Sammie's "The Wilds" Fic Recs
I read a lot of fics so I thought I might make a little "master" document of all the fics I've read and really liked! A link to the fic, the author, and a blurb about what I enjoyed about the fic below 💛
Show Continuations
Waiting on a Miracle by shepard_2077
Shepard picks up where season 2 leaves off so cleanly it's like I never actually stopped watching the show. They've written the characters so accurately that I actually watched the show in my head as I read -- this is my own personal S3, and has been since I read it. I highly recommend reading this fic if you're itching for closure for the story. It does focus more heavily on Leah and Fatin's relationship and how that develops -- the fic is written entirely from their POVs -- so if that's a deal breaker for you, it's better you know now than later. It's also got a sequel!
After the Fall by shepard_2077
Speaking of sequels, here's the sequel to "Waiting on a Miracle"! It's going to spoil the ending of the previous fic for you if I say too much more about the fic itself, but it's important to note -- this fic is still updating as of writing this post. We're at 20/26 chapters, but Shepard is a writer worth waiting for! If you love long chapters, these two fics are for you.
Mad Girl's Love Song by ThornedRose44
Another continuation fic, this one starts similarly to "Waiting on a Miracle" but immediately takes a sharp left turn. It's a shorter fic, sitting at just about half of Miracle, but it's not any less gripping of a story. If you like the thriller genre and works that make you think, you'll absolutely love this fic. Be careful though, it has a very good chance of making you cry!
Alternate Universes
Where the Wild Things Grow by filmfanatic82
I've made a post about this fic before (here) so it's a no-brainer that it ends up on this list. It's a beautifully-written summer camp AU that captures the essence of friendship, love, loss, and what it means to fight for what you care about in less than 200k words. I actually wish this one was longer! Each chapter is a different POV from a different Unsinkable; filmfanatic82 knows these characters like they created the girls themselves, and it's proven in the way these chapters are divided and written.
Old Flame by twop69
This fic... this was the first long Shoni fic I ever read, and it set the bar high. The quality of the writing itself is lovely. It's a slow burn (no seriously: S L O W B U R N), it's classic Enemies to Lovers, Toni's a firefighter and Shelby... well, I'll leave some things as a surprise. But it's cute, I think I read the whole thing in 3 days I was so hooked on it? My wife was impressed and excited that I'd found a fic that had so thoroughly hooked me. It's worth the read, really.
Return to the Wilds by filmfanatic82
This one I always want to toss into the "continuations" pile but it's not really a continuation, it's more an alternate timeline than an alternate universe: and it kind of follows "Mad Girl's Love Song" in some of its premise. It's also written by the lovely filmfanatic82, who knows these girls like the back of their hand -- so it's a multi-POV fic and it is a great one at that. It's gripping, it has action, it's still really similar to the source material compared to the last fic of theirs mentioned. If you like "more island scenarios with the girls," you'll like this one.
I'll add more fics as we go, so keep checking back on this post! I've definitely read a ton more, I'm just being a bit selective with what I write in great detail about ☺️


















