Sawyer Scholastics, LLC

People often say that everyone in the U.S. has “inalienable rights,” no matter their age. But the truth is more complicated. Children do have rights, but they are not the same as the rights adults have. The Supreme Court has made this clear in many cases.

Kids have constitutional protections. For example, in Tinker v. Des Moines (1969), the Supreme Court said students have free speech rights at school. In In re Gault (1967), the Court said minors have due-process rights in juvenile court. Children also have the right to be safe, to get an education, and to not be abused. So they aren’t without rights.

But here’s the key point: children’s rights are limited, and they are often controlled or filtered through their parents. Parents in the U.S. have what the Supreme Court calls a “fundamental right” to direct the upbringing of their children. This comes from cases like Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925) and Troxel v. Granville (2000). These cases basically say parents get to make most decisions about their kids—things like schooling, medical choices, religion, where they live, and how they are raised. Because of this, a child’s rights don’t function the same way an adult’s rights do. A parent’s authority usually comes first unless the child is in danger.

The state (meaning the government) can step in if a parent’s decisions put a child at risk. This is based on the idea of parens patriae, which means the state can act like a “backup parent” when needed. This is why the government can remove a child from an abusive home, force medical treatment to save a child’s life, or require kids to go to school. In these situations, the child’s safety overrides the parent’s rights.

There are a few areas where older minors get more say. Some states allow teenagers to make certain medical decisions on their own, especially for things like mental health care, birth control, or substance-abuse treatment. This is sometimes called the “mature minor doctrine.” But it doesn’t apply everywhere, and it definitely doesn’t give minors the full independence adults have.

If you haven't subscribed yet, do it now! Like and share, please.

I'm up to 100 subscribers! 🥳👍 First milestone reached! Now let's go for 500! Spread the word by sharing this post, please! https://youtube.com/@SawyerScholastics