Coll Parker: #1 DuJour Fan

Fiction is not reality and pretty much every genre of fiction has certain standard ways in which it deviates from reality. And I’m not just talking about how we shouldn’t nitpick the physics of how Superman is able to fly. There will be ways in which the characters’ behavior and relationships will be informed by the genre as well and it makes just as little sense to judge them by realistic standards as it does to complain about something in Star Wars being scientifically implausible.

For example, “Adults are Useless” is a well-recognized trope in children’s literature. But that’s not because children’s authors are all going around writing adult characters who are terrible parents or teachers. It’s because the protagonist of a story written for children is almost always going to be a child, and the protagonist of the story has to get into trouble and solve problems themselves for the story to be any good. Yes, in real life, teenagers shouldn’t be fighting in a war. But if the grown-ups stepped in and stopped the teenage protagonist of your action-adventure series from fighting, there would be no story.

Does that mean the grown-up characters in that series are evil people who use child soldiers? No, because we accept a child being in these kinds of situations as a conceit of the genre of children’s fiction, and we interpret the characters and their choices accordingly. We don’t apply a realistic standard because the very premise is unrealistic to start with.

Another example: An adult hitting a child in real life is horrible. But if the child is a superhero, and the adult is a super villain, and they are in a cartoon, then we can’t read it the same way. All cartoons with any kind of action or fighting in them use violence unrealistically, and if the child and adult characters are presented as equally matched adversaries then that’s how any violence between them has to be understood. The villain might be a real bad dude, since he’s, you know, a villain, but hitting a child superhero in the context of a super-fight does not make him a child abuser, specifically.

I’m focusing on children’s books and cartoons here because I think that’s where tumblr fandoms have the biggest trouble with this but it applies to everything. Characters in a romantic comedy won’t behave realistically, characters in fairy tales won’t behave realistically, characters in police procedurals won’t behave realistically, all of them will behave as characters within their specific genre have to in order to make that genre work. The second you start trying to scrutinize every single action a character takes by realistic standards, you miss the point.

And this doesn’t just apply to complaints, but also praise. Nobody said it better than Ursula K Le. Guin:

Sometimes parents and children dont click. Wednesday and Morticia are very different and can run eachother the wrong way, but they still love eachother and work within eachothers boundaries (or at least morticia works within boundaries, Wednesday is young and has a hard time with emotions so they're difficult for her).

A great example is the fact that morticia doesnt force her physical affection onto Wednesday. In most shows it would be a joke that wednesday hates it but cant escape it or she would just accept it after their argument is cleared up. But that didnt happen here. In the first episode she sees her off by caressing the sid instead of Wednesday's face, and after their issues are resolved she does the same. And its great.

And the thing that made me post this, "I'm sorry you felt like you couldn't come to me with this." No guilting, no offense taken, just a genuine apology. And it's so great to see depicted in media.

#That’s it. #That’s the show 

THE BATMAN (2022) dir. Matt Reeves

+