Reflecting on this essay by Isabel Pabán Freed(whose novels I *will* read, but whose essays I know are great), and got to untethered thinking of my own fraught relationship to writing.
The profound self-critic I have is one thing, but I have felt a distinct lack of meaning in writing, and, really, most things I do. I can ascribe this to Major Depressive Disorder, which is part of it, but that provides an explanation and too many possible ways out(therapy[and a subtree of all the kinds of therapy], medication[and a subtree of all the kinds of medication], meditation[also many kinds], exercise[doing it, doesn't really work], better sleep[I'm bad at it] etc, etc). My abstracting, conceptual brain needs to attach words to these feelings, not a diagnosis.
There was a sense of meaning I had when I was younger. I would characterize it as an impulse to act from within. As my sense of self shifted to external sources, that impulse quieted and the big, unwieldy sense of obligation took over. My debt to the people who were kind to me, a karmic debt I owed a world of beautiful creatures and things. So I would get meaning from serving others - how very Catholic of me, which I was raised as, so I can trace that thought at least. But helping others, serving, obligations generally, became my life in substantial ways. I think this is good to a certain extent, but not really sustainable for writing(well maybe a certain type of writing). More generally, this sense of obligation also became work, and I took less and less pleasure in it. I needed to clear my obligations so I could get to living, but living happened only in certain ways, not the writing I wanted to be doing(not always, I've written some things). What I'm circling around is this slide from meaning to obligation, and a collapse of pleasure from that slide. Obligations become work, and all I do, and many people do, is work! And this is not the work of humans that refreshes the spirit after effort. It is terminal, a compartmentalization of work into something bad, and the rest of life as this inaccessible good thing you have to finish all your work to do. As far as anything can feel unnatural, this feels unnatural. I can only ascribe the cause to a Fordism of the mind and alienation from labor. We do so much meaningless work the poison of it breaches containment and the entire concept is rendered unlivable. So much so, we have AI to do "work" for us that would otherwise be pleasurable and rewarding with novelty, like research, writing, thinking.