Are the Blacks physically abusive in your fics (specifically Dissonance and Disrupted Allegiances)? I think I remember Bellatrix and Andromeda getting slapped once or twice by their father(?), but is that like a recurring thing where they get hit/hurt for just about anything, or is it a once in a while sorta thing (with their father only or the rest of the family)???
No clue if this made sense, but yeah. I want to know more about the abuse they faced at the hands of their family (Sirius, Bella, and Narcissa, and so on).
Ohh, that's a good question, anon!
Yeah, they are. Unfortunately.
You see, they're obviously a very dysfunctional family with waay too much power, money and complicated relationships. There's no doubt they love each other, but that love isn't alway healthy (actually, most of the time it's pretty toxic). I wouldn't say they were beaten all the time, but yes, it definitely happened.
It really depends on which family member we're talking about. The Blacks in my fics grew up believing they owned everything (and everyone). The definition of old money: power, wealth, influence, beauty.... and very strong personalities. Mix all that with the rise of blood purity ideology, the Dark Lord and two wizarding wars and you've got the perfect recipe for toxicity 🫣
The most violent ones were Sirius II (our Sirius's great-grandfather) and Cygnus (Bella, Andy, and Cissy's father). They both had terrible tempers and absolutely hated being challenged. Old Sirius constantly hit Arcturus (Sirius's grandfather) because Arcturus had a quieter, more introvertd personality, which Sirius II saw as weak. Cygnus, on the other hand, always resented the fact that he only had daughters, and Bella was the one who got hit the most because, well, we all know she never backed down from a fight. Andromeda and Narcissa were smarter about avoiding their father's temper, but once Andy rebelled, she got the worst of it too.
As for the Grimmauld branch of the family, Orion (Sirius's dad) wasn't hit very often. Arcturus genuinely didn't like hitting his son, so it only happened a handful of times (Orion truly was the perfect son, he only disappointed Arcturus twice in his entire life). Walburga, who also has a very strong personality, was hit by her mother (Irma), but never by her father. Pollux never laid a hand on his children, which Arcturus always judged him for because, well, look how they turned out.
Ironically, Walburga would've never imagined herself hitting her own children, but Sirius had (and still has!) a very special talent for getting under his mother's skin. So they screamed, argued, and every now and then she did hit him. As he got older, she mostly slapped him across the face, but eventually that stopped because he ran away from home. Regulus, being much smarter about these things, was always the well-behaved son. He got hit more when he was really little (for normal kid mischief), but as he grew up, he quickly figured out exactly what he could (and couldn't!) get away with.
If Sirius ever had kids (would he? 👀 lol), he would never hit them. He'd definitely want to sometimes, though, because obviously at least one of them would inherit the (in)famous Black personality.
James was never hit (truly the golden boy), and Lily got into some fights with Petunia when they were little (classic sibling fights). Remus and Pete were never hit either (I hate the HCs that make Remus's dad abusive).
Well, this got pretty long, but I hope it gives you a better idea. Obviously I'm against violence, I include it in my fics because I think it adds another layer to the complicaded dynamics of the Black family.