I dont know if you're playing dumb or just hoping that I have a terrible memory, but either way every single thing you claimed I refuted and your only response was either to pivot to a different point (because you have no way to refute me) or start insulting me for….liking a cartoon? and daring to criticize your crush? But hey, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume the American education system has just taken its toll on your reading comprehension skills, so I'll make this easier for you.
You said that Emma never said his service was fine. I reiterated your point that she did the interviews with him (something that made you extremely angry for some reason?) but expanded on it by saying she explicitly defended his decision to join blackwater because, according to her, its hard for military members to find other kinds of jobs. So you're just wrong about her not saying it was fine, in fact she defended his decision.
Platner's team cancelling on Hasan does not change the fact that Hasan openly said he is "100% on team platner" and he said this even though he also said "I believe Platner has done some irredeemable shit while in service and I still support him". Whether or not Platner's team likes Hasan is irrelevant, my argument was that Hasan openly said he supports Platner despite believing that Platner has done irredeemable things in Iraq and Afghanistan
I said Hasan and Emma were some of the most prominent figures on the American left, and this is just objectively true? If they werent you wouldnt be so ass mad defending them, anyway. But regardless your hyperfixation on this small point kind of proves that you're grasping at straws. Even if they werent very important figures, that doesnt change the fact that they deserve to be criticized for their disgusting normalization of Platner being a murderer.
You claimed that Hasan did not support Platner. Quoting you,
"The most Hasan said was, "wow out of this multiple choice test with 3 answers, I'd choose this one", but since Hasan didn't act like deranged person ready to hang the man in the fucking public square allowing the onlookers to throw tomatoes while platner slowly died, he's a "supporter"??
We see what the man does when he's actually a fucking supporter."
I rebutted this by quoting his explicit statements of support for Platner, and saying that even tentative support for someone who openly claimed he killed Arabs and thinks it was an excellent experience, is disgusting. Your response to this was to to pivot to "umm where is your army??? something something steven universe something something cosplayer". Yeah, not much of an argument, just more floundering from someone who clearly has no clue what they are talking about
I literally dont care if you're here to simp for Hasan. Go do that then, instead of throwing an incoherent tantrum trying to defend his indefensible position. I made one post, that's not "clutter", you just have poor emotional regulation skills and cant handle someone saying something you disagree with. Thats why you had such a weirdly intense reaction to me criticizing Hasan, Emma, and the American left.
Speaking of assumptions, I never said Hasan was Hamas or too pro palestine? I do not think that at all, so you're just shadowboxing. I'm an Arab with Palestinian family members, I've been aware of Israel's atrocities since I was a child. also, I'm not an American?? If your movement is harmed by a so called "nobody" according to you posting something, it's a pretty piss poor movement. Which is extra pathetic considering Americans are some of the most privileged people in the world, and you guys still cant do shit except "pwease dont be mad at the guy who killed innocent Arabs, you dont understand he was indoctrinated as a poor child of checks notes 29 years old when he did his FOURTH tour of killing innocent people abroad"
I do find it funny that you refuse to engage with the pretty straight forward hypotheticals I gave about if Platner was an ICE agent that called the experience of violently deporting random people "excellent", then said on his campaign that he is trying to recruit more ICE agents and thinks they should be payed more? and what if he was in the KKK? Of course you wont engage, because you know the answer is that no you would in no way shape or form support him in that case, proving that you just dont view Arab lives as equal
For this last point you made, which is the worst of all, lets put our thinking caps on. Now Graham Platner is a guy that 1. Openly admitted to having killed people in his 4 tours and his time as a blackwater mercenary (that he joined after it was exposed that they committed war crimes btw), 2. Called that experience an excellent experience, 3. on his website, that you can literally visit right now, says that he wants to fix the military recruitment crisis by increasing the wages of people who join (your alleged anti military candidate, huh?) but that also 4. Pays lip service to the pro palestine cause. Now, would an even remotely reasonable person take point 4, basic lip service, over poitns 1, 2, and 3, which involve the literal action of murder, the gloating about that murder, and then the CURRENT desire to increase the number of people in the people-killing military?
