Time Drags On
Pt. 18 — This Love
cassie mckay x f!reader
summary: cassie's back from ohio and at your front door.
warnings: slow burn, age gap (reader is 26, cassie is 42), angst, hurt, comfort, mutual pining/yearning, smut, oral (r!recieving), scissoring, dacryphilia (kind of), cuddling, service top!cassie, bottom!reader
word count: 3.5k
a/n: this series was named after and is inspired by the song crying during sex by ethel cain. so uh… yeah. that is all.
soundtrack ‧₊˚♫ ˊ⊹
MASTERLIST
Your eyes have to be playing tricks on you.
“Ca-cassie?” you whisper, feeling like you’re staring at a ghost.
The woman in front of you clasps her hands together and presses her lips together to form a smile. Her dimples pop perfectly into place, a detail you almost forgot about her. She’s wearing her green jacket, the shirt underneath is the one you wore the morning after your first and only night of loving passion.
Your brain is barely commuting that she’s here in front of you. Cassie’s here.
“Hey,” she murmurs, her voice like honey to your ears.
“Wha… what are you doing here?”
Cassie inhales sharply and takes a step closer to you, now just inches away. “I just…” Cassie lifts her hands like she’s about to cup your face before balling them into fists and dropping them to her sides. “Fuck,” she sighs. “I needed to see you. I’m done.”
“Done?”
“Done with Ohio. I’m moving back here. I don’t give a fuck about that fellowship. I miss seeing my son regularly. I miss my dad. I miss my usual AA meetings. I miss my job. I miss my house. I miss Pittsburgh. And I miss you,” Cassie lists breathlessly.
“But… what…” You swallow hard, your eyes glossy as you stare into Cassie’s ocean blue ones. “What does that mean?”
Cassie lets out a humorless laugh, her hands flying to her hips. “It means I can’t fight this any longer.” She lets out a shaky breath, her steady voice lowering into something more quiet and vulnerable. “I’m so sorry that I kept pushing you away instead of just dealing with my feelings.”
“You want to be with me?” you ask apprehensively, your voice trembling.
“Yes,” Cassie answers right away. “If you still want me.”
The grip you have on the door handle tightens, as does the ache in your chest. Your head is spinning, still in disbelief that the person your heart has been craving is finally right here. She’s right here and she wants you.
Unable to get any words out, you just nod.
With your silent confirmation, Cassie wastes no time with closing the distance. Her hands fly to your face, cupping your cheeks. The second her lips meet yours, it’s like a homecoming, every lingering doubt falling silent. Instinctively, you gently grab Cassie’s wrists, every piece of you settling back into place as you melt into her touch.
You walk backwards, Cassie following you into your apartment. Without breaking the kiss, she kicks your front door shut. You guide her further into your home as you pour everything you’ve been feeling into this frantic, warm, long overdue kiss.
“You came back,” you murmur against Cassie’s lips.
“I came back,” she echos, sure and glad.
Cassie caresses your cheeks before dropping her hands to your waist, gripping onto you like you’ll disappear any moment. She moves with you, all personal space gone. Blindly, you walk backwards to your bedroom. Cassie moans against your lips as you stumble into a wall. She then breaks the kiss momentarily, glancing over your shoulder before connecting her mouth back with yours.
Reversing the roles, Cassie now walks backwards, heading to your bedroom. The only other time she’s been in your room was on the Fourth Of July. It felt like years dragged on since then. But it also felt like that day happened yesterday, recalling so clearly how your limbs tangled together as you both drifted into a peaceful slumber.
“We don’t have to,” Cassie murmurs between kisses as the two of you enter your dim bedroom. “Do.” A kiss. “This.”
“You don’t want to?” you question, still kissing Cassie.
“I—” She’s cut off as you press your lips against hers, kissing you back for a few seconds before pulling back just enough to speak. “I don’t want you to—” Cassie shudders, your mouth finding her neck. “I-I don’t want you to feel like you have to. Or if you’re not ready.”
