when did nancy fall out of love with steve ?? O: when did that shift btwn season 1 and 2 occur ?
NANCY NEVER STOPPED LOVING STEVE . she did , however , perceive it as that . or , okay , the better way to describe this would be that she had her doubts . around the summer before s2 , she began to isolate herself . it was subtle , and it was largely due to bouts of horrific depression and anxiety flare - ups which coincided with the canon i hold for her which is that she takes medication to keep her symptoms under control and she often forgets or punishes herself by not taking them . i think this time in particular is hard for her . she gets paranoid about her relationships , and her guilt melds with her paranoia , and it’s constantly telling her : you don’t deserve this , this is too good for you , it can’t be this good .
so , i think a big part of it is that she’s convincing herself that she doesn’t love him because on a subconscious level she feels guilty for being with him , and for being happy with him . he represents life before the upside down . he represents good things , or innocent things , and it feels weird for her to be with him still as if nothing happened . as if he didn’t break her heart , and more importantly as if she doesn’t have lingering guilt over the fact that he and her were together while barb was dying . that she heard barb in that scene and didn’t stop what was happening to check on her . she’s mad at herself , but because it’s such a hugely complex emotion , her head takes it out on steve .
now , timeline - wise , this is set in motion ever since s1 and after the right moves situation . i think that shakes her , originally , and i don’t think they ever have a proper conversation about that so it lingers in the back of her head . now , that said , i think it gets worse during the summer , and it makes her feel uneasy . what really triggers anger directly towards him is the party / barb’s parents hiring murray to look into the case . it triggers something for her . and her hurt and her anger is actually towards herself , but him trying to give her an out ( let’s just be stupid teenagers ) makes her angry . not because of him . because she doesn’t feel like she deserves to have fun like that . and it’s complicated . she’s not self - aware of her self - hatred . so she misplaces it .
she doesn’t think she doesn’t love him until he says it to her , because that’s not what i hc her to have meant by the line “ like we’re in love ” . she meant for the focus to be on , “ like we didn’t kill barb ” . because she says “ like we’re in love and we’re partying ” . she’s mocking the situation . she’s not saying they’re not in love . but the way she phrases it , of course he picks up on it , and him calling it out makes her realize a way out . she replies “ bullshit ” because she’s speaking out her subconscious instinct which is to ruin things . make it bad . you don’t deserve him . you don’t deserve this .
then the next day , he reiterates it and asks her to claim otherwise but suddenly all the guilt over the relationship finds a way to rework itself . she starts to look at it in a more easily understandable package . he gives her a reason why she’d been feeling so fucking awful , and it’s easier to face than “ i feel like i killed my best friend and i don’t want to be happy because of it ” . so instead , she latches on to that explanation . murray later hammers in the concept . finally she has a scapegoat for her discomfort , and anxiety . it’s not accurate . it’s a misjudgment of her own emotions because she is a logical person . she has little handle over her own feelings , and very little understanding . she doesn’t process her internal motivations well .
so , short answer , she never stopped loving him , and she probably never will . but she is impressionable and goes on gut instincts and rarely can work through complicated emotions , so , she believes she fell out of love with steve a long time ago . she feels like maybe she doesn’t even know what love feels like . she’s not sure , because she’s genuinely confused .