Why I Still Believe in Byler After Vol. 2, and Why Vol. 2 Had to Break Us First
First of all, I want to say that after waiting an entire month and finally finishing Vol. 2, my feelings were pretty much the same as most peopleâs: deep frustration.
These three episodes felt painfully mediocreânowhere near worthy of our expectations. Whether itâs the fact that Byler didnât develop in the way we had hoped, or the overall narrative pacing that left people genuinely confused, it was hard not to feel disappointed.
Iâve seen countless discussions about these issues across sns. What I want to bring up here, though, are some points that are rarely talked aboutâthough a few people have mentioned themâand which I believe are extremely, extremely important.
With only one episode left in the entire series, the most devastating thing for Byler fans is that so many of the clues and setups we noticed in the past havenât been called back at all. Itâs reached the point where weâre starting to doubt ourselves. We were once so sureâlike Joyce noticing the Christmas lights flicker.
But please donât ignore the details. It was precisely by re-examining those details that I managed to calm myself down and reassess these three episodes. And now, I genuinely believe these choices make sense.
Letâs talk about character-driven storytelling and narrative function in screenwriting.
People have noticed that in these three Vol. 2 episodes, the screen time for Mike, Will, and El is almost nonexistent.
Fans are angry because Willâs coming-out scene felt unbearably awkward, and because it seems like the creative team intended to use that scene to close Willâs entire character arc. At this point, Byler feel completely boned, and many are convinced this is outright queerbaiting.
Hereâs the theory I want to propose first: Willâs emotional arc and character narrative are not over.
What I mean isâtheyâve clearly put all the important material into the final episode. The storylines involving Will, Mike, and El belong to the main narrative. For protagonists, their âhighlight momentsâ directly push the core plot forward.
From a structuralist narratology perspective, a characterâs high point is equivalent to a qualitative shift in the subjectâobject relationship. If you trigger that kind of narrative transformation before the final episode, you are essentially ending the story ahead of time.
So from the very beginning, the writers had to make sure that the season finale would be the most powerful episodeâand carefully decide how that power should unfold.
At the same time, this show excels at ensemble storytelling. We love every character, and every relationship between themâand that requires significant screen time devoted to supporting characters.
But when supporting characters get their own highlight moments during the storyâs climax, those moments must ultimately serve the protagonists. The narrative needs to follow the principle of perspective anchoring.
That means the writers have to âwrap upâ each strong supporting-character storyline before the final episode, giving them their own moments to shine.
Now you can see why the main characters almost disappear in these three episodes: their highlight moments must be saved for the final climax. And because the climaxâs screen time belongs to the protagonists, the writers had an enormous amount of groundwork to handle in Vol. 2.
So pleaseâstop blaming our creator for a moment, and look with me at what they actually did in these three episodes.
They gave Dustin and Steve a genuine relationship high point. Starting from Dustinâs trauma, moving through his conflict with Steve, then facing danger togetherâand finally, after the crisis, Dustin truly opening himself up and confronting that trauma head-on.
All the odd behaviors Dustin displayed throughout the season are fully explained through this arc. And through conflict and reconciliation with Steve, their relationship is elevated to a deeper emotional level.
Another Byler pair: Nancy and Jonathan.
This couple starts running into problems as early as Season 4. They canât be honest with each other, because their love was born out of shared traumaâand that pain never truly went away.
Most people have always believed this pair to be the most stable, unquestionable canon in the entire series. Because of that, many viewers didnât even realizeâuntil finishing all of Vol. 2âthat what they were actually watching was a breakup.
Of course, I still have some reservations about this particular narrative choice. People love Jancy too much; no one ever expected them to break up. But I think this is yet another example of the Duffer brothersâ fascinatingly chaotic brains. I wonât go deeper into that here.
Lumax!
I have to say, out of all the characters in these three episodes, Max shines the brightest. She embarks on her own adventure with Holly inside Henryâs mental prison, while Lucas and Rovickie fight their own battle in the hospital. These two wars unfolding in parallel had me clenching my fists in anxiety for this couple.
And when Max slowly wakes up in Lucasâs arms, we finally see them reclaim each other. This heartbreaking pairâafter enduring such a long stretch of traumaâat last reaches a moment of happiness.
These three sets of characters all receive their own highlight moments across these three episodes. The writers deliberately bring their storylines to a full emotional resolution, because the screen time that follows must serve the protagonists.