“Please,” you whisper against her neck, ready to beg if that’s what it takes.
“Are you sure?” Cassie asks, sliding her hands all over your back, remapping the space she’s worried she forgot.
“Mhm,” you hum against her skin.
“God.” Cassie sighs as she surrenders. “I miss you so much, baby.”
You whine in response, one of your hands holding the back of her neck while the other dances across the small of her back. Cassie walks you backwards to your bed as you continue to shower her neck in heated kisses, each one feeling like a silent vow.
When your knees hit the edge, you sit down. Cassie crawls onto the bed too, continuing to kiss you as she makes her way to the headboard. Once there, you gently push Cassie, her head falling against a pillow. Then you climb over Cassie’s body, tucking some hair behind your ears before leaning down and attaching your mouth on hers again.
Cassie’s hands wander under your shirt, running wild all over the surface of your back. She starts to tug the fabric up, going slow to allow you time if you want to stop. But you encourage her, bringing a hand to the bottom of your shirt to help Cassie remove the barrier.
After she throws it on the floor, you slide a hand under Cassie’s oversized t-shirt, your palm lightly pressing against her stomach. You can feel every little reaction coming from Cassie as your hand glides across her sensitive skin. Your fingertips hit the lower cup of her bra, wanting—no, needing more.
“Wanna feel you.”
Cassie closes her eyes and moans at your words, her nimble hands finding your ass. “Me too, baby.”
With Cassie’s eager permission, you remove her shirt, tossing it so far that it lands on your dresser, knocking over the jewelry tray that was sitting on the edge. You couldn’t care less though, your mind solely focused on Cassie.
She squeezes your butt, you involuntarily arching your back as she does. Your soft stomach is pressed flush against Cassie’s, your guys’ breathing able to be felt by the other. Cassie moans into your mouth, the sound shooting straight to your core.
“Let me take care of you,” Cassie pleads, pulling back enough to look in your eyes. She takes in your flushed appearance, your lips parted as you breathe in through your mouth. Cassie reaches up and tucks a piece of hair behind your ear, her hand then holding your cheek. “Please, baby.”
“Okay,” you whisper, Cassie’s tender expression nearly making you cry.
Carefully, Cassie rolls you over so she’s on top. Then she hooks her fingers in the waistband of your pajama bottoms, glancing up at you before taking them off. Instead of removing your underwear next, Cassie reaches around her back and unhooks her bra, letting it fall off her chest.
“Cassie,” you whimper.
“I know,” she hums, offering you a smile. One of her hands finds your thigh, rubbing it soothingly. “Just relax.”
You nod and let your head fall back onto the pillow behind you. Cassie starts to remove your underwear—not urgently, but not slowly either. Once they’re off, Cassie takes a moment to admire you, imprinting the image of your bare form to her brain. Then she parts your legs, touching you like you’re something fragile she’s trying not to shatter.
Cassie leans down, hooking your legs over her shoulders. She then licks her lips and takes a breath before diving in. The second her mouth makes contact with your cunt, a cry escapes you. Your hips start rolling against Cassie, unable to stop your restless body. You fist the sheets and bite down hard on your lower lip, trying to hold out.
“You taste like heaven,” Cassie purrs, her hot breath hitting your sensitive clit.
Cassie’s tongue glides from top to bottom, finding home by your entrance. Her tongue pokes through, a broken moan falling from your lips at the gratifying feeling. One hand stays clutching the covers while the other flies to Cassie’s head. Your fingers tangle in her brownish red hair, guiding her motions.
Still working her mouth on you, Cassie blindly reaches up. Through half-lidded eyes, you spot her arm extending up to you. Releasing the sheets, you grab ahold of Cassie’s hand. She gives you a firm squeeze, her strong tongue thrusting in and out of you ravenously.
