Spoiler ahead
Interpretation/analysis of Naoya Zenāin. We love our bastard.
Naoyaās arc.
Naoyaās role in the story.
What Naoya represent (meaning) as a character in the story.
The reception of Naoyaās character: about how his misogyny was romanticized and trap in the idea of the redemption of misogynist.
Naoyaās arc start and ends with Makiās mother. First, letās talk about how the narrative built the story. Itās important to understand that we canāt understand the story just reading lineally or chronologically. This is because the recent events tend to signify the past events. Read this story is an exercise of going back and forward in the time line. And this happens with Naoyaās arc, you can only truly understand Makiās mother and her connection with Naoya in the end.
The first scene of Naoya start with him answering a question where Maki's mother ask for her daughter.. As we donāt know who this lady is, we just ignore her. When she meets Maki and we realize that she is her mother we get a deep understanding of that first scene and what was that line. She asked Naoya about her daughters. When Naoya speak rude about Maki and Mai in front their mother, Gege make this panel to show the womanās reaction. She remains silence but in an uncomfortable silence to his statement about woman getting stabbed if they donāt walk three steps behind a man.
When I first read this panel, I wonder why āstabbed in the backā. Why, if womans are son weak, why stabbed in the back which is a way that a coward would take. In that moment I though it was because the woman walks in front of the man so she is giving the back to him so is a way to punish that attitude. Is very thoughtful phrase, because it get re-signify when Makiās mother kills Naoya. That expression is subverted with the mother final action, which is the action when she breaks the submission.
To have a deeper understanding of Makiās mother I made a post about her psychology as an abused woman and how Naoya ends makes perfect sense. I wonāt repeat it here because this is about Naoya, but I recommend you to read it.
Letās talk about Naoyaās personality. He is a very self-confident person, very arrogant and clearly quite proud of himself. This is an obviously result of him being born with his fatherās technique and clearly superior to others possible heirs. He was told that he was the next leader of the clan, he was told he was great. And he believes it because he grow up in the privilege of being what his family wanted him to be.
Itās almost ironic how he admires Toji when he is the representation of what Toji dislike. Naoya is a āchild blessed by his parentsā (Toji said this to Suguru). I donāt believe Toji had any interest in Naoya or even talked to him (maybe few words) before leaving the clan. Toji wanted to probe that a person who was a deception could defeat a blessed child. But when he thought in a blessed child, he thought in Satoru Gojo, the most blessed of all. And the thing here is that Toji and the rest considered a fact that Naoya didnāt, the fact that he born with a secondary cursed technique and not the main inhered cursed technique of Zenāin. The true blessed boy is Megumi. Naoya was pretty fine to be the next leader until Megumi unveiled his technique. But that was something that Naoya was aware of, probably blinded in his own arrogance. That is why he was in shock when Naobitoās testament was read.
We know that Naoya also like Satoru. He likes him in the way he wants to be like him. He wants to be the strongest, someone who stand out from the rest. Ironic again how he is what Satoru dislike, a conservative asshole. This irony is portrayed by Gege in this panel where Toji and Satoru are not looking at him, which it means they werenāt aware or if they were they didnāt care or liked Naoya.
I believe Gege is portraying in Naoya the lie of the status quo of Jujutsu world. Those who rules the jujutsu society and the rules they make up to sustain those structures are not thoughts to the wellbeing but to sustain those structures and the power of those who are in the top. Naoya, as the rest of them, deeply believe that they are worth of their position and they get to decided over the rest, and to use their lives as tools. But they arenāt that great at all, they power depends more in the authority they had built and the obedience they get than in true power. So, we see Naoya going very confident to kill Yuuji and Megumi and he fails to defeat Choso. And get a look down from Yuuta.
Choso vs Naoya. Both are portrayed as the opposed of the other. Choso is someone who gains happiness and a meaning of existence in his relationship with his significant others, particularly his brothers. Naoya is someone who doesnāt care of anyone except of himself. He was actually very happy about Naobitoās dead (we canāt blame him for that). I believe is this part of the story his opposition to Choso helps to built Chosoās character. But it also represents the corruption of Jujutsu society, who are more interest in keep they position than to protect the world, help others or do any kind of good. We can easily see that when they are more concerned in execute allies than do something about the culling game and Kenjaku. Naoya is what the leaders of Jujutsu world are, including the lame part.
And all this is because Naoya is the result of a conservative system. Maybe if he was born in a decent family, he would be kind of different, maybe, we can not know that. But what we know is that all the shit he is saying panel after panel was learned. Those questionable values were learned from their family. Clans are like littles hell holes where everyone hate each other. Love is a way of resistance in this type of environments, maybe that is why the only character who felt true love were able to break that idiosyncrasy. But Naoya is all comfortable in that idiosyncrasy because he is the privilege one. I donāt believe there is a path where Naoya could break the ideas which he was raised and redeem himself or become something else. If Gege chose to kill him in the downfall of Zenāin clan is because Naoya was not only a character who represented those structures but also someone who was absolutely okay with it. The privilege one donāt organically question the structures where they are in the winning side.
Finally, lets talk about the reception of this character. Particularly in those who are romanticizing him.
Disclaimer: I do like Naoya, I think he is hot and I found very funny all those post like ātaking a break from feminism with Naoyaā.
I donāt believe there is any problem in linking him or making erotic fanart or fic or wherever. The problem is romanticizing him in order to excuse his misogyny. And what is the problem? Goes in the wrong direction to understand the misogyny as a problem.
There is so many posts where the main idea is that all he need is the right woman to be a better person. And that is a false idea. Its problematic and dangerous. Iām concerned about girls and people in general thinking in this way. Because there is no big issue with a fictional character (is just fiction) but if you think is this way, would you be able to recognize violence when it happens to you? Would you be able to recognize that you boyfriend is a violent person and you have runaway and not stay to try to change him? I donāt know. I really donāt know. As Iām not sure either I donāt know, I believe its important to reflect on this. Just reflect, Iām not censorship none, I just think is important to reflect what we like and what we like of that and how we interpreted the things we like.
The problem with romanticizing misogynist is that it creates an illusion that they can change with the "right woman". There is no such a thing like "right woman" to end violence in a man. Is an inner aspect of those men which are the result of patriarchal cultural system, in which this man were socialized. Can a misogynist love? Of course, but they think in woman as their belonging and if this woman doesnāt feel the same, she could end up murderer. If we look straight in the canon there is no sign about Naoya thinking in woman like something different than objects. So, think, what kind of love you can show to an object?
Naoya has a problem of power with the rest of his family, not a conflict of values. He could probably kill his entire family to obtain the leadership, but he would end up reproducing the same behaviors and idiosyncrasies of his family. Because he has no problem with that, except for the part where he is not the leader.
The problem with hot assholes in that we quickly forget they are assholes and romanticized them make them look less shitty and make them fit in our desires. If naoya was ugly this conversation wouldn't even exist. But he's handsome and everyone's want to believe that he is nice in the deep of his heart. I donāt see anything bad about simp a villain but keep this in mind about romanticizing misogynist.
As patriarchal cultural system raised violent man, also raise woman to tolerate and even value that violence. So, keep your eyes wide open. We have to unlearn a lot of things we learned.
Let me tell you that I really love Naoya character, it was simply amazing what Gege did with him. I would like to see him more like any simp but I believe his ends was perfect.
If you want a interpretation/analysis of Toji, let me know.
If you read until the end you deserve heaven <3
Feel free to leave your opinions and disagree.















