contradictory Character design, milky way cookie, and how crtoa (kinda) screwed it up.
[this is long. sorry. also sorry for typnos and grammer and yadda yadda yadda]
Milky way cookie is a very interesting design because it baits you twice in a row. Ive seen some people complain about how her design is a bit lacking and not really what you'd imagine what this franchise would make a design after the concept of the entire damn milky way.
Id like to say thats the point, its supposed to be a bait and switch. Its funny. Moonlight Cookie being based on the moon is a legendary Cookie, powerful. You'd expect a design based on the milky way to be grand and big. Milky way is just kinda the opposite. Shes small and overall pretty plain design wise. She wears oversized clothes and refers to herself as special (and is even treated like such by Moonlight cookie herself), like shes supposed to be something bigger but she's just not.
With her design being a bait and switch on her concept and name, Its also a bait and switch from design to personality. She has these big glossy stary eyes that looks like shes about to cry and in her main crk sprite shes frowing, shes tiny, she has a cute voice, and shes marketable as hell. So by looking at her design you might assume shes just gonna be cute, maybe a little crybaby? A bit flat on the character side of things because shes just kinda meant to be cute and easy to sell?
Nope! BAIT AND SWITCH. Shes pretty damn capable. She has personality outside of being cute, and shes pretty okay under pressure. Honestly some facts and lines from her feel like shes activily poking fun of the overly cute thing, making fun of the whole "just a cute mascot" idea and giving this design its purpose.
Most of the time a design is supposed to tell you something about the character, thats a big part of it, but i find that when a character design seems to PURPOSEFULLY break expectations is when its really fun, because at the end of the day the design is doing its job, its still telling you something you just gotta be ridiculous enough to get the correlation between design and personality.
Anyway, this could be me defending my oshi, using the idea of purposefully contradictory designs as a crutch. If you think that then your gonna hate the crtoa version of her where her design just seems so much more boring, and this crutch is taken away for this design to crawl
Shes far less capable here and funnily enough despite being the first canon game to straight up elude to the fact she isnt considered a child its the game shes the most childish! Wow! amazing work guys. Im sure people will be normal about this information.
her design feels SO much more basic with this interpretation of her, and i feel like it actively goes against what we've seen of her before. Ive seen her straight up talk about how dangerous Dr.Evilglaze is and then snark him, why is she crying out for help to no one at the sight of nightmares? She was "Waaa..."ing too much here. Shes not helpless. Even when it seems like she kinda is shes not open about it to the point of yelling for someone to help her.
Im kinda glad Aurora wasnt here, if Aurora pulled the stuff they did in kindgom with this specific Milky Way Cookie it would be seen as much worse and many more people would've probably hated them.
She wasnt like this throughout the whole story, she still had the slight edge she had in crk and crob (Never played crwc so idk how she was there) but it was so much more toned down. This milky way wouldn't have snarked Evilglaze and probably would have had a heart attack during the nightmare storm stuff from crob
I swear, the writers for her didnt look at the other stories with her in it. They only really looked at her design and took it at face value, thats what it felt like. And with a contradictory design thats the ONE thing it shouldn't feel like.