“You know I thought about you every single day, right?” Cassie mumbles against your pussy, the words barely intelligible.
“Me too,” you confess, a sharp gasp then escaping you as Cassie’s nose bumps your hardened clit.
“And—” A thrust. “I love you.”
Gripping onto Cassie’s hand and scalp tighter, you moan loud, her words turning you on far more than they should. You glance down to look at Cassie only to find her staring up at you. The sight of her between your legs could probably make you cum all on its own.
Your eyes start to get glossy again, overwhelmed by all the powerful feelings swirling inside of you. Cassie’s efforts grow more intentional, knowing how to push you across the finish line. Your hips buck up to her face, chasing your high. Cassie lets you, not caring that her breaths are shallow. She devours you like you’re her oxygen.
“Cass,” you whine as blissful and bittersweet tears pool in your eyes.
Cassie squeezes your hand as if to say I’m here, her movements never faltering. She goes faster. Harder. Determined to make you feel good.
The bridge of her nose keeps brushing against your clit, your hips grinding relentlessly onto Cassie’s face. With your orgasm only seconds away now, hot tears fall down your cheeks, overwhelmed in the best way.
“Gonna—”
Cassie moans into your cunt, letting you know she knows you’re right there. The vibrations of the intoxicating sound she let out heighten the ecstasy coursing through your veins. With one more thrust of her tongue, your legs clamp around Cassie’s head, and you climax.
Your back arches high off the bed as several high-pitched moans leave you. You’re gripping Cassie’s hair so intensely that you wouldn’t be surprised if you pulled out some strands. As pleasure courses through you, you squeeze Cassie’s hand bruisingly tight, your knuckles turning white. Your broken cries fill the room as you use Cassie how you need, your mind fuzzy.
Cassie doesn’t resist. She welcomes it.
Her tired tongue continues plunging in and out of you, swirling the determined muscle against your spongey walls. With purpose, Cassie angles herself so you can utilize her nose to get off, your arousal covering her whole face as she pants, her face red.
When Cassie can tell you’ve rode out your high completely, she pulls back and presses soft kisses between your thighs. She stays down there for a few minutes, kissing and sucking on your sweaty skin not hungrily, but affectionately.
Then Cassie climbs up your body, sensually and lovingly kissing all over your neck and face, expecting nothing in return. Your tired hands come up to the back of Cassie’s neck, holding her closer to you while she peppers you with adoring kisses.
“Baby,” Cassie coos, her hot breath in your ear. “Do you think you have one more in you?” she asks breathlessly and without pressure, letting you take the lead.
“Mhm,” you whine, never going to max out on Cassie.
She kisses your cheek, and then wipes a tear away with her tongue, leaving your skin wet with her saliva rather than your salty tears. Your eyes close, cherishing the feeling of Cassie’s warm body on you.
She surprises you with a kiss on your lips, you instantly melting into it. You can taste yourself on her, the smell of your arousal woven into her face. When Cassie breaks the kiss, she sits up, rubbing her thumbs over your hips before climbing off of you.
“C’m’here,” Cassie murmurs softly, grabbing your hand.
Cassie helps you sit up too. You watch as she moves silently, kicking off her jeans and boxers quicker than you can process, still feeling hazy from your orgasm less than three minutes ago. Then Cassie sits against the headboard, motioning for you to come over. When you’re in reach, she grabs your waist, eagerly tugging you onto her lap. You glance down between your bodies, Cassie’s slick glistening in her dark curls from only eating you out.
“Baby,” Cassie coos, your eyes raising to meet hers. “Here,” she says, gripping your right thigh to move your leg under her left one.
You hold onto Cassie’s shoulders, letting her move you how she pleases. Once your leg slides under Cassie’s thigh completely, you moan and dig your fingernails into her skin, your pussies colliding.
“Is that comfortable?” Cassie asks you as she looks up at you with the most adorable puppy eyes you’ve ever seen.
