Reminder: There Is No Canon to Creepypasta and Frankly, There Shouldn't Be
I already made a post about this (it was actually my first one), but I have gotten better at conveying what I'm trying to say here. I donβt know how many people will actually see this, but I hope some do because I think this is really important given how the fandom is going these days.
There is no canon to Creepypasta.
Did you really think the people who made Slenderman or Jeff the Killer planned for them to star in an AMV where they battle to the death with Fall Out Boy playing? Or that theyβd be featured in cute ship animations and oWo storylines? Of course not. And the same goes for nearly every character in this space.
But people kept creating. We invented the idea of a shared universe. We gave it lore. We gave it depth. We gave it ships, AUs, Proxies, tragic backstories, and haunted mansions.
There. Is. No. Canon. There never was, and there never will be. And thatβs a good thing.
We can do whatever we want with these characters. We already do.
Want a model for this? Look at the SCP Foundation. Itβs got hundreds of characters, monsters, and stories and no true overarching timeline. Many of those stories contradict each other, and thatβs the point. SCP works because it embraces creative freedom. Creepypasta can do that too.
In fact, calling things βheadcanonsβ doesnβt even make sense when thereβs no actual canon to begin with. If your βheadcanonβ changes a backstory, a relationship, or the emotional tone of the world, itβs an AU. And thatβs not bad! AUs are where the most fun happens.
Jeff and Liu can be brothers or enemies. BEN Drowned can be a dead kid or whatever AI hivemind he was in the ARG. Slenderman can be a Lovecraftian nightmare or a weird neutral forest God. You can write horror, slice of life, romantic drama, or comedy.
We donβt need a Creepypasta wiki like SCP has, but if we had something like that? Something that gave space to all these alternate takes without arguing whatβs βtrueβ? It could help.
Because at the end of the day, we should feel free to tell whatever the Hell stories we want with these characters and the universe. IF ANY!
You can just have owo Yaoi, Yuri, and whatever a "straight" ship is! You want slice-of-life shenanigans in a mansion Slenderman owns for some reason? GO. FOR. IT. Itβs valid.
Thereβs no canon. Thereβs only you, your weird brain, and the stories you want to tell.