So please, stop complaining that Mike seems hidden in the shadows, or that even Maxâs wheelchair had more presence than he did.
I keep hearing people say Vol. 2 was boring, messy, or downright incomprehensible. But once you understand that the writers are carefully preserving the narrative rhythm to serve the final episode, you might start seeing these choices very differently.
That said, I still canât convince myself to accept that much children content.
I genuinely canât figure out why those children were given so much screen time. Unless their presence is meant to serve Henryâs character arc, the amount of focus they receive feels excessive. And I still donât understand the narrative purpose of these scenes.
In solid storytelling, supporting characters are supposed to function as contrast, echoes, or mirrors for the protagonistâin this case, the protagonistâs perspective is Henryâs. If they fail to do that, then it violates some very basic principles of narrative theory.
So weâd better discover the true function of these kids in the final episodeâotherwise, Iâll consider this the biggest misstep of the entire series. The same logic applies to Kali as a character.
From this point on, most of the remaining characters will likely appear as service characters for the unfolding main plot. Their personal highlight moments are already over.
And I donât believe El will truly face death. I donât think any writer would openly telegraph the death of their core character in advance.
So in the final episode, what weâre likely to see is this: the main group finally enters the ultimate main quest and steps onto the battlefield. This central storyline is anchored by Henryâs narrative thread. The first wave of character highlights will likely focus on El (maybe with Kali?). As Hollyâs storyline is wrapped up, weâll be led into a false climax.
And thenâthe spotlight shifts from El to Will.
Because we all know things are never resolved so easily. Willâs trauma will be fully uncovered and exposed, triggering the true final climax of the entire series.
Ohâand are we forgetting someone?
Yes. That damn guy whose emotions we never get to see clearly: Mike.
We are finally about to get Mikeâs POV.
These two narrativesâMike and Willâwill unfold simultaneously. And at the absolute peak of the final episode, weâll see their shared character highlight moment. This is the moment weâve been waiting for all seasonâthe most emotionally explosive payoff of all.
Will Byler still happen?
Yes. I still believe Byler will be endgameâand not quietly, but in an emotionally catastrophic, full-on eruption kind of way.
We will experience Mikeâs avalanche moment through his POV.
Hereâs where I want to bring up Catradora.
I havenât actually watched the show myself, but Iâve seen countless people on Twitter explain how this ship became canon. If, like me, you hadnât heard of them before but are curious, I highly recommend looking it up. This is a lesbian ship that the Stranger Things writers are known to love.
Throughout the entire series, they were never officially acknowledged as canonâright up until the final episode.
And then, in that last episode, when Adora is in danger and on the verge of disappearing, itâs Catra who reaches her. But Adora has already given up on surviving. She says:
âItâs too late. I failed.â
Catra screams in despair:
âNo! No! I will not let you go! Donât you get it? I love you! I always have!! So pleaseâjust this onceâstay!!!â
Itâs Catraâs love that saves Adora. And Adora, in turn, uses love as a shield to protect Catra. With tears streaming down her face, Adora looks at Catra in disbelief and asks:
âYou love me?â
Catra pulls her lover tightly into her arms, crying and smiling at the same time:
âYouâre such an idiot.â
Adora looks at her, softly says:
âI love you too.â
They gaze at each otherâand then Catra cups Adoraâs face and kisses her deeply.
Tell me that doesnât sound like the most romantic Byler endgame imaginable.
And yet, Iâm willing to bet that right now, very few Byler shippers actually believe something like this could really happen.
There are only five days left until the final episode. But Iâm saying this with absolute certainty: Bylerâs ending will parallel Catradora.
When Mike looks at Will, standing on the edge of death, all the love heâs hiddenâdeep, buried, and unspokenâwill explode like an avalanche, impossible to ignore any longer. Heâs about to lose the person he loves, and he screams:
âI do love you! I always do!â
This moment directly parallels the Season 4 pizza shop scene where he tells El âI love you.â
Oh God. Everything will flipâfrom the worst shit imaginable to pure electricity shooting straight through your bloodstream. Whether you believe it or not.
Guys. Believe me.
Thatâs exactly what the Duffers want.
Iâm willing to bet on it.
