A/B/O / Omegaverse ?
Highschool AU ( a personal hatred )
College AU
A/B/O is one I'm into but there's a 70% chance that I won't like how its written. When it's basically sex pollen + worldbuilding around different genders + characters are so so into each other (and a couple other kinks I shan't mention) I love that shit, A+. But it's more common to find RL Gender 2.0: Extra Bioessentialism, social conservatism treated as fact, abuse red flags treated as hot, condescension treated as hot, rape culture, controlling possessiveness, DD/LG, etc, all things I actively find gross.
High school AU is an F from me. I tried them more when I was closer to that age and never found one I liked. I'm not into slice of life, and I find that putting characters into that setting typically cuts off the most interesting elements of their character, let alone the interesting stakes of their original plots. To make a high school AU I'd like functionally requires a setup like the Worm webserial/Spiderman/Animorphs: keeping a cover identity is an active issue in this person's life, a complication; the point isn't the schooling itself. (ps Worm is fantastic but it legitimately is a content warning for almost every subject imaginable FYI, and I'm not being flippant).
College AUs are more readable to me, maybe a D-- similar issues to High School AU, but at least theres more space for the characters to still be interesring to me. Maybe 1 in 30 would be something I'd actually want to read. It'd be cooler to me if it was a Magic University situation with actual worldbuilding, I'd eat that up. But alas. I've literally never encountered a College AU with worldbuilding or original (non slice of life) plot to speak of. Oh wait I take that back-- there was one fabulous GoT author who wrote a spectacularly fucked up one about an intelligent sociopath abuser professor. That one was cool as hell. Kudos to that author.
My unflattering assessment though is that both High School and College AUs represent training wheels-- using more familiar settings in order to have to do less thinking about setting or even character actions and personality (I rarely see the characters' personalities accurately translated into the setting.) This is great for early authorial development, but not what I'm looking for as a reader. It also, I must assume, makes the characters more hashtag relateable-- but I'm generally seeking out fanfic because I already clicked with the characters in their unique setting! I'm a reader who really prizes novelty, so the removal of unique settings makes for a downgrade for me personally. Kind of counter to my personal impulse for seeking out fanfic (my reason being I want to fully explore a universe in ways that are not at all practical for a single story; to get to see it from a bunch of different angles and interpretations and scenarios.)
For all these tropes, the fact that the authors and audiences are having fun are the only things that matter, but they're not for me.
Ask me about fanfic tropes!











