Starrycoffees fanfic collection☕

Caesar

• You're already in a relationship for this one

• This also takes place sometime after battle tendency, he survived but with major injuries

• Those weeks of recovery shattered you, and you spent every possible moment by his hospital bedside

• Holding his hand and feeling he is still in this world helped, but you were struggling

• Your love, your anguish, your thoughts were too much to keep in your head, you didn't know you could mourn the living

• So one day you pour your heart out on a sheet of paper laying around

• It was freeing, and everyday you waited for him to wake up you wrote a poem

• Many were dedicated to him and the love you felt, some about how you were feeling, your situation

• Obscured and riddled with metaphors and symbolism, some even you weren't sure what they were about with how abstracted you wrote them, but they felt right

• You felt lighter, free from the weight of the world

• Once Caesar woke up, your writing slowed down but never stopped

• You expanded to journaling and short stories you'd come up with

• It doesn't take long before you have a collection of books filled with your writing

• Very early on Caesar takes notice of your writing, leaning over to lay his head on your shoulder and read your writings

• Mentioned in a previous hc, but intimacy is important to Caesar. He wants to be as close as possible to you, in every aspect, and getting to read your writing counts as intimate

• While you share most of your writing, the poems purely about him are reserved for your eyes only

• Seeing as there's quite a few, Caesar does take notice that you're gently directing him away from reading those

• He doesn't know what they're about, still he wants to read them so badly

• Begs, but ultimately respects your no

• He stares at you with such longing eyes, but won't press you any further

• When he sees your little poem books laying there he feels tempted to take a peak

• Caesar banishes the thought immediately, he's not gonna betray your trust like that

• He wants to read them, but he wants you to want him to read them too

• He wants you to feel more comfortable in baring him your heart, so Caesar will take the first step

• After a few days he'll approach you and hand you a delicately folded piece of paper

• A short, but deeply sweet, hand-written poem about you

• Caesar knows he's not as good at this as you, despite his best attempts, but the way you're staring so intently is making him embarrassed

• You lean your forehead onto his, before kissing him and thanking him

• You're still feeling a bit nervous, but now feels like the right moment to share your first writings, so you do

Joseph

• You were a good friend of Joseph, often getting dragged into his shenanigans, but you never complain

• Not when he gives you so much material for writing

• Also because you have a huge crush on him, so all his stupidity is forgiven💕

• You've been writing for a while, and it's actually thanks to granny Erina

• She noticed your crush right off the bat and encouraged you to confess, but you just couldn't

• Unbeknownst to you, Granny Erina encouraged you because she knew Joseph had an interest in you too

• You could barely manage to act like a normal person around Joseph, in your mind there's no chance Joseph would accept your confession

• Knowing your struggles, granny Erina suggests to write your feelings

• First you wrote confessions to Joseph, no intention of ever giving him those, poems about Joseph and your lovey-dovey feelings

• Then you started writing about other things, your day to day lives, struggles and bottled up negative feelings, but also about the small things that made your day brighter

• At least once a day, Joseph will catch you writing in your little books, occasionally he asks what your writing about

• He makes it a habit to randomly pick up a notebook and read through it, and while he does become invested in some of the things you write, he's kind of indifferent to most of it

• Really, it doesn't interest him that much, not until the one day when you leaped over a table to snatch the book out of his hands and closed it

• A deep red hue is spread all over your face, your breathing is ragged and you're clutching onto that notebook like your life depends on it

• You yell something at him before storming out, but for Joseph it's goes in one ear and right out the other

• Now he needs to know what your writing about, what embarrassing stuff you're trying to hide

• The next time Joseph sees you with the notebook he sweet talks you, complimenting all your writing, how skilled you are as an author/poet

• He gets reeeaaaal close and chummy with you, trying to convince you to just give him a peak at it

• After kicking him to the curb, Joseph's left to his own devices, but not at all unsatisfied as he's holding said notebook

• Yeah he swiped your little book right in the middle of your interaction, you can't tell me THE Joseph wouldn't do that shit

• He's giggling and grinning, just so giddy to see what's inside

• Five pages in, Joseph quietly closes the book and places it back where you'd find it

