Lady Theories

Huge spoiler alert‼️

The point is that Alix is not protecting the timeline that turns out to be the best, but only protecting the timeline in which she exists as a bunnix.

The first appearance of bunnix is of her as an adult, that chapter being the reason she will be given the miraculous in the first place. From where we know that there is going to be a hawk moth until at least 10 years in the future. At this point we don't know how her power works, we only know that she enters a hole and appears in the time she desires. No reason to think the could know who hawk moth is.

The next appearance is in chat blanc. Instead of fixing the problem of Adrien discovering ladybug's identity because of the gift, he explicitly led her to fight chat blanc, traumatizing her that chat discovers her identity, losing trust in him and turning him more into a sidekick than her real partner (this causes too many problems later on). In this chapter we learn well how her miraculous works, being that she is practically omnipresent, being able to reveal hawk moth's identity to Marinette and not doing it because ✨Reasons✨.

Her next appearance is in Evolution. There, I don't have much to say; she gets paralyzed, and then Rabbit Noir and Ladybug solve the problem. Here, Mini Alix is officially designated as the one responsible for protecting the Rabbit Miraculous until they defeat the holder of the Butterfly Miraculous.

Then she briefly appears at the end, bringing reinforcements to Paris against the Miraculized. She could have gone to help Marinette, but whatever.

Her last appearance was in Miraculous London. Yes, she helps Ladybug prevent Lila from discovering her identity, but again, we see very clearly that if she wanted to, they could find out who took the Butterfly Miraculous and act on it, but again, they don't because ✨reasons✨. They also give Marinette an ambiguous answer about whether lying to the world to protect terrorists was right or not (obviously not! Kagami's mother is still at large and hasn't changed her objective, only her way to achieve it). Lastly, they make it clear that she really enjoys being Bunnix.

In conclusion, Alix could have ended the whole charade a long time ago, but she chooses not to. I don't know if she does it because she's afraid of disappearing or because she enjoys being Bunnix too much, but I don't think she's choosing the greater good.

I had this miraculous theory going on, and I don't really think it'll come true, but I find it interesting and wanted to have some opinions:

What if Lila is a time traveler? Hear Me Out

Let's say that she's from a few years into the future.

And she was a Ladybug fan, to the point that she knew everything about her battles and blah blah.

But knowing so much, she started spinning around what happened to the first Hawk Moth.

At first she didn't want to believe it, but the more she researched, in order to find something that denied it, the more sense it made for Gabriel to be a monarch.

And then she kept thinking, "Why would Ladybug lie about something like this? How does it benefit?"

I don't know what she would think there, but she grabs a horrible grudge on Ladybug for lying that way to protect a terrorist.

New Hawk Moth feels her grudge, and Akumatizes her.

Adult Lila realizes she's her young-self.

She doesn't tell her much, but they make a deal to send her into the past and have her take care of Ladybug back then.

Already in the past, she has to fit in and be as less recognizable as possible. She forms 2 or 3 families and it goes between schools, changing person and appearance, so thet no one can figure it out who is her young-self.

Looking for the opportunity to find the first Hawk Moth, who she knows is Gabriel, and considers Adrien, his son, the best way to get closer.

And she does, she goes to his school, she finds him, and by chance of fate, he has the book about the miraculous.

She makes a copy of the book and continues with the pantomime of dating the future boyfriend of that very famous designer where she comes from.

Then comes Ladybug and the humilliation. She doesn't care about Adrien, but this confirms that Ladybug wasn't a good person even at the first time. And is filled with anger.

Volpina thing happens.

Over time, he meets Gabriel Agreste and can continue with her plan.

Blah blah, Marinette discovers she's a liar, she needs more time to get information from Gabriel, so she has to disqualify her.

She becomes Gabriel's model, manipulates Chloe who is surely still horrible as an adult, so she enjoys making her suffer.

Marinette discovers her in front of the class, but she's already got what she needed from Gabriel. He has the proof that confirmed her theory and even why he did it.

Then remember, Chloe Mayor had to happen and she says, "Meh, why not?"

She passes the final battle, and while Marinette is thinking about how to lie