One of the most hauntingly beautiful properties I've ever scouted is this abandoned chapel, located just north of NYC...
It was like something out of a Lovecraftian horror movie: the cracked dome ceiling, the streaks of green mold, the pews in disarray, the broken tiles, even an old organ on the balcony...
Yet miraculously, the stained glass windows looked as though they'd just been installed that morning:
This was the last thing I was expecting to see when I reached out to tour the old abandoned building on Western Highway, which I kept driving past as I was scouting houses in the Tappan area.
Built in 1909, this was once the German Masonic Home of Tappan, a residence for older "Masons, their widows, and orphans" who needed a place to live. After closing in 1983, it then became a dorm for the nearby Dominican College.
In my research, I learned that students traded ghost stories about a pair of suicides that once occurred here. In 1933, John Ellich, 74, and Marie Kiefer, 64, both residents, had fallen in love despite strict rules against such behavior. A year later, they secretly eloped in NYC.
Unfortunately, their secret was discovered, and they were informed by the board of directors that they were to be separated, with one of them being moved to the Masonic Home of Utica.
On September 3rd, 1933, the superintendent found Ellich and Kiefer dead in Kiefer's room, lying side by side. Ellich still held an automatic pistol, and suicide notes were found on the dresser. There had been a massive storm that night, and the shot was mistaken for thunder.
You can see the full tour here, with newly added full-size pics that weren't in my original post: https://nickcarr.com/
Unfortunately, things don't appear to have improved much since I took these photos over a decade ago. Perhaps someday something will be done to save it; till then, it will live on in ghost stories.