland where he had been for just over a century - having reached his lowest (giving Bae to Pan) he had tried to redeem himself when he met bandit Snow, faking Prince David, and unknowing werewolf Red. He tried to distance himself from everyone and do good deeds from afar so not to hurt anyone else but fate had a different idea and he bumped into them all the time, before long they all finally realised they were all in love and formed a poly Quad.
Under the curse (not done by Regina but by someone else) they were transported to Hyperion Heights which is right next to Storybrooke. Detective Rogerâs first name is Kian, he often gets it shortened to either Kee (key) or Ian (mostly because everyone kept pronouncing it differently or asking him a million questions based off of it). Once the curse breaks he keeps that name instead of Killianâs, he finally forgive himself (after over a century of making up for his past deeds and continuing to do that since) and that he wasnât the same man who had the name Killian Jones. He takes the last name of Charming but he often gets called just Rogers like he was under the curse.Â
Because he took in Alice under the curse heâs the one who understands their now growing daughter the most, and her mental health issues, despite that he wished that it hadnât taken him so long to do it, he also totally regrets not having bonded as much with Emma and tries to make up for it but itâs hard because his baby already has so many walls.Â
He and David worked together as partner detectives under the curse, he  visited the diner owned by Ruby twice a week, and spoke to Mary Margaret who he saw in the bookstore every Tuesday and Thursday night at 8pm no matter what (they were subtle like that) (until Emma came to town and it all started to change and become uncursed. He had crushes on all of them but he assumed that he was just good friends with them or desperate for human connection.Â
He still has phantom pains where his hand should be, under the curse he got his new hand attachment which works almost like real hand which he keeps when the curse breaks. He only uses his hook against villains.
Ruby:
Ruby is a very logical thinking and a natural mediator, she was both a knight and a diplomat in their kingdom (as well as having the official title of princess like her husbands has the title prince). She uses these skills during the curse at her diner which lies between Storybrooke and Hyperion Heights to both run the place and the financial side and to help people in the diner solving their problems.Â
She would walk around with Alice on her back in werewolf form when she was a baby until the curse fell in the Enchanted forest and couldnât sleep, she would often find runaway near her diner in the early hours when she was starting to open it, she always took her in and made sure she had enough to eat, she did the same when Emma suddenly started to hang around with Alice. She wanted to take them in but was told she wasnât allowed to foster either of them because she was always at the diner (plus the curse was wanting to make her feel guilty).Â
She is an amazing cook and baker, when the curse breaks their home smells like baking all the time. She shares cooking duties with her spouses as they often catch up on their days while cooking. She tries to teach her daughters how to bake, she encouragesÂ
She is a really fast runner even in human form, she uses that to her advantage as both of her girls are such fast runners and they sometimes spook and run away when theyâre scared.
Because of being a werewolf she runs hot and rarely ever gets ill, but when her spouses or children get ill she has about a million different home remedies to try and help them.
Snow:
Sheâs a teacher in a school in Storybrooke during the curse but she lives between the city and the town, close to Rubyâs diner, theyâve been friends for as long as they can remember (because of the curse). The diner is also how they all met during the curse. When the curse breaks she stays a teacher.
She always talked to Alice at the diner but had no idea she was homeless until Rogers took her in (Alice hadnât wanted her to know), one day she brought her a backpack with some new clothes, hygiene stuff, snacks, and puzzles because she could tell Alice needed things like that.Â
She spent hours in the bookstore, becoming friends with Belle as she did, she was constantly (unknowingly) recommending books to her spouses while they were cursed. When they buy a house after the curse breaks there are bookcases full of books all around the house.Â
Sheâs rather type A, just like Kian, sheâs hyper organised which comes in positive when they are going out somewhere. Sheâs also very competitive, particularly when it comes to board games (she sometimes lets Alice or Emma win).Â
She became Emmaâs teacher in Storybrooke when Emma joined, she made sure to give Emma all the extra help she needs, she bonded a lot with her and strongly supported David fostering Emma during the curse, but felt a little jealous that she didnât.Â
David:
He was partners with Rogers under the curse and had a crush on him during it but thought it was just because they work together in what can be a high pressure environment. He also had a crush on Ruby who he talked to and jokily flirted with at the diner at least once a day, and Snow who he met in the hospital.Â
He was shot the week Emma came to town. In hospital he met Snow, Emma, and Alice. Snow was volunteering there and Alice was snooping around trying to figure out what was going on. Emma was part of Snowâs class volunteering and she started to talk to him. They see each other in the diner all of the time, when he realises that she ran away from her foster home and was living on the streets with Alice and a few others, he becomes an emergency foster career and fosters Emma (while Rogers takes in âTillyâ)
His apartment in the city is really modern and rather big (his cursed self was pretty well off (because he wasnât the one who Zelena mainly cared about affecting) He felt bad when he realised even the things he took for granted Emma had never had. He was much happier when they bought a slightly more homely feeling house when the curse broke (plus it meant both he and Kian could try and convince their wives to get a dog - âOne that isnât Rubyâ âYouâre both in the doghouseâ)
After Emma moves out of Snowâs class and into a new one they find that she isnât being helped at all and is basically ignored, they have to choose between finding a school in the city which can help her better, or David homeschooling her, or a mixture of the two.
