ABYSS WALKER - what do they hope is waiting for them on the other side? do they believe in a set afterlife, or do they imagine itβll be something different?
SEND ME A QUESTION FOR A HALLOWEEN THEMED ANSWER!
ABYSS WALKER - what do they hope is waiting for them on the other side? do they believe in a set afterlife, or do they imagine itβll be something different?
Bless you for sending me this question. If there's one thing I love, it's meta about Doctor Who, and this is going to let me talk about so much meta. Strap in, anyone who dares read this - you're in for a wild ride! I'm going to be drawing mostly from New Who, and RTD's Who in particular, since that's what I've seen the most.
So, Doctor Who actually has a rather uplifting message about the afterlife. One episode that comes to mind is Voyage of the Damned. The Doctor's brief companion Astrid Peth dies at the end of the episode, and the Doctor tries desperately to bring her back to life. He can't do it, and in the end, he has to let her go, and this happens:
THE DOCTOR: Now you can travel forever.
(He points sonic screwdriver at a window, which opens. Astrid turns into specks of light.)
THE DOCTOR: You're not falling, Astrid, you're flying.
And Astrid flies out of the window and into space, and it's implied that she goes on, existing among the stars, the way she always wanted to in her life.
One could even take an example from an eleventh Doctor episode, The Doctor's Wife, where the TARDIS's soul is put into a human body, allowing the time machine sentience. At the end of the episode, her body expires, but the soul of the TARDIS floats before the Doctor in glowing light, looking very much like an angel. She and the Doctor have this conversation:
IDRIS: I've been looking for a word. A big, complicated word, but so sad. I've found it now.
THE DOCTOR: What word?
IDRIS: Alive. I'm alive.
THE DOCTOR: Alive isn't sad.
IDRIS: It's sad when it's over. I'll always be here, but this is when we talked, and now even that has come to an end.
They go on, but that's the important part in reference to the topic of the afterlife on Doctor Who. She eventually fades away, but it's shown that the TARDIS is still "alive", in some way, even if her physical form is gone.
It's a lovely, uplifting message, perfect for the philosophy of a children's show like Doctor Who. While the Doctor himself seems to fear and outrun death (literally changing his whole body and personality to escape it, with the tenth Doctor's last words being I don't want to go) I'd say that the overall message of the show is that there is something better out there, some life after life on earth.
Conversely, Torchwood takes a very different, darker, look at the afterlife. And, since both shows exist in the same universe, and Torchwood includes several characters who have died and come back to life (most notably, Captain Jack Harkness) then we have to assume that Torchwood's philosophy on existence after death is the correct one within the universe of Doctor WhoΒ (A.K.A. the Whoniverse).
JACK: Why are you doing this?
SUZIE: Because life is all, Jack. You should know. I'd do anything to stay. Anything.
Suzie Costello is an ex-member of the Torchwood team, and a recurring villain in two episodes of the show. In her second appearance, she is raised from the dead, and, in an effort to escape death, she drains the life out of Gwen Cooper. When asked why by Jack, she replies the above line. Because life is all. But, unlike the Doctor's eternal life, his ever-changing attempts to outrun a final death, Suzie's quest to keep living is shown as wrong, and selfish. Even though, it seems, she has every right to fear what comes next. She says the following, of existence after death:
GWEN: So when you die, it's just --
SUZIE: Darkness.
GWEN: And you're all alone? There's no one else?
SUZIE: I didn't say that.
And, later, another member of the Torchwood team dies (Owen Harper), but he's also resurrected (it's a crazy show, seriously) so everyone can have their final goodbyes. The team believes he only has a minute or so until he dies again, so Jack's by his side, trying to prepare him before he goes again.
JACK: Sorry, I had to [bring you back] to help you prepare. I know what death is. I want you to be ready.
OWEN: There's nothing. Just darkness.
To cut a long story short, Owen doesn't die again, and he sticks around, as a living corpse. Martha Jones asks what it's like after death, and Owen says that there was nothing, but that "[Suzie] said there was something beyond life. Something in the darkness, something moving."
This is never disputed within the canon. All characters who have died and come back to life (Jack, Suzie, Owen, and a few minor side characters) talk about the same thing -- darkness, and nothing, except the sense that something is out there.
Interestingly, any character's quest to escape death across both shows is framed as immoral and selfish, or a literal abomination against nature (unless you're the Doctor, in which case never dying is actually good). Suzie is shown as selfish, draining the life from someone else to stay alive; Owen is seen as a freak of nature, existing beyond his natural life; the Doctor himself is literally afraid of, and repulsed by, Jack Harkness, who simply cannot die. Jack is an offence to the natural order of the universe, a fixed point in time and space that even the Doctor can't heal.
Which brings me to the other character whose main drive is to escape death: the Master. The Master not dying is actually an in-universe running joke at this point, so much so that at one point, Missy just says to Clara Oswald "Death is for other people", and gives no explanation as to how she survived a supposedly fatal encounter. Even John Simm's incarnation of the Master uses a secret cult with a magic ring to bring himself back from the dead, and just somehow survives being trapped in the Time War in The End of Time.
But, unlike the Doctor, the Master's quest to escape death is shown as evil, wrong, and even perverse. He steals bodies (as Geoffrey Beevers) lives through painful disfigurements (as Peter Pratt and Beevers again), drains the life out of others in order to live (as Simm), and even becomes a snake-like ghost thing in order to keep living (as Eric Roberts -- the 1996 film is such an experience) all to escape death. Heβs resorted to possession, cannibalism, and witchcraft. Unlike the Doctor, who is simply given extra regenerations in The Time of the Doctor, the Master has blagged, stolen, cheated, and murdered his way through countless bodies, all in a bid to stay alive, or come back to life.
Why would he do that? Why be so afraid to die, so desperate to come back to life? Because he knows what's on the other side. He might never stay dead, but he has died, multiple times. Even when he was in his Saxon body, in the show, he willingly died rather than be the Doctor's prisoner. But he came back. Because he doesn't hope something is waiting for him on the other side. He knows it is. The same thing that awaits everyone in the universe of Doctor Who. The darkness, and something waiting in it.