• He feels like a dick, aware it was probably a dick move to steal it

• Probably a dick move to not stop reading even though he already understood in the first page

• Avoiding you and making excuses for why he can't hang out with you, Joseph doesn't know what to do

• Eventually confesses his sins to Caesar hoping he'd get it and help him out, only for Caesar to almost beat him

Kakyoin

Realizing feelings

• Kakyoin is in touch with his feelings and very self aware, always analyzing himself, his actions and the world around him

• Not only that, he knows what he wants in a partner. It's the first to third encounter and getting to know you that he thinks "this the one"

• From that point on, feelings solidify fast and strong

How they act

• Kakyoin is a gentleman, he's not about to scare you away with being too forward, but he still wants to grow closer

• Tries to learn everything about you, your interests and hobbies, likes and dislikes to find a common ground

• Info dumper. Will give you random bits of information, no context and out of the blue.

• Kakyoin will be sketching you in the corner of his notebook. If you're in one of his classes it'll be a sketch of you from his pov, hierophant green will be the one looking to see how you look

• Searches for you during lunch to share food, but holds back from asking to have some of your cherries (Jotaro violently told him not to)

• Studies extra hard just so he can help you with homework, often suggest studying at each other's places if it's for an exam

Do they know you have a crush too?

• Not at first

• But as you two grow closer he reads into all of your expressions and mannerisms, and compares to how you act around other

• Goes back and forth about this a lot

• If he's right, he can go forward with his plan to date you, but if he's wrong it could ruin your friendship

• Rather quickly, Kakyoin decides to go for it

Confession

• He's the one to confess first

• He has it all planned out. Take you to an arcade/museum, go out to eat at your favorite place and then end it with an evening stroll through the park where he'll confess his feelings and ask you to be in a relationship with him

• He doesn't phrase it as a date when he asks you, and depending on what he thinks is more your tune he'll either invite you to the arcade or the museum. He feels confident in his skills/knowledge in both so he hopes to impress you

• During dinner is when it starts going sideways. One moment your laughing at a joke he said, then Kakyoin sees someone approaching from behind you, an aura surrounding as an ominous figure slips out from him

• Next thing you know, money's been thrown at the table and Kakyoin is pulling you as fast as you can go, almost making you stumble. There's yelling and the sound of stuff breaking too, but Kakyoin pulls you far away enough for it to blend into the background

• He makes up reasons to normalize and downplay what happened, he knows at some point he will have to tell you about stand user's, but it won't be today. He also didn't think he'd encounter an enemy stand user so soon

• With the mood more relaxed now, Kakyoin makes his final move: confession. He lays it on thick, naming all the things he loves about you (it's everything about you), how you make him feel like he's at the highest point, even tossing in some poetic lines

• He ends it with asking if you'd be in a relationship with him, which you accept ❤

A few dating hc

• Just like before, Kakyoin will info dump at any givin chance, please info dump on him to

• Whenever he's worried about you during school, he sends out hierophant green to check on you

• Enjoys cuddling, but not for sleeping so you resort to draping yourself over him

• A morning person, he waits so you can cook breakfast together

• Definitely would want to get you matching earrings, but will wait for a special occasion to give them to you

• Puts in effort to have actual date nights and plans a lot of it ahead, but will always ask for your input

• Imo, a lot of your dates include learning or doing new stuff together, like an origami class or making and painting pottery

• Not a big fan of pda, but does call you petnames. Dear is most common during the relationship, but as you both become more comfortable it becomes my dear  love, honey and sweetheart

• Honestly a very 50/50 relationship, you both give equal efforts in every sense. House keeping, emotional effort, taking care of each other, it's split very equally

• I can't imagine Kakyoin pushing stuff onto you purely because he doesn't feel like it, but you know each others needs and stick to your strengths

• Very healthy relationship, with good communication and problem solving... except when it comes to stand users

• The whole situation with Dio was a nightmare that can't stop haunting him, he struggles to open up about it. He only gave you a surface level explanation when he first told you about stands

• Unintentionally, he ends up pushing you away whenever dangerous stuff is going on, afraid of losing you

• Cling onto him, don't let him go and reassure him you're here to stay. Stand user or not, you're going to be there by his side

Narancia

Realizing feelings

• I can see Narancia gaining an interest rather quickly, he's the type to fall in love at first sight

• But he doesn't treat it as being in love

• No, it's just a silly little crush! It can't be that deep!