Heâs pretty athletic and is an avid runner and can even beat Ruby, he competes every year in a few marathons and races, often for charity. He lets Emma and Alice âtrainâ with him, often before they have baths and go to bed⊠mostly to wear them out.
Alice:
Alice was conceived when Kian had a one night stand a little while before he got into a relationship with David, Snow, and Ruby (he slept around a bit in the hopes that he would stop feeling things for his true loves). The lady tracked him down a few weeks after Alice was born and said that she didnât want Alice and she was now his problem to âdeal with however he wantsâ, he was not about to abandon (or worse) his daughter. He fell in love at first sight, he prepared to leave because he assumed no one would want to raise someone else's baby, but his spouses would never do that. They also fell in love straight away, Alice knows her story, and that family isn't made of blood but of love.Â
Alice was nearly 5 when the curse hit and had been very excited about her mommy going to have another baby, especially when she was told the secret (that it was going to be a girl). She actually helped choose Emmaâs name, out of two options (with strong hinting from Snow that Emma would be an amazing name).In the Enchanted Forest she was taught chess by her papa. She started to play chess against him again when the curse started to break when Emma came to town 6 years later. Sheâs really good at it and it helps her to organise her thoughts and figure out the curse to go on to break it with Emma).She was meant to go through the wardrobe with pregnant Snow but the curse fell before her Hook could get her to the nursery.She told her parents that she was going to marry a girl when she was 4, she pointed out that she was right when she got her first girlfriend.
She had been living with a neglectful couple during the curse so she ran away when she was young, sheâs good at living on the street and can parkour pretty well. Emma was in a similar situation and the two found themselves drawn to each other, when Emma ran away Alice looked after her, the two were constantly together. She became a informant for Detective Weaver, which is how she initially met Rogers. She was eventually looked after by Rogers.Â
When the curse broke it was rather overwhelming to fully remember her pass as well as being aware of the six nearly seven years she missed out on having her family. She broke down yelling at all of them when she didnât think Emma was around to hear. Zelena had only cast the curse as she saw how happy Snow was when she was pregnant with Emma , and wanted to be the ruler instead. So Alice shouted (out of being overwhelmed and a little jealous) that if Emma hadn't been thought of she would never had her family stolen from her. Emma heard and ran away, Alice was the one who found her and assured that she honestly didnât mean it, no matter what she never shouted anything like that again.
When she was a teenager she was diagnosed with bipolar disorder. Her parents help her a lot with managing it, but sheâs still getting used to it. Sheâs starting to notice a difference between how she feels when sheâs on her medicine and when sheâs off of them.
Emma:
She came to the city when she was 6 when she was fostered by Blue and George, they were emotionally and physically abusive towards her from the first night she was there, so it took her a short time to run away from there and onto the street. She became best friends with Alice and August along with a couple of other street kids.
She has autism and ADHD. She autism was the reason the people who were months away from adopting her decide that they didnât want her - her parents pointed out that thatâs not her fault and that the other people were wrong to give her back because sheâs autistic. Snow (or Mary Margaret) was the first teacher to really invest in her and actually help her.Â
Sheâs worn a hearing aid in her left ear since she was 4 and was hit by a foster mother, the same thing happened when she was in Storybrooke, only by George this time, when people had started to realise that she wasnât living there and had run away. Tilly holy Rogers and David and they arrested George and made sure that she got checked out at the hospital.Â
Sheâs nicknamed Koala as sheâs always attached to one of her parents, particularly David, sheâs a complete daddyâs girl despite claiming that sheâs independent. Sheâs always assured that itâs okay to be a little clingy, after all her sister was the same.
She carries around her important things in a backpack she's rarely seen without, her baby blanket, a teddy, sketchbooks, pencils, her kiddie tablet, etcetera. She also always has headphones with her which help when she overstimulates.Things have to be deemed very important to go in her backpack.