“Yeah,” you reply, hooking your ankle around her waist.
Cassie’s palms spread across your lower back, keeping you close. “You gotta adjust to find the right angle, okay?” Cassie tells you gently. “Move around for me.”
You nod, and then look down. You wiggle around to find what feels best, Cassie not moving as you do. Just looking at your cunt touching Cassie’s is making you more soaked than you already are, your arousal building without any actual friction.
As you adjust slightly, your clit hits Cassie’s crotch in a way that sends pleasure down your spine. You moan, Cassie pushing you forward to encourage you. Your body takes over, beginning to grind against her.
“That’s it,” Cassie mutters, a groan leaving her after she gets those two words out.
You wrap your arms around Cassie’s shoulders, leaning even closer to her. She meets your movements, grinding in sync with you. Wet, lewd squelches fill the room along with both of your heavy pants. The sounds circling the air around you fuel your desire, your hips starting to move quicker.
“I’m serious,” Cassie mumbles, then moaning as your clits bump.
“Hm?”
“I love— mmph— you. And I’m not just saying that because I’m— oh, fuck— having s-sex with you.”
You moan before telling her, “I know.”
Cassie leans forward, kissing your collarbone, her tongue dragging across the slender bone. “I don’t want you to ever think I don’t love you, baby.”
Tears begin to well in your eyes again, Cassie’s words hitting you deep inside your heart. This is all you’ve ever wanted.
You drop your head to Cassie’s shoulder, hiding your face from her. “I know,” you repeat, your voice breaking both due to a moan and emotion. “I love you too,” you tell Cassie, then kissing her shoulder.
Keeping one hand on your lower back, Cassie brings the other to your head, cradling the back of it. “Hey, hey, hey,” she hushes, stroking your hair while continuing to rub her heat against yours, though, her movements slow a little. “Look at me.”
A single tear falls, landing on Cassie’s freckled shoulder. You left your head, your pink and swollen lips parted as you breathe heavily through your mouth. When you lock eyes with Cassie, your hips instinctively twitch, your drenched folds jutting up into hers. Cassie tilts her head, affection and love being sent to you through her gaze.
With her thumb, Cassie brushes away the stray tear that rolls down your cheek. She gives you a soft smile, her lips parting seconds later as a moan spills out. You grip Cassie’s back, clinging onto her like she’s the first deep breath after being underwater too long, nearly drowning.
“I’m almost there,” you whimper, your hot core grinding against Cassie’s faster.
“Me too,” she cries, her knees buckling straight as her coiling release creeps up.
Cassie leans forward, pressing a fleeting kiss to your lips, then on the corner of your mouth. When she pulls back, her grayish blue eyes meet yours right away. As Cassie holds your gaze, it’s like she’s cracking your soul open, what’s spilling out is raw grief, love, and hope all tangled together.
“You’re so pretty when you cry,” Cassie whispers hoarsely, her thumb brushing away tears you didn’t even know were falling. “You’re always so pretty.”
You nuzzle into her hand and whimper as your climax begins to boil over. Cassie can tell, making an extra effort to rub her pussy harder against yours. You cry out and moan as you see stars, your whole body shaking.
Seeing and feeling you come undone like this is what sends Cassie over the edge. She desperately moans your name, her hand on the small of you back pulling you impossibly close as she ruts her cunt into yours. Cassie’s shuddering release reaches every nerve, all the pent-up tension in her body gone. Her eyes try and flutter shut, but she wills them open, needing to look at you. She’s so close to you that she can faintly see her reflection in your eyes.
Once your orgasm fades, your body grows limp. Feeling the change, Cassie guides you to the mattress, setting you on your back before collapsing too. Her breathing is still ragged, not as in shape as she used to be. Your shoulder touches Cassie’s, the subtle contact a reminder that she’s here.