• Meanwhile he can't stop staring at you you with big eyes, making dumb excuses just to talk for a minute

• It's when he sees someone else getting a bit too buddy buddy with you, or you laughing at something they said, that he becomes pissed off

• Immediately picks a fight and scares them off, and feeling great about it too

• But now the gears are shifting in his head. Why did he do that?

• He won't finish that thought

• Fugo will though, when Narancia's struggling to do math (too distracted by seeing you in the distance), Fugo yells at him to stop being a lovesick puppy and to focus

• More yelling will ensue, and even more denial

• It's when he's left on his own that he thinks about it more and accepts it, he likes how you make him feel and he likes being in love you

How they act

• Like mentioned earlier, a lot of staring. His eyes almost become heart-shaped and the gang teases him for it

• An absolute rambler. You'll know everything about him and his day, what he ate, how studying is going, what weird dream he had last night, whether you ask or not

• Will bring you snacks to share. Narancia notices if you have a favorite snack and will bring more of those and say their for you

• He also shows you stuff he considers cool, on occasion even gifting you knickknacks

• If Narancia sees you're out, running errands, he invites himself to join you so he can "carry stuff" for you

• If you manage to fluster him, he doesn't get a full face blush and it's barely noticeable on his cheeks

• Instead his ears flush completely, so you'll see him covering his ear if you compliment him

• Bonus thing: he can't say your name without smiling and Mista makes fun of him for it

Do they know you have a crush too?

• Absolutely not, but that's not going to stop him

• It also doesn't matter if you're dropping hints that you like him too, they go over his head unless you say word for word that you love him

• And even then it takes him a minute to process what's going on

• It's not that he doesn't understand, he just wants to make sure you really mean him

How they confess

• Let's say you didn't confess and spell out that feelings are mutual

• Straight up, he asked Bruno for advice on how to romance you

• This ain't about Bruno but I still wanna mention how honored he feels, like yes his boy is taking the first steps in the dating world❤

• ANYWAY, since Bruno has a good reputation, finding a good restaurant for a dinner date is no problem

• The gang actually steps up to make sure there's no interruption from anyone

• After getting a lil pep talk from Bruno, Narancia goes to ask you out

• He's relaxed the entire way until you're in front of him, then the nerves start kicking in

• Shyly pulls out a single red rose and says it for you

• Blurts out the question if you'd want to get some dinner with him, his ears are red and Narancia's eyes will be full of hope

• Becomes ecstatic once you say yes and drags you right then and there to the restaurant

• Dinner goes as smooth as it can, but Narancia is no longer sure how to act around you and is super tense

• By the time dessert is served, he stops over-thinking it and relaxes, whatever happens happens

• He still needs a way to get rid if the physical tension in his body, so he'll ask you to go on a walk with him

• Now outside where it's just the two of you, he's feeling the mood, now is the moment and he takes your hand

• Tries talking from the heart, but he keeps starting over and over again, until he says it outright: he really likes you. Not just casual like but like-likes you

• Asks if you feel the same way (he's hoping so, since you did accept in the first place), which you do

• Really wants to kiss you right now but how do you actually kiss

• Slowly inches his face towards you until he's pressing his lips on yours

• Very awkward at it but still so sweet

• Narancia is ecstatic and on cloud 9, completely forgets that dates do need to come to an end and wants to kiss you again

• He drops you off at your place and is already scheduling the next date

A few dating hc

• He LOVES sharing, just showing/giving you stuff has him smiling like a dark as he waits for your approval

• Gives you flowers he picked from the side of the street, but he tries to make them look like a bouquet

• God forbid Narancia catches anyone eyeing you too much, he's fighting on sight

• PLEASE let him lay his head on his lap and play with his hair, he loves it so much

• Also play video games with him, but only co-op, he will be in a bad mood if you beat him too often

• If you're good at math, he starts going to you instead of Fugo. If you're bad at math, he'll go to you for cheering up and praise (kisses and hugs)

• Always physically touching you, either holding hands, arm wrapped around your shoulders or waist, draping his legs over yours, he'll even settle for interlocking your pinky fingers

• So yeah, very physically affectionate, that goes for sleeping too. He's a messy sleeper, but won't kick you off the bed- he's partially laying on top of you, no matter starting position

• He's taking any chance to cover your face in kisses, you give him cuteness aggression he just wants to smush you face

• Wouldn't mind you being a member of passione, that means he gets to see you more!

