Being part of one community but working with another is occasionally weird and incredibly difficult.
This is a post about identity, activism, energy, and work.
Now, when I say different, I’m not talking apples and oranges. I mean more like..being a fruit, but working on issues that effect...I don’t know...sharks. Maybe some issues effect both, like water pollution or climate change, but things like soil quality isn’t going to mean a thing to a shark, and things like overfishing aren’t necessarily going to do much to an apple tree.
I’m a trans* person. I say person because I don’t feel like I fit in either binary gender category, though I have days I may present as or even loosely affiliate with either (passing aside). I accept either binary pronoun, but don’t personally use they. If I could stamp an NB or an Other on my paperwork I would - though not necessarily other labels that would associate me with a “third” gender. I don’t feel like I belong in any, and I’m okay8888888888888888888888888 with that. Am I eschewing all labels? No, I just haven’t found one that feels like it fits “just right” yet, and I know for sure that the two that we build things around are definitely not right for me.
And I say that in ways that give me certain freedoms. I can wear clothes from any section of the store. I don’t have any hangups about whether something makes me appear more masculine or feminine in terms of activities or interests (something that I had to build up to, thank you internalized misogyny and consistently being told or shown that associating with something feminine would automatically categorize me as female whether I identified that way or not). I think women are strong and amazing for putting up with what they do and have the experience to understand just what that is, and at the same time I have the privilege, when I pass, of being free of some of those things - and the responsibility to raise my voice for women in a different way than I may have before, which quite frankly, feels like an honor that is also disgustingly representative of the problem of misogyny itself.
Then there’s the game of deciding whether I can use a public restroom without making someone uncomfortable or putting myself in danger. The fact that despite leaning more toward the transmasculine side in many ways when I’m forced one way or the other I don’t “belong” in men’s spaces, but also know I don’t belong or feel comfortable (for my sake but also for theirs) in women’s spaces either. Feeling like I have to “pick one” in order to function in certain environments, like when working with kids or in spaces (or whole states) where being nonbinary is unsafe.
And yet I don’t work within my community. I’m not an LGBTQ advocate by profession, or now that I’m dealing with significantly reduced energy thanks to a mild TBI, even necessarily in my off-time. I no longer work in an environment where I can be an educator about LGBTQ issues and a safe space for LGBTQ youth even though that may not be my primary function. I work with kids and families, and most of my work both personal and professional focuses on things as they effect low-income families or children in the mental health or foster care systems. How they play into abuse dynamics and how to prevent child abuse in general. They’re places where, say, trans* issues can certainly intersect, but right now in my very narrow and particular part of the world at large (specifically sexual abuse), the most I can do is educate as it comes up and connects to that narrow and particular part on a case-by-case basis and be affirming and validating and not bat an eye when someone mentions without it otherwise connecting to the situation at hand that a child is LGBTQ. I can educate on social media when I have the energy to do anything outside of work. I can call people out on things compassionately and without hesitation when I see these things even beginning to surface.
Sometimes, for those reasons, I feel like some kind of traitor to my cause. I see friends and other members of the community focusing more extensively, more publicly, more vocally, on trans* issues. I see them running classes or becoming literal spokespeople or pioneering programs and I think, “Am I letting my community down?”
When I was in better health, when I had more energy, when I could tell people “I’m really sorry, I’m too busy right now to fit in another thing” and not “I’m sorry, I’m just exhausted, I already had to cancel everything else too, I promise it’s not just you,” maybe I did more of both. When it wasn’t appropriate to focus on at work (because look, if it doesn’t play into the issues of a family you’re working with because of a host of other very pressing issues, someone’s off-handed political comment is not something to go back to just then) I could do things outside of work, like writing a column or educating educators more proactively. When it wasn’t something that came up spontaneously but there was room to address it I could bring it up myself as casual or careful way as necessary. When it was something that came up and needed to be addressed but couldn’t be head-on, I could be positive and subversive and relentless.
So, I guess this is also a post about ability and disability, too - a topic I’m still getting used to after a year and a half of major life changes that mean this has to come up a lot.
What do you do then? What can you do other than being visible and confident, and vocal as things come across your field of vision? When you don’t have the energy to spare from basic function to go looking for ways to speak out, because there are no shortages of reasons? What responsibility do we have to our community, to ourselves?
My first responsibility has always been to kids. That’s where my passion lies. And do I have a special responsibility to kids who are also LGBTQ? You damn right I do. But can I narrow my focus to kids within my community, so that I can dedicate more energy to my own community?
I can’t. There’s so much work to do everywhere, for everyone. It means sometimes getting overwhelmed on multiple fronts - your own, the populations you work with, the populations tangential to them, the places where they all intersect.
So am I shirking some inborn responsibility? Even on days where I feel like the answer may be “no,” I can’t help but feel like it.