I had someone comment on one of my posts, and the gist of it was "...just because Elain doesn't admire Nesta..."
It's not about Elain admiring Nesta. It's about how Nesta is always there for Elain; it's about how Nesta will do anything for Elain, including marrying an abuser to keep Elain fed, or selling her body on the streets to keep Elain fed, or taking care of Elain 24/7 when she's too traumatized to take care of herself, but as soon as Nesta is too depressed and traumatized to take care of Elain, Elain turns her back on Nesta when Nesta needs her the most.
I had an Elain stan tell me that Elain just didn't know that Nesta needed to heal away from her siblings, but Elain didn't give Nesta personal space to heal. She willfully isolated Nesta, purposefully excluded her, lashed out, and then joined the IC in ganging up on Nesta, manipulating her, and was complicit in their abuse of Nesta. Elain didn't give Nesta the space she needed for Nesta's sake. Elain isolated her for Elain's sake and as a form of punishment for Nesta not healing quickly enough for Elain. She silently suicide-baited Nesta.
I get that Nesta was lashing out and hurting Elain's feelings, but Elain still had no right to turn her back on Nesta when Nesta needed her for the first time in her life. Most of the times Nesta hurts Elain's feelings, I fail to see the cruelty. Elain has been so infantilized her entire life (and yes, Nesta is partly to blame for this) that she has such thin-skin and gets hurt way too easily. I had thicker skin than her by the time I was ten. Even though I'm not a Nesta, I have worked and met many Nesta's. Nesta is every foster child I've ever worked with. She's everyone I've ever met who's been raised in an abusive home and is struggling to make the transition to adulthood. That's what traumatized people do: they lash out.
Chronic, unrelenting stress in early childhood, caused by repeated abuse (Nesta being beat, verbally abused, and groomed before the age of seven) can be toxic to the developing brain, which can lead to lifelong problems in behavior and physical and mental health. People can't expect Nesta to act like a normal 25-year-old when she's endured so much trauma as a young child.
I know of a 17-year-old foster kid who burned down his foster parent's garage on the weekend they began fostering him. Why? Because everyone had given up on him and kicked him out, so he was trying to speed up the process before he grew attached again and was left heartbroken when he believed they would inevitably kick him out. What did the foster parents do? They refused to kick him out and instead loved on him, and that made all the difference in his life. Nesta's the same way. Everyone has either abused her or neglected her or isolated her or given up on her, so she lashes out at everyone to cause them to give up on her before she grows attached, and they hurt her.
I think the reason I take personal offense to Elain's actions in ACOSF is because I've taken about 100 hours worth of training to work with foster kids and heavily traumatized individuals, and I know that Elain's approach is wrong. Elain did what I spent 100 hours learning not to do. She made Nesta's trauma all about her. She forced Nesta to heal on her terms rather than Nesta's. She made everything all about her, even though Nesta has made her entire life all about Elain.
This narrative paints Elain as the selfless one and Nesta as the selfish one, but really, Nesta is one of the most selfless characters in this entire series, and Elain is one of the most selfish. Elain is the shitty sister everyone claims Nesta is.