• If you're not a stand user, it does make him panic. A lot. It makes him lock in and focus on ending the fight without you getting hurt

• Does want you to get along with the gang, so you occasionally join them for normal hangouts

• Btw, not a great gift giver but he's trying. You need to be very direct on what you want

• Will always be on your side of any argument, no questions asked, he supports your rights and your wrongs

Caesar

Realizing feelings

• He's already flirting and serenading you before any feelings are there

• You either need to turn the tables on him and take it up a notch

• Or be completely immune to his flirtation and not pay him any mind

• Both will get him going and his interest in others will start to dwindle

• Caesar makes it his mission to "win" this game your playing, but doesn't realize he's playing himself to fall hard

• You keep matching his wits and beating him at his own game, it's frustrating but he keeps coming back for more

• The sweetness in his voice becomes more genuine every time he says something to you

• It's a quiet but quick realization, and he fully accepts it

How they act

• If you're a ragebaiter like Joseph, he falls for it way more easily but bites his tongue. To you, he's just seething in his seat and glaring at you

• In a weird twist, his cassanova act tones down over night

• His focus is now on learning more about you as a person and seeing how compatible you might be

• He's there at your beck and call, you off handedly mentioned wanting a specific dessert? He's already got it served and ready for you

• You're out in the city together and he sees you looking at some item at a shop with interest? Caesar buys and gifts you it

• Caesar won't make it a big deal either, either quietly placing it in your room or hand it you claiming he "happened to feel like it"

• Seeing the way your eyes light up with joy or how brightly your smile, you really are everything he could ever want

Do they know you have a crush too

• Yes

• He notices the interest is mutual while asking about your interest

• The shift in your mannerism is the biggest give away

• Lingering touches and how you look at him from the corner of your eyes, he immediately notices it all

How they confess

• He tries confessing during romantic outings, but you laugh it off

• He's done this with multiple women, you're not gonna take his words too seriously

• Frustrating for him, but he can't blame you. You were there when he flirted shamelessly and openly with multiple people

• Caesar is wracking his brain, trying to figure out how to make his feelings clear to you

• It's actually Lisa Lisa who asks you to hear him out, so you do

• You're expecting another grand spectacle, for him to try serenading you and to whisper sweet nothings to you

• But that's not the case, not this time

• Caesar is waiting for you at a bank when you join him, not many people are there, and for a while you sit in silence

• Until he takes your hand, "I truly do love you with all my heart."

• Caesar doesn't give you a chance to interrupt, he needs to confess every thing you make him feel

• He pulls you in and holds you tightly, afraid that you'll go and that he'll lose you for real

• Asks you to give him a chance, for you to be his and if he can be yours

• You return his embrace and confess your own feelings

A few dating hc

• He wants and needs to be the man of the house, doesn't matter your gender. You got an issue with something or someone? He's handling it, no need to worry your pretty head about it

• Caesar might be a romantic guy, but he likes the focus being on him. He LOVES having your attention, look at him and only him

• Praise him too and it'll get him going

• He isn't afraid of much, after everything he and Joseph went through, but he does fear upsetting you

• If he does somehow, immediately begs for forgiveness and reflects on what he's done

• Showers you in gifts, no matter how expensive your taste is he'll make it happen

• Intimacy is very important to him, and I don't mean NSFW stuff, I mean cuddling bare skin, the direct skin contact and just holding each other, hearing you breathe and feeling your heartbeat

• Speaking honestly about whatever is on your minds or in your hearts, he doesn't want you to hold back

• Takes you on extravagant and lavish dates, as long as you're indulging him