(1) Hey, Clockie! I have a question about the Blue Fusion theory. It's a nice theory and all--I don't know if I agree with it, but it brings up a lot of interesting things--and forgive me if you answered this before, but what about Blue Diamond's (the one presented as the legit BD on the show) utter and almost all-consuming grief over Pink Diamond? That couldn't possibly be fake, can it? But if it were a completely new fusion...
(2) ...how could she have such deep feelings about someone she didn't really interact with (probably)? Or maybe, is this grief genuine because the BD being presented is made up of the old Labradorite and a different Lapis that was loyal to Blue and is letting her grieve? Or something else entirely? Any thoughts on that?
My thinking at this point is that current Blue Diamond is not a new fixture.
I doubt just anybody could sidle into the position of Diamond, much less be a total dead ringer for the past Blue (if my theory is correct, outside of number of arms). And even if my theory is right, sheās clearly sure enough in her position that on rare occasions she will actually challenge Yellow.
I donāt think sheās faking her grief at all, and I do think she knew Pink personally and cared about her.
Roughly- I think a lot about the character of Lapis, and, how Lapis is very used to hiding and sneaking around. In particular, thereās been several times now where Garnet has split into Ruby and Sapphire specifically to sneak past an enemy who would identify GarnetĀ in a heartbeat.
So I have the theory that Blue Diamond used very much those same tactics.
Lapis never says exactly why she came to Earth. My hunch is she was hunting Rose- either for revenge, or because something major was not adding up about Pink Diamond. After all, we see Lapis react very strongly to Stevenās shield (that he inherited from Rose) but Lapis also so far has not said a word about Rose Quartz orĀ any of the Diamonds. To me that suggests a topic sheās avoiding in order to not implicate herself.
I think that Blue Diamond often split into her components, secretly- and Lapis would run off to be secret eyes and ears. With her maneuverability, and her unassuming appearance asĀ āmerelyā a Lapis Lazuli, she could get away with that easily.
But someone would notice if Blue Diamond disappeared. Someone might need to urgently speak with their leader and panic if they couldnāt get hold of her. Yellow Diamond suggests the Diamonds need to be on call constantlyĀ and while thatās somewhat of Yellowās workaholic nature showing, I think thereās a kernel of truth to it as well.
This is where I think the person currently acting as Blue comes in. I think that she was born, in a way, to be a Diamond in effigy.
When Blue disappears, she fills the gap. She acts as Blue Diamond. Seemingly, she can use at least some of Blueās powers- something Iād wonder if it has anything to do with the idea that Diamonds can be evoked by proxy.
But this is the easy way that her present situation could have come about. Because, again- while weāre not sure why, Lapis was sneaking around alone on Earth. And again, if Lapis was so sure her partner was safe on Homeworld, thatād suggest she left her partner in a safe place.
So... Lapis would disappear, having everything neatly in order to hold over until her return. And then she... actually disappeared, and seemingly, something else befell her partner.
But now why would the double have such a strong relationship with Pink, you might ask? Well, factoring Rose Diamond theory briefly... Rose is fascinated by people. Given the Zoo, itās fair to assume she always has been.
Rose could well have been someone interested inĀ āfakeā Blue for who she was.Ā