heyyy, I was wondering if we could have the batboys with a s/o who is hesitant and cynical about love?
maybe they've had negative experiences in past relationships and have kind of given up on it altogether. so when the boys try to flirt or indicate they're interested they don't take it seriously, or think the boys are messing with them.
also, how would the boys try to earn the readers trust? what would their reaction be to the reader not taking their advances seriously?
βNo other heart will do.β
3 posts in one day? Look at me go!
Batboys x Reader :Cynical!Reader
β’Bruce realizes fairly quickly that you donβt reject romance because you dislike it,you reject it because you donβt believe it lasts.
β’Every compliment he gives you is met with, βYouβre just being polite,β or, βYouβll change your mind eventually.β
β’The first time he asks you to dinner, you genuinely assume itβs a business meeting.
ββ¦Bruce, you know you donβt have to pity-date me.β
β’He blinks. βI wasnβt aware I was.β
β’Bruce doesnβt try to argue you into believing him. He knows trust isnβt built through speeches.
β’Instead, heβs relentlessly consistent. He calls when he says he will, remembers the little things you mention, shows up when he promises, and never pressures you to define the relationship before youβre ready.
β’What surprises you most is that he never seems offended when you doubt him. Thereβs a flicker of sadness sometimes, but never anger.
β’Eventually he tells you quietly, βYou donβt have to believe in love today. Just believe that Iβll be here tomorrow.β Then he proves it.
β’Dick flirts so naturally that you assume he flirts with everyone exactly the same way.
βYouβre beautiful.β
βYou probably say that to all your friends.β
ββ¦I absolutely do not.β
β’The first few times, he thinks youβre joking.
β’Then he realizes you genuinely donβt believe heβs serious.
β’ That realization breaks his heart a little.
β’Instead of turning the flirting up, he changes tactics.
β’He starts showing you affection through actions rather than words,bringing you coffee before you ask, saving you the last slice of pizza because he knows itβs your favorite, walking you home even if it means going out of his way.
β’If you thank him and say, βYou donβt have to do all this,β he just smiles.
β’Dick wants you to feel loved before you ever feel obligated to say it back.
β’He never rushes you, even when he desperately wants to.
β’Jason catches on almost immediately because he recognizes the habit of expecting disappointment.
β’Every time he says something genuine, you brush it off.
βYouβre incredible.β
βYouβre laying it on a bit thick.β
ββ¦No. Iβm really not.β
β’At first he gets frustrated,not with you, but with whoever made you think sincerity always comes with an ulterior motive.
β’He stops trying to impress you and starts focusing on making you feel safe.
β’Giving you a spare key without expecting one back.
β’Showing up when you need help without making you feel like you owe him.
β’Never disappearing after difficult conversations.
β’One night you quietly ask, βWhy are you still here?β
β’Jason looks genuinely confused.
βBecause I said I would be.β
β’Tim initially assumes youβve simply missed his hints.
β’Then you respond to him asking, βCan I take you to dinner?β with,
ββ¦That wasnβt what I meant.β
β’ You laugh awkwardly because you think heβs teasing.
β’Tim quickly realizes your instinct is to reinterpret anything romantic into something safer.
β’Instead of making bigger gestures, he becomes incredibly clear.
βIβm flirting with you.β
β’That question catches him off guard.
β’He spends a long moment looking at you before answering honestly.
βBecause I like who you are when nobodyβs watching.β
β’Tim earns your trust through transparency. No mixed signals, no games, no making you guess what heβs thinking.
β’He knows uncertainty only feeds your doubts, so he chooses clarity every time.
β’Damian is baffled the first time you dismiss his interest.
βI enjoy your company.β
βYouβre being nice.β
ββ¦No. I am expressing interest.β
β’You assume heβs joking.
β’Once he understands your reluctance comes from past hurt rather than lack of interest, his approach becomes surprisingly patient.
β’ He never mocks your cynicism or tells you to βjust trust him.β
β’Instead, he quietly becomes one of the most reliable people in your life.
β’If you need him, heβs there.
β’ If he makes a promise, he keeps it.
β’If he says heβll protect your heart, his actions begin reflecting that long before you believe the words.
β’ The day you finally admit, βI keep waiting for you to get tired of me,β Damianβs expression softens.
β’He takes your hand and replies simply,
βBelovedβ¦ I do not invest my heart carelessly. If I have given it to you, it is because I intend to keep choosing you.β