Expanding on my horror-sitcom role swap au where everything goes exactly as canon except the Emersons are the vampires. This definitely turned into a crack w angst situation which is my absolute favorite:
Just consider: vamp!Emerson family, fully prepared to lay low and be The Most Normal Family You Will Ever See when they first move to Santa Carla, being worried how people will feel about their weird schedules, what would happen if people start going missing, just all of them being so worried about having to lay low. And then they get to Santa Carla… and everyone is batshit.Somehow, even without laying low and pretending to be human, the Emersons are the most normal people in the goddamn town and they’re fucking VAMPIRES. Imagine when they all debrief back at the house after the first night on the boardwalk; Michael: “so I got my ear pierced, and the guy who gave me the earring started licking my blood?? And him and his friends sang a song about eating me?? And no one else seemed to notice what was happening??” Sam: “oh dope I think two vampire hunters want me to work with them? They gave me this comic about vampires being everywhere, and I was standing right in front of a mirror with no reflection so… they have to know, right?” Lucy: “well, I met a nice man who gave me the night shift without any questions being asked!”
Sam and the Frog brothers. God. This is so… oooh it hurts so good. Here you have vampire hunters trying to hunt vampires and they recruit… a vampire. Like so many opportunities for crack, but also it’s so goddamn sad. Sam, forever 14, just wants friends who get him. And he stumbled upon these two brothers, who are so funny and they get him in a way no one else has before and finally finally he has friends— but they want him dead. They want his caring, protective older brother dead. They want his sweet, passionate mother dead. If they knew who and what he really was, he can’t guarantee that they wouldn’t stake him. And if that isn’t an absolute allegory for growing up queer in a conservative area, idk what is. So you have all of that heartbreaking angst, but it’s juxtaposed with the antics of Alan and Edgar setting up vampire traps that Sam just so happens to keep tripping. The Frog brothers either being completely oblivious or willfully ignorant keep writing off excuses for why Sam is tripping the vampire traps and it just gets funnier and funnier, more outrageous.
Michael and the Boys. Fuck. This one is painful. Michael, forever almost 18. Who just wants to grow and live, seeing these four boys and one girl absolutely throwing their lives away. Being stupid and reckless and absolute idiots. Who don’t want to grow up at all, and Michael is jealous that they get the choice to throw their lives away— he can’t afford to do that, he has to protect Lucy and Sam, and he can never grow up. Michael would love getting to be a “normal reckless” teenager with them, but I think as the Boys’ stunts got worse, he’d be frustrated with them and so confused. He understands why it’s fun for him to race to the edge of a cliff in the middle of the night, to hang off a bridge while there’s an oncoming train; he doesn’t have to worry about getting hurt, he can’t die. But the Boys are painfully human, so why are they just throwing their lives away like that? Just the concept of unwillingly turned Michael who desperately wanted to grow up be normal and get away from his family, now forever unable to, still seeking out the Lost Boys and trying to seek comfort in their antics but not being able to bc he knows what the world is like. But again, you have absolute crack with this— Michael trying to keep the Boys alive while they do the stupidest fucking stunts ever. Can you imagine Michael’s face when David gives him the bottle, and he assumes it’s just wine bc what else would humans be drinking, and then he realizes it’s fucking blood??? Also the pure comedy of Michael “confessing” to them that he’s a vampire, an undead creature of the night, and they all just go “sick yes that’s what our brand should be now great idea Michael.” Michael just banging his head on a wall as his stupid humans drink questionably sourced blood because it makes them “look cool.” He thinks Star is the only sane one, but no she’s just as batshit /pos as they are, just more subtle about it.
Lucy :((( Lucy I’m so sorry to do this to you. I think the humor in Lucy’s situation comes from Max’s insistence that she’s the “perfect sweet gentle mother who is a positive influence” meanwhile Lucy is like… eating a pedophile in the corner (bc I do think the vamp!Emersons would try their damndest not to hurt people, mostly drinking from actual blood bags, but also Lucy and Michael would on occasion drink from an absolute asshole of a person). Vamp!Lucy might be a little more tuned into what an asshole Max is, but he’d still give her a job and take her out on dates and be “nice,” so I do think she’d fall for him somewhat.
I think that the Emersons have only been vampires for a few years, like somewhere in the 5-7 year range. I think for angst purposes, Lance (I think that’s the name we got via the book but correct me if I’m wrong) was turned, and then he’s an absolute asshole who, Max style, decided he wanted his entire family to be vampires too and he turned Lucy and the kids. This way, he could have control over them and make sure they stuck with him. Don’t worry tho, fucker gets staked! By who? Great question. Could be anyone— I could see Lucy, Michael, or Sam doing it, could’ve been a random hunter, could’ve been Grandpa who wanted to get his baby girl and her babies to safety, so he killed the asshole and then offered his house to them. I think the only really important bit here is that they’ve only been vampires for a few years; they’re still getting used to being dead, and the cognitive dissonance of “how old I am vs how old I should be” is very strong. If they’re 15-20 years post-turning, it’s a lot easier to seperate the ages, but I think 5-7 is in an absolute sweet spot. Sam should be 19, Michael should be in his mid-20s, but that’ll never happen. 5ish years also allowed for them to still be very connected with their humanity— it really hasn’t been that long since they were human, they still remember what it was like and they still desperately want it.
The big reveal. God I wish I could write bc this is the funniest scene in the world. Instead of big battle, you just have everyone showing up at the house for their respective Emerson, and it just all gets revealed. Total spider man pointing meme. Michael: “I flat out told you guys I was a vampire! I came to the cave with blood around my mouth one day!” David+Boys: “yeah dude we just thought you were like… really edgy and kinky ngl.” Sam: “I didn’t have a reflection the first time we met! I never touched any of the traps!” Alan+Edgar: “we just thought you were prissy about getting your hands dirty or something, we just thought people from Phoenix were weird like that!” Meanwhile Lucy is beating Max’s ass out back for being a piece of shit