After a minute of silence and recovery, you roll onto your side to face Cassie. She turns her head, a sweet smile breaking out on her lips as she meets your gaze. You’re quiet for a few long moments, finding the courage and words to say what’s on your mind. Cassie lets you gather your thoughts, her kind eyes reassuring.
“Are you really not going to leave?” you whisper, terrified of the answer.
Cassie’s face immediately softens more than it already was. Her brows pull together as she turns onto her side, your eyes dropping to the sheets instead of her.
“Baby,” she murmurs as she places a hand on your arm, that single word making your heart flutter. “Hey,” Cassie softly says, her other hand finding your chin, gently tipping your head up to look at her again. “I’m not leaving,” she tells you firmly. “I’m staying right here. I’m sorry that I left in the first place and for putting distance between us. Even before I moved, I created space and pushed you away, and I’m so sorry.”
You grab ahold of Cassie’s wrist, feeling the beat of her pulse with your thumb. “Okay.”
“Okay?”
“I’m still mad,” you admit. “And hurt. But I also want to forgive you— I am starting to already. I just don’t want to be hurt again.”
“I promise I’ll do everything in my power to keep you safe from that.”
Your eyes sting with tears that don’t fall. “I believe you,” you whisper, your features softening and the corner of your lips curling upwards.
It feels like a weight’s been lifted off of Cassie’s chest. She lets out a relieved breath, a smile then settling on her face. The hand Cassie has on your arm drops to your waist, gently pushing you to her.
You scoot closer to Cassie, her arms immediately enveloping your frame. You bring a leg over Cassie’s while one of your hands finds her side, resting on her bare skin. Like it’s the most natural thing in the world, you lean forward and kiss Cassie’s forehead, then the tip of her nose, and finally her lips.
When you pull back, Cassie pecks a final kiss to your mouth before settling into her space. “I don’t want to be away from you like that again. It hurts too damn much to miss you,” Cassie confesses as she grabs one of your hands, kissing your knuckles. “Being torn away from Harrison when he was little was a different kind of pain, one only a mother can experience, but I still felt that same empty, aching hole— just in another part of my heart.”
You nod, recalling months and months ago, not long after you first met when Cassie mentioned that she temporarily lost custody of Harrison. It’s reassuring to know that you’re that intertwined with Cassie’s life. With Cassie. Like you’re a part of her.
“I’m just glad you came back home.”
“Me too,” Cassie says before kissing the back of your hand again.
She then rolls onto her back, her arms still around you. Once she’s settled, you curl up against Cassie’s side. She loosens her hold on you so you can get comfortable, but the second you still, her hold on you strengthens. You let out a content sigh and trace the freckles on her chest with your pointer finger, able to feel her heart beat.
“I love you a lot, Cass,” you whisper. “You make me feel seen. And safe.”
Cassie closes her eyes, fighting back tears. “I love you too,” she whispers back. Cassie then kisses the top of your head, your hair tickling her nose. “So much.”
You curl up more, draping a leg just below Cassie’s waist. Her fingernails dance across your back soothingly, comforting you without words. Your body fits so perfectly against hers, like it knows it belongs there.
Like it’s found home.
╰┈➤ Next
taglist (CLOSED): @somemetallyillbitch @killah28 @bigstupids @lovvrr @mil1an @noprophet @escapereality4music @angryoilslick516 @mxtokko @abbotitts @wewerewildandflourescent @likesomethingidk @longfulforlee @winstonhelp @sadoutlaw @theworldscalamity @bsttwice @randomstuff02sblog @beingniceisntahobby @geekyandgay98 @cmckaysdollpuppy @banginglikeahurricane @hehehehahahohohuhu @eatmykittycatt @midnitewaves @dixondeers @moonshoesdekarios @secretlyurfemmwife @elliskies @taliiiaasteria @luv-brd @gf4lwt @mwah-w4ddingh4m @dragonfruit-depression @starcrossdlover @boiiiiigenius @gwhaley127 @quakee4eva