Everythingâeverythingâhas been part of their plan. Including the interviews weâve seen, and all the hints theyâve dropped. That word Mike has been unable to say for so longâthat âthat thingâ or âblank blankââhas become the biggest Chekhovâs gun of the entire series.
If this wasnât all set up for one final, massive climax, then everything Mike has gone throughâthis awful âbad boyfriendâ arcâwould make absolutely no sense.
Finally, I have one more bold ideaâthis time about how El might enter Willâs memory world.
What I find interesting is this: whenever El enters someone elseâs memories, the camera usually takes us through a lotof visual information. Weâre shown things. But when El finds Will, we donât actually see those things we would normally expect to see.
So can we speculate that El may have already seen some memoriesâand that what weâre seeing now is intentionally withheld? Or perhaps El will re-enter Willâs memory world later, and everything is being saved for the final episodeâs climax?
The van scene.
Willâs feels stupid at sunset.
The coming-out scene.
Will explicitly says Vecna showed him something terrifying, but we still havenât seen what that future was. Think about that for a secondâDerrickâs visions were shown to us in full. Yet for Will, weâre expected to accept that awkward and painful coming-out scene without ever seeing what Vecna actually showed him.
And now we know something else: all of these scenes only last a few minutes onscreen, but every single one of them took an unusually long time to film.
So hereâs the question: were these scenes shot with multiple cameras, deliberately designed to be re-presented later in a different form?
We already know what these scenes have in common: they are all Willâs trauma.
This leads me to my theory: in the final episode, El will enter Willâs memories and witness these traumasânot aloneâbut with Mike.
You might say, damn, Mike doesnât have superpowers.
But please pay attention to something extremely suspicious that happens in Episode 7.
At that point in the story, they suddenly introduce a brand-new concept weâve never seen before.
Think back to the moment when Kali and El are sitting back-to-back on the grass. El shares her vision with Kali. Kali is literally standing inside Elâs mind and asks:
âHave you ever done this before? Shared your mind like this?â
El shakes her head.
They even added visual effects for this scene.
Now ask yourself: if this concept wasnât going to matter later, why introduce it at all? Why write this dialogue? Why spend extra money on effects for something supposedly meaningless?
There is only one reason this concept exists: El will share her mind with Mike.
Together, they will experience Willâs trauma.
They will see the truth behind the painting lie.
They will see Willâs tears.
They will see the moment Mike didnât clock Willâs flirtingâand Willâs crushed, disappointed expression afterward.
And they will finally see the terrifying vision Vecna showed Will: everyoneâespecially Mikeâpulling away from him, fearing him, and not loving him.
In that moment, Mike will finally understand everything.
Heâll understand Will completely.
Heâll understand that Willâs feelings were never just a âcrushââthey were love.
I swear, if the final episode unfolds the way Iâm describing, Episode 7 will go from being the most disappointing episode to the greatest episode of the seasonâsecond only to the finale itself.
Of course, anything could happen. Maybe the Duffer Brothers really are just two assholes. If thatâs the case, I hope they somehow see this post early enough to rush back to set and reshoot everything to save their careers.
Just kidding. LMAO.
You and I both know thatâs not happening.
But after calming myself down and asking how Iâm still able to ship Byler after watching Vol. 2, I realized something important: destroying this ship would also destroy one of the most meaningful pieces of artistic creation and media analysis in recent years.
Weâve been so happy witnessing these two boysâ friendshipâand the love growing inside it.
If youâve read this far, youâve probably noticed that English isnât my first language. Still, I chose to spend a huge amount of time trying to express how I feel right now. I believe language is never a true barrier to emotional communication. I used AI and translation tools, so some phrasing may not be perfectâbut my belief remains firm:
Willâs story does not end here.
He will not become a sacrifice to queerbaiting.
One thing I genuinely respect about the Duffer Brothers is that they donât try to please everyone. They create what theywant to create. They didnât try to cater to Byler shippers with shallow, fan-service-y gay soap opera scenes. They know their foreshadowing and symbolism have been understood by someâand that many others wonât like Byler at all.
And honestly? Thatâs cool.
Iâm a creator too. I make things I love in my native language in my spare time, and I wouldnât change my creative intent just to match what an audience expects to see.
So letâs wait together and see whether the first day of the new year brings us something truly greatâor completely destroys the rest of our year.
Anyway,Happy New Year. đ
#If you like this, please share it so more people can see it.đđ