29.10.2025, 00:06
“The less you eat, drink, buy books, go to the theatre or to balls, or to the pub, and the less you think, love, theorise, sing, paint, fence, etc., the more you will be able to save and the greater will become your treasure which neither moth nor rust will corrupt—your capital. The less you are, the less you express your life, the more you have, the greater is your alienated life and the greater is the saving of your alienated being.”
― Karl Marx, Economic & Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844
Marx describes how capitalism flips life upside down. He’s saying: the more you deny yourself living, the more you accumulate wealth. The less you enjoy, feel, love, or create, the more money you can save, and in capitalism, that saving becomes your measure of success.
But this comes at a cost. You become poorer as a human being even as you become “richer” in possessions.
This section appears in Marx’s discussion of alienated labour, where he begins outlining one of his core early ideas, the concept of alienation. Marx identifies four dimensions of alienation in capitalist society:
Alienation from the product of labour.
Alienation from the process of labour.
Alienation from one’s “species-being” (human essence).
Alienation from other people.
The quote mainly illustrates the third type: alienation from one’s species-being. According to Marx, human beings are naturally creative and self-expressive; we realize ourselves through productive, conscious activity and social interaction. However, under capitalism, this creative potential is subordinated to the accumulation of capital. People no longer produce freely for their own fulfillment, but instead produce as a means of survival or profit.
In this quote, Marx is showing how capitalist logic encourages self-denial as a way to accumulate wealth. Every human act that expresses life (eating well, socialising, studying, creating) becomes seen as a cost rather than a value. The less one lives and enjoys, the more one can save; and in capitalist terms, this accumulation of savings becomes a sign of success. Marx argues that this inversion, valuing “having” over “being”, is a core symptom of alienation.
This connects to several of Marx’s later ideas. In Capital (1867), he develops the concept of commodity fetishism, where social relationships between people appear as relationships between things (commodities). Objects and money seem to possess value in themselves, detached from the human labour that created them. This process extends the alienation he described in the Manuscripts: the products of human activity gain independence and power over their creators.
The quote also anticipates the concept of reification, later developed by Marxist theorists such as Georg Lukács. Reification refers to the process by which human qualities and relationships are transformed into measurable, object-like forms. Under capitalism, time becomes quantifiable (“billable hours”), creativity becomes a “marketable skill,” and personal identity is shaped by ownership and productivity.
Marx’s argument is not moralistic but structural. He is not simply criticising greed or materialism; he is describing how the economic system itself reorganises human behaviour and consciousness. Capitalism rewards accumulation, so self-restraint and reduced self-expression become economically rational behaviours. In the process, human life becomes a means to sustain the system of capital, rather than the system existing to sustain human life.
