I don't believe I've seen it before, could I have your thoughts on the shadow paint brush? It always puzzled me somewhat why the white brush got to be just white but the black one had to be specifically shadow
I can answer your second question easily enough: when it was first released around 2001, Shadow (sometimes referred to as "Shadowed" in old news) pets were solid black fills with white outlinesβquite a bit different than what you'd expect from a normal black pet.
After a few years, they were updated to literally have heavy shadows on them, as shown below. Eventually, however, the "shadow" aspects of shadow were scrapped, but the name was never changed.
(TNT themselves seemed to have been aware of the discrepancy, because the matching petpet colour is called "black" instead of shadow.)
Anyway, there's not a lot to talk about beyond that when it comes to shadow, as it's basically just a plain base recolor. The biggest issue I have with it is that it's never been consistentβsometimes shadow pets are light gray, sometimes they're dark gray, sometimes they have bluish-purple accents, sometimes they're monochromatic, sometimes they have yellow eyes, etc. These aren't really meaningful differences, but rather just a lack of overall coherency. Beyond that, it's a nice colour that works well for customization.
Most shadow pets didn't change much after conversion, so there's nothing to talk about there.
Favorite Species:
Xweetok: All shadow pets are fairly similar so there's not a lot to talk about here, but the shadow Xweetok does look nice, with a lot of different shades of dark gray being used for contrast. The blue eyes really pop nicely here. The Acara is similar and also looks pretty nice.
Shoyru: I'm giving the shadow Shoyru a spot for one simple reason: I really like that cyan color used for the eye, which is used on this pet and no others. The blacks in the eye could've been darker, but this still looks really pretty. I like the very dark gray used as well.
Aisha: I'm honestly not the biggest fan of the shadow pets with purple-blue mixed in as a main color (outside of the eyes), but the Aisha looks pretty good. The collar is an optional wearable as always, but it also looks nice and doesn't overwhelm the design. I also really like the reshaded "A" tag, which has almost an obsidian look to it.
Least Favorite Species:
Grundo: The one on the left is a shadow Grundo. The one on the right is a grey Grudno. I think the problem should be obvious. Second-place "winner" is the Uni, which has a pretty jarring combo of blue and magenta for no real reason, but at least I can tell that one's shadow.
Weirdest Species:
Kau: [Plankton voice] Good grief he's naked!















