Hey so @dudebros/mall ninjas who think that theyâre hot shit because they bought âkatanasâ and now theyâre unstoppable because katanas are the most sophisticated weapons of all time and whateverâŚas a white person who has dedicated a huge part of her time to studying Japanese swordsmanship, can you please Not
1. That katana you got in your local novelty store? Not even a katana. Seriously. It is literally impossible to sell actual katanas in, like, a US mall. Katanas, real ones, are forged over the course of several days and are prayed over by Shinto priests to this day, because theyâre made with the idea that they carry a part of a personâs soulâŚ.and you really think theyâre going to be on sale in your local mall?
(Itâs also worth noting that those swords sold in malls are generally wakizashi length and possibly also make. But itâs not like theyâre real wakizashi, either.)
2. I know you think you look cool dual wielding or wielding with a single hand, usually your right hand, in the middle of the hilt or up against the tsuba (guard) but uh. No. Katanas, or any swords modeled after them, such as bokken, iaito, or shinai, are meant to be wielded with two hands. YES, two sword styles exist!! But they are not common for a reason. You donât generally have the same flexibility or power that you get with two hands. Also, Iâve never seen anyone wield two full sized swords at once. Iâve only ever seen someone wield one full sized sword and a dagger sized weapon in the other hand.
(Also, the only person in my dojo who has an actual, legitimate, has-been-used-in-combat katana, is my sensei, which was gifted to her by her sensei. The rest of us use iaito or bokken, even the people who have been there 10+ years.)
3. Japanese swordsmanship, just like anything else, takes years of practice to get any good at. Iâm into my third year of kendo and iaido and Iâm nowhere near black belt ranked. In fact Iâm still considered very much a beginner and Iâm thankful for it. There is no precedence for picking up a sword and suddenly being able to wield it; you are not a genius or a prodigy just because you have a sword, and nor will you be able to win a fight. I say that because, surprise, the SECOND youâre in a fight, everything youâre still working on comes out in a negative way. Meaning youâre shit. No matter how far youâve progressed in your training, winning fights is a whole different ball game. I guarantee you that anything you think you can do will fly right out of your head the second someone else comes after you. You are not an exception to this rule just because you think you are.
4. JustâŚgod. Why would you claim a culture or sword style is the epitome of life or sophistication or whatever when you donât even bother to learn about or acquiesce to the actual cultural values or techniques? Iâm one of like, two non-Asian people in my dojo, and my sensei is strict. Being a white American, I was 100% not used to being immersed in a totally different cultural context to my own, and do you think I would have gotten literally anywhere if I hadnât shut the fuck up and just listened? And did what my sensei told me to do? And listened to those who were there before me? Being from a totally different cultural context meant that I had to (and STILL have to) work twice as hard to understand what to do and when to do it, and more importantly, what NOT to do and when NOT to do it. And if I didnât, I would just look like an ass. And if you do that, you will just look like an ass.
(Basicallyâbeing a white person in a primarily Asian space does not make you special. It just means you have to work harder to fit in.)
5. Holy shit. If I tried to go up against a HEMA practioner or something, I would get my ass kicked. It might be a little more even with, say, a kenjutsu or koryu practioner, but on the whole, the way Japanese swordsmanship is taught nowadays, itâs seriously not the most practical thing, and you really shouldnât pretend otherwise.
Basicallyâyouâre not going to be able to pull some kind of Last Samurai miracle here. If you want to learn modern or old-style Japanese swordsmanshipâkendo, iaido, kenjutsu, koryu, etc.âawesome! There are plenty of opportunities out there for learning and theyâre all great. But thatâs the point. You have to learn. You have to be open-minded and recognize that opening yourself up to learning a sword style means embracing the culture around it. And at least in my dojo, that means shutting the fuck up and listening to Sensei.
TL,DR; @dudebros/mall ninjas and anyone else who bought a cheap âkatanaâ in a mall and suddenly think theyâre The Last Samuraiâstop projecting your own ideas of what Japanese swordsmanship is onto Japanese swordsmanship.