A warm June evening found the lecture hall to be a jovial place.  The three remaining first year students of the Gifted Studies program, Valentina, Julianna and Naveen were being celebrated.  Surrounded by their six upperclassmen, the three girls were applauded.  While no one was dressed quite as well as Eli – wearing an ivory waistcoat and pants over a black button down shirt, everyone looked great.  The fourth years had arranged a catered dinner, the fifth years set up a modest bar, and the second years, Jamie and Mike, brought in a stereo with some music.  Valentina was dancing with Eli, still marveling at the grace of his movements.  She wore a dress he helped pick out, a black sheath dress, accessorized with a bone-colored belt and matching lace half-palm gloves.
The night had been filled with a delicious food, drinks, and dancing. Â The research classes mingled and joked, not about their work but about their lives, their interests, and their experiences in the program. Â
Patrick, a handsome fifth year student cleared his throat to get the attention of the others.  It was Patrick that had stepped up to help the first years while Eli was in the hospital.  “Naveen, Julianna, Valentina!  You have survived your first year at Denvellia!  You will go down in the books as our first all-female research class!  To our lovely ladies!  Congratulations! You are second year students!”  Patrick announced in his thick Irish accent.
Hayley and David, the other fifth, now sixth year students, passed out confetti poppers to everyone. Â The students set them off one at a time, at first, but after the first four, it became a chaotic rain of colored paper and glitter. Â Eli surprised everyone by pulling three bottles of champagne from behind the lectern, and then set eleven glasses on the desk. Â His class applauded his generosity, until he took one of the bottles by the neck and started shaking it vigorously. Â A chorus of playful screams rang out as Eli popped the cork, and he sprayed the others with alcohol. Â When the champagne shower subsided, Eric and Gianna helped pour and hand out the glasses, and the Gifted Studies program began their toasts.
“To Valentina, Julianna and Naveen, the newest members of our family!” Hayley lifted her glass.
“To Patrick and Elijah, for leading them into the fold.” David toasted.
“To Elijah, for having the balls to take Dr. Utkin’s place!” Eric laughed through his toast.
“To Valentina, for finding a way to get that stick out of Elijah’s ass, even if she had to go up there after it herself!” Jamie joked.  Eli was too drunk to be embarrassed.  Instead, he pulled Valentina into his arms for a kiss as their friends laughed.
“Who do we toast for Duke’s dropping out?” Mike asked, getting another round of laughter.  Pulling out of the kiss Eli raised his glass, pointing to himself.  He didn’t let Valentina go, keeping her close to him.
“You did not!” David accused.
Eli nodded insistently, and let Valentina speak for him.  “He says that he conquered Duke’s woman and shamed his masculinity.  Also, Eli’s drunk, and lusty.  But really, it was Billy Duke that led to his own undoing.  He is now the unhappy father of a bawling baby girl.”  Valentina felt a little guilty for making a joke of Liebe and Billy Duke’s misfortune, but they did bring it on themselves.  Before she could feel too badly, Eli pinched her butt.
Around them, their friends toasted and celebrated. Â She wondered if every June was like this for the Gifted Program. Â Did the other programs celebrate this way? Â She had never seen Eli so happy in lecture hall. Â He was wearing a smile he usually reserved for more private scenarios. Â Ignoring the rest of the room, Eli caught her mouth with his, giving her a passionate kiss. Â His hands slipped around to the small of her back, pulling her to his chest. Â Valentina put her arm around his neck, placing the other hand to his face. Â Around them everything stopped. Â They both expected to have drawn attention with their affection, but everyone was in shock when Eli finally let Valentina go . Â The room was silent. Â The music had stopped.
Thump-step-step. Â Thump-step-step. Â Thump-step-step.
“Meester Coates.  What have you dune to the lecture hall?” Dr. Utkin looked around in wonder.  “Eet smeels leek France een here.”
All the students rushed out as fast as they could, leaving Eli and Valentina alone with their teacher.  Valentina’s scar was camouflaged in the flush of embarrassment.  Eli quickly tried to straighten out his vest and act like he wasn’t drunk.
“Dr. Utkin, we are so sorry.  We were just celebrating the end of the semester.  I suppose things got out of hand.”  Valentina tried to explain.  She found her way back to Eli’s side and took his hand.
“And wheech one are you, dear?” Dr. Utkin poked his cane at the empty bottle of champagne on the floor, the same one Eli had used to celebrate.
“Oh, my apologies.  I am Valentina Lytton.”  She suddenly felt hot.
Eli tugged at his collar and rubbed his face. Â He felt panicked. Â He put his hand to his chest, moving it in a circular motion around his heart. Â He pointed to himself, and then made a sweeping motion across his left palm with his right hand twice. Â Eli fixed his glasses. Â He was feeling sick. Â Was this was what normal teenagers felt when they got caught by their parents?
“Eeleezhah, what has happeened? Nyet to the room.  What happeened to you?” Dr. Utkin stepped closer to inspect Eli’s appearance.
Eli made the circular motion in front of his chest again, his eyebrows knitted together above his glasses. He’d disappointed Dr. Utkin.  With his hands poised before him, he moved his hands, palms down from side to side, and finished by putting his lips to his right hand before making gesture with his thumb pointing up toward the ceiling.  His face looked pained.  Valentina became worried.
“Eli, are you okay?” Valentina put her hand to his forehead, but couldn’t tell if he was feverish, or simply worked up from the surprise.
