hi sharp!! i reread the series again recently (oh my GOD) and im once again thinking about debaser!sidney. god shes so cool.... those motherfuckers NEVERRR deserved to slander her name sighhh..
we spend the series seeing sidney through a very billy and stu skewed lens (duh) so im wondering if you have any author insight into sidney, her relationship with tatum, the night it went down, etc... if so i would love to hear!! i hope you are having a great day!
Hey thank you so much! Honestly one of the big challenges in this series is writing any of the women (including Nancy). Having to write them through Billy or Stu means passing them through a misogyny filter but I also try really hard not to actually write their characters in a misogynistic way? Idk I hope it's working, Billy and Stu's views of these women are not meant to come across as trustworthy.
Billy and Sidney as mirrors
Anyways yeah I've thought a lot about Sid, in my mind her and Billy are sort of mirrors. They're both real gay and so closeted they may not even be aware that gay is an option for them. They're both secretly yearning for their blond best friends, both missing their moms (in very different ways obviously). They're both the slightly quieter friend, both a little more serious but fully capable of being silly when they let loose, both a little artistically inclined (Sid goes to theatre school and Billy's personality is basically film major).
Similar to my perception of Billy, I think Sid's gender expression in high school is also a little more conforming than her preference. They're both trying to be what they think they're supposed to, both in terms of sexuality and gender presentation.
For Sid it's subtle, in the first movie she wears baby blues, a little red floral shirt, light, neutral makeup and long hair.
She has the stereotypical good girl wardrobe, and we see her struggling with that identity throughout the movie, its sort of a central theme. She's afraid she's going to turn out like her mom, she literally says so before her and Billy have sex.
To contrast, in scream 2 she cuts her hair short, starts wearing red lipstick and eyeliner. Her wardrobe shifts towards darker colours and neutral tones, she even gets herself a leather jacket.
It's still femme but its a little edgier, it feels more like Sid, and her style stays closer to that for the rest of the franchise. Billy does a similar transformation.
In terms of her relationship with Tatum I imagine they became friends in middle school or junior high. Tatum's always been the more extroverted and I think Sid has looked up to her for that. Sid is also socially capable but when she was younger I think she definitely envied how outgoing Tatum was, probably got upset and confused when Tatum started dating first. She was worried that Tatum would leave her behind for whatever boyfriend she had at the time but if anything Tatum prioritizes her over boyfriends.
Tatum is the only person who Sid feels totally understood by, totally comfortable with. Tatum was her first kiss because Sid got scared about not knowing how to kiss when she first started dating Billy and Tatum volunteered to help her practice because that's just what girls do for each other right? It's all Sid can think about the first time she kisses Billy but she chalks it up to Tatum being more experienced than either her or Billy.
I think Sid imagined the rest of her life being with Tatum, even when she thought they were both straight. Like they'd both get their husbands but they'd buy houses right next to each other and see each other everyday. Basically she always knew Tatum was the love of her life, even before she even knew she was gay.
The night of the massacre
I don't even know where to start with this. She starts the night trying to be brave, to put the past behind her and stop being haunted by her mom. That's why she has sex with Billy, it's barely about him. And then she thinks she sees him get murdered right in front of her eyes, and once the panic of the chase wanes a little the guilt sets in. She feels horrible for suspecting him before, feels the complex loss of losing someone you 1) have been dating for years and 2) just had sex with for the first time.
And then of course he reveals himself. She runs the gauntlet of emotions- shock, fear, betrayal. She feels stupid for having talked herself out of distrusting him, for having slept with him, for staying with him at all. And then him and Stu start monologuing about their plan and everything turns into rage. It reignites the pain of losing her mom and that becomes rage too. It unlocks a version of her that she hasn't seen before, the version of her that survives over and over. The version of her that taunts the killer right back.
She isn't afraid in the end of the movie she's livid and she has every right to be. It sucked to kill her off at the end of Debaser I wont lie. The movie is as good as it is because she wins in the end, I was just writing a different kind of story. She has every right to her rage and she has every right to fuck those twinks up bigstyle.
In the Debaser version she also of course figures out that Billy and Stu are fucking. I think its not actually that much of a shock when she thinks about it, the kind of thing that seems obvious in retrospect. I think that realization pisses her off even more because she would have been chill, supportive even. She would have kept Billy's secret, probably would have stayed with him as a beard. She would have hyped him up and been there to talk to about Stu.
But nah that little motherfucker just had to get stabby about it.
So yeah Sid deserves the world. She a queen, full stop.