When âThe Boy Who Wouldnât Grow Upâ Actually Does
By Mary Doucette, Marketing Intern
Peter Pan has been a classic figure in English literature and media for over a century, yet his story, much like himself, never grows old. At his inception, Scottish novelist J.M. Barrie (1860â1937) wrote the character as only seven days old in The Little White Bird (1902), a story about a newborn who could fly. In Barrieâs later play titled Peter Pan, or The Boy Who Wouldnât Grow Up (1904), and novel titled Peter Pan and Wendy (1911), Peterâs age is not stated, but he is described as still having his baby teeth.
Barrie was fascinated with the idea of being young forever after his older brother David died in an ice-skating accident the day before his 14th birthday in 1867. Therefore, Barrie was very interested in immortalizing youth, and sought to achieve this through the character of Peter Pan. Adaptations sought to preserve this idea, therefore Peter consistently epitomizes youth and curiosity. Interestingly enough, Harriet Whitney Frishmuthâs Peter Pan, (1936, bronze) at the New Britain Museum of American Art was commissioned to be placed near the grave of the artistâs deceased cousin. In an interview with the artist, she recalls, âA cousin of mine [Dorothy Frishmuth] whom I never met always wanted one of my pieces. After her death, her husband, Dr. Craig, came to the studio and asked me if I could make a Peter Pan to place between her grave and his in Laurel Hill Cemetery, Philadelphia, as she had an affinity for Peter Pan and hated being âgrown up.ââ With these aspects in which Peter Panâs character is so associated with death, it questions whether his eternal youth is a blessing or a curse.
Harriet Whitney Frishmuth, Peter Pan, 1936, Bronze, 19 x 14 x 26 in., Gift of Ruth Talcott, New Britain Museum of American Art
The story of Peter Pan consistently has strong ties to themes of nature; primarily through the way he is often dressed in leaves or, in later adaptations green, a symbol of nature. Additionally, his last name has ties to the mythological satyr Pan. In Greek mythology, Pan is represented as the god of the wild, shepherds, and flocks, nature of mountain wilds and rustic music, and companion of the nymphs. Another tie to nature: Peter is often depicted with a pan flute, claiming them as his signature instrument. This ties back to his characterâs association in Greek mythology: Pan fell in love with a beautiful wood nymph Syrinx who was transformed into reed plants by her sisters. Upon hearing the music created when the wind blew through the reeds, Pan chose seven reeds not knowing which one was his beloved, and crafted them into the pan flute he is typically depicted with. In Frishmuthâs sculpture of Peter Pan, there is a pan flute beside the figure, which suggests the artistâs knowledge of the Greek god Pan and the desire to tie him to Peter Panâs character, as has traditionally been done.
Poster for Peter Pan, 1924, Paramount Pictures
Peterâs childlike qualities were adapted in other media variations quickly after Barrieâs novel was published in 1911. For example, in 1924, a silent film was released featuring American actress Betty Bronson as Peterâmaybe femininity was considered more youthful and pure at that time. This characterization is further depicted in Disneyâs 1953 animation; our protagonist is young, sprightly, and mischievous with a great sense of adventure. In 2003, the live-action film Peter Pan featured a fourteen-year-old Jeremy Sumpter (b. 1989) as Peter Pan. Then, in 2015, Warner Bros. released Pan, another retelling of the classic tale, in which our protagonist, played by Levi Miller (b. 2002), is again a young teen. Though Peter Panâs character has aged since his inceptionâgrowing from a boy of seven days to a toddler to a young teenagerâhe continues to maintain energetic and youthful traits through personality and countenance.
However, the character doesnât always exactly remain young. Hook, a 1991 fantasy-adventure film adapting Barrieâs Peter and Wendy, starred Robin Williams (1951â2014) as an adult Peter who travels to Neverland to regain the memory of his youthâpresenting youth as a positive theme. However, this isnât the only instance in which viewers can see Peter Pan represented as an adult. On the television show Once Upon a Time (on ABC), the character was introduced in his late teens. Played by Robbie Kay (b. 1995), this character, though older than the original Peter Panâis obsessed with maintaining his youth. He has become evil in his attempts to stay young, drifting from the characterâs original representation of intentions. Anyway, this may be the only instance in which Peter Panâs never-ending youth has become a tarnished trait.
Robbie Kay, of ABCâs Once Upon a Time, at San Diego Comic Con, 2015
It is clear that Peter has gradually aged over the years and variety of adaptations, but has his youthful essence of character changed? When Barrie initially created the character, his age was an over-exaggeration of youth; he will never grow old. This trait continues to stick with Peter Pan no matter the adaptationâbut is eternal youth a good or a bad thing?
Barrieâs writing evoked a playful spirit and I see his original version of Peter Pan as a loving remembrance to his brotherâs death. I think Barrie idealized childhoodâthough his brother would never see adulthood, he was still able to experience youth.
People are likely to be reminded of Disneyâs 1953 film when faced with thoughts of Peter Pan, and I think they may prefer that character rendition to the brooding young adult depicted in Once Upon a Time, due to Disneyâs nostalgic qualities. That being said, it is important to note that the target audience for Disneyâs film is children. Children are more interested in the story at hand rather than fine plotline details. Whether itâs his childlike traits or appearance that captivate, the important question is: does his eternal youth pose as a warning or an opportunity? In Disneyâs version, and the 2003 live-action version, I believe that his youth is optimistic; his energetic and adventurous spirit reminding us to live life feeling free and uninhibited.
Harriet Whitney Frishmuth, detail of Peter Pan, 1936, Bronze, 19 x 14 x 26 in., Gift of Ruth Talcott, New Britain Museum of American Art
These themes of Peter Panâs eternal youth, specifically from earlier adaptations of the story, permeate throughout Frishmuthâs sculpture, particularly the figureâs eyes. Though his eyes are made of carefully sculpted bronze, they showcase endless amounts of wonder to meâthe artist asked her model to pose as if he were looking up at the night stars for the very first time. All I see here is endless possibility; his eyes reminding me of the look I must have had as a child, imagining thousands of worlds that lived beyond my own.
Peter Panâs youthful characteristics provide him the opportunity to âlive onâ in literature, film, television, and more. While many of us wish we could travel back in time, we are offered a fleeting opportunity through stories such as Peter Pan.











