the walk to the backyard is painfully quiet. for once, lake doesn't crack another joke. not because she doesn't have one, but because she knows anything she says right now will either make summer angrier or encourage caroline further. somehow, she's already exhausted from trying to stand between two forces of nature.
so she lets summer speak. every word, every accusation, every sacrifice she'd carried for two decades finally given a voice. lake doesn't interrupt once because none of it is untrue. by the time summer finishes, lake finds herself staring down at the grass beneath her feet, absentmindedly rubbing the side of her thumb with her fingertip. she lets the silence settle between the three of them before finally lifting her gaze. it lands on caroline. not with anger, nor with forgiveness. just curiosity. her eyes linger on the woman standing in front of her, searching for something she can't quite name. something familiar. something that makes sense.
" you keep callin' us your girls. " her voice remains calm, almost gentle. " but ... you don't know us. " she pauses, letting the words breathe, and where summer leans on her anger to get her through, lake attempts to do the same, but all she feels is hurt and confusion and instability, which makes tears begin to prick at the corner of her eyes. " you don't know my favourite colour. you don't know that summer still cuts the crusts off my grilled cheese because the crust is always fuckin' gross and dry. " a tiny smile flickers across her face before disappearing just as quickly. " you don't know i hate mushrooms. you don't know i cry durin' stupid dog movies. you don't know where i work, who my friends are, or what my life looks like. " her throat tightens. " you don't even know who i've become. who we've become. and let me tell you, we're pretty fuckin' great, all things considered. " the words hang in the warm afternoon air. there's no bitterness in them, only sadness where all of them have missed out on something important in their lives.
lake folds her arms loosely across herself and looks away for just a moment before finding the courage to meet caroline's eyes again. " i wanted you to come back. " the confession surprises even her. " i really did. i don't know why. " she exhales softly before allowing another quiet laugh escapes her. " i think some part of me just wanted proof that ... that we mattered enough for you to come back. " lake reaches for summer's hand, her fingers slipping instinctively between her sister's. home. comfort. certainty. " i don't hate you, " she admits quietly. " i don't think i ever really got the chance to. but, i don't know you, either. " she gives a small shake of her head. " no matter what happens after today ... " her eyes never leave caroline's. " ... she's the one who raised me. she's the one who stayed. and that's goin' to be somethin' you gotta respect. "