The first time you saw him again after the breakup, it felt like nothing had ended at all.
You were standing outside the campus cafĂŠ, arms crossed against the February breeze, pretending you werenât waiting for anyone. Then he walked up beside you like he always used toâhands in his coat pockets, indigo hair slightly messy from the wind, eyes sharp and unreadable.
âYouâre late,â you said automatically.
Scaramouche scoffed. âYou came early.â
Same tone. Same rhythm. Same you-and-him.
It had been three months since you broke up. Three months since you both agreed it âwasnât working.â Three months since you told yourselves that loving each other wasnât enough when pride kept getting in the way.
And yet here he was, holding out your favorite drink.
âYou still take it with less sugar,â he muttered.
You stared at the cup. âYou remembered.â
âI donât forget things.â
He never did. Not birthdays. Not random details you mentioned once at 2 a.m. Not the way you liked your hand heldâfingers intertwined, not just palms touching.
Neither of you mentioned that he had no reason to buy it for you anymore.
After the breakup, nothing really changed.
He still walked you home at night. Still texted you when it rained: Bring an umbrella. Still sat next to you in class like the space beside you was reserved.
When your friends asked, âAre you guys back together?â you both answered at the same time.
But you still shared earphones. Still stole fries from each otherâs plates. Still argued over whose turn it was to carry the bag.
You just⌠never stopped acting like you were.
Valentineâs Day arrived quietly, like it didnât want to disturb whatever fragile illusion you were both living in.
The campus was suffocating with pink. Roses everywhere. Confessions happening behind buildings. Laughter echoing in hallways.
You told yourself it wouldnât matter.
Then you opened your locker and a small box fell into your hands.
Inside was your favorite brand of chocolates. The expensive kind you only bought during special occasions.
But there didnât need to be.
You found him on the rooftop during lunch, leaning against the railing, staring at the sky like he owned it.
âYouâre unbelievable,â you said, walking toward him.
He didnât look surprised. âWhat?â
âYou canât justââ You held up the box. ââdo this.â
He glanced at it. âItâs chocolate.â
âItâs Valentineâs chocolate.â
âYouâre not my boyfriend.â
His jaw tightened slightly. âIâm aware.â
The wind howled softly around you.
You hated how calm he looked. How unaffected. Like this wasnât tearing you apart.
âThen why?â you asked.
He finally turned to you fully. His eyes werenât calm. Not at all.
âYou think I can just switch it off?â he said quietly. âYou think because we said weâre done, I stopped caring?â
âThatâs not what Iââ
âYou still call me when you canât sleep,â he cut in. âYou still sit next to me. You still look at me likeââ
âLike what?â you demanded, your voice cracking.
The words hung heavy between you.
You stepped back slightly. âYouâre the one who said we should break up.â
âYouâre the one who said you were tired.â
âI was tired of fighting!â you shot back. âNot tired of you.â
Raw. Open. Painfully honest.
He ran a hand through his hair in frustration. âEvery time we argue, you shut down. Every time I get jealous, you pull away. I thought⌠maybe if we werenât together, weâd stop hurting each other.â
âDid it work?â you whispered.
His laugh was bitter. âDo I look like I moved on?â
He still watched you like you were the only thing in focus. Still stood slightly closer than necessary. Still adjusted his pace to match yours when you walked.
You were something worse.
Two people in love pretending they werenât.
âYou still get jealous,â you said softly. âI saw your face when that guy gave me flowers this morning.â
His eyes darkened. âYou didnât take them.â
âI didnât want them.â
You swallowed. âBecause they werenât from you.â
Something in his expression crackedâlike the pride heâd been holding onto finally gave up.
âYouâre cruel,â he muttered.
âYou keep staying,â he said. âYou keep choosing me in every way that matters except the one that counts.â
Your heart pounded painfully.
âThen choose me,â he said, voice low but shaking. âStop half-loving me. Stop pretending weâre nothing.â
âI never stopped loving you,â you admitted.
The confession felt like stepping off a cliff.
âThen why did you let me go?â he asked.
âBecause I thought you wanted to be free.â
He stepped closer. âI wanted us to stop hurting.â
His hand hovered near yours, hesitating. Like he wasnât sure he had the right anymore.
You grabbed his coat and pulled him down into a kiss.
It was months of pretending. Months of unsaid words. Months of jealousy and late-night calls and sitting too close.
His hands found your waist instantly, like muscle memory. Like theyâd been waiting.
When you pulled away, your breathing was uneven.
âYouâre an idiot,â you whispered.
âYouâre worse,â he replied, forehead resting against yours.
He looked at you with that stubborn, intense gaze that always made you feel seen and challenged at the same time.
âNow,â he said, âwe stop pretending weâre exes.â
You huffed a soft laugh. âWeâre going to fight again.â
âYouâre still going to get jealous.â
âIâm still going to overthink.â
âBecause,â he interrupted, brushing his thumb gently against your cheek, âIâd rather fight with you than live without you.â
Your chest ached in the best way.
Down below, the campus buzzed with Valentineâs confessions and new beginnings.
It was old. Familiar. Complicated.
He slipped his hand into yours like he never stopped.
This time, you didnât let go.