“Eeleezhah, calm down.  We can talk about all thees in the morning, da?  Do not worry about the mess.  I weel have it cleaned up.  Go home, geet some reest, and stay out of trouble.”  Dr. Utkin clapped Eli on the shoulder.  By now his student was going white.  Eli moved his hand from his chin out ward as Valentina led him away.
The celebratory spirit was gone from Eli. Â His hands were shaking as Valentina hailed a cab. Â He took off his glasses and rubbed his face. Â His eyes were stinging. Â Unaware of what was going on around him and wrapped up in his own mind, Eli was surprised when Valentina pulled him into the backseat of the taxi.
“Eli, what happened in there?  You weren’t acting like yourself?”  Valentina worried over him.
“No, that was me back there.  I disappointed Dr. Utkin.  I was supposed to take care of the program.”  Eli held his head in his hands.
“You did take care of the program, Eli.  Don’t be so hard on yourself.  You only feel badly because you are so drunk.  Let’s get home.  You can take a warm shower, and I’ll make you some tea.  You’ll feel better in the morning.” Valentina promised him.
When they arrived home, they did just that.  Valentina pointed Eli in the direction of the bathroom.  As he stripped off his layers of clothes, he could hear Valentina calling the dogs, taking them out for a walk.  He caught his reflection in the bathroom mirror as the water heated up.  Eli barely recognized himself; he’d changed so much recently.  His mind, either clouded or clarified by alcohol and guilt, wasn’t sure if those changes had been positive. Â
Somehow, he stumbled into the shower and tried to relax under the hot water.  His career at Denvellia was most likely over.  He should probably start looking for a job.  A real job.  This decade-long academic fantasy had been fun, but he knew it couldn’t last forever.  What else could he do?  He’d been a student for nearly all of his life.  Eli was going to end up working in the furniture store with Levi after all.
At once, the alcohol went bad in his stomach, probably from his worrying. Â Eli clumsily rushed from the shower before he threw up his dinner. Â When he was sure he had nothing but bile left in his throat, Eli brushed his teeth and finished his shower. Â He left his glasses on the counter as he wandered back into the bedroom, not bothering to even dry his hair. Â Eli found his way into a clean pair of cotton pants, and then into bed.
Out in the hall, he could hear Valentina. Â She was back from taking Dinah and Ceres out, and talking to them. Â After another moment she entered the bedroom. Â Eli was thankful she was alone. Â He loved his dogs, but he was not in the mood to have two growing-ever-larger foxhounds climbing on top of him.
Valentina went into the bathroom for her own shower, which was far less eventful than Eli’s.  It was a quick task, and with the champagne washed from her hair and skin and her make-up removed, Valentina quickly wove her hair into a French braid.  She slipped into a t shirt and a little pair of sleep shorts.
Eli looked up at her when he heard the soft sound of plastic on his nightstand. Â Valentina had set down his glasses, and then slipped down to sit on the edge of the bed beside him.
“You left them by the sink.  Do you want that cup of tea?” Valentina ran her fingers through his wet hair.  Subtly, she checked for a fever, or any other last effects of his sudden sickness.  He wasn’t sure how she knew he’d vomited, and even with his aversion to being taken care of, he appreciated her touch.
“Is this the price of happiness?” Eli asked, ignoring her question.
“This is the price of drinking too much, too quickly, yes.  But the price of happiness?  I don’t know.”  She watched him, his eyes were red and barely open.
“What do I do if I’m expelled?” Eli felt around for her hand.  When he found it, he placed it over his heart. “This is the only life I know how to live.”
“You’ll just start a new life.  And you’ll do whatever makes you happy.” Valentina assured him, keeping her voice soft.
“What if I can’t?”  His voice caught, even telepathically.
“What if you can’t what?  Why wouldn’t you be able to be happy and start over?”  She asked, confused.
“Every choice I make seems to cost another.  I have these gifts, but what did they cost me?  For my happiness and love with you, I have to give up my work.  What if to find my next happiness, I have to give you up?”  Eli reached up to touch her face.
“Elijah Coates,” Valentina asked sadly, “Why don’t you think you deserve happiness?”
“What have I done to earn it?” Eli had started to cry.  His tears were contagious, Valentina’s eye welling up as well.  Her heart was breaking for him.  Valentina wanted to hope it was just the alcohol talking, but she was afraid he earnestly believed he had to fight for the right to be happy.  And not just to be happy.  Eli seemed to believe he had to earn each and every bit of happiness in his life.
“Eli, you are an amazing man.  You are smart and strong, and you are a good person.”  Valentina sniffled, holding back tears. “You don’t need to earn your happiness.  But even if you did, you already would have awarded yourself a hundred lifetimes of happiness.”
He blinked back his tears, and pulled her down to his chest.  Eli wrapped his arm around her and held her close.  “I love you, Valentina.  If nothing else, I have you.”
“I love you too, Eli.  Now, please… Get some rest.  I’m sure things will look better in the morning.” Valentina kissed his forehead.  She shut off the light beside the bed, and crawled into the blankets beside him.  As Eli put his arms around her and kissed her good night to the cheek she managed a small smile.
As they fell asleep she wondered over something her father said. Â Murroh once said that Eli reminded her of her biological father, Mischa. Â Now she wondered if Mischa would admire Eli, and see Murroh in him. Â The last thought she had before sleep was a worrying one. Â How did she manage to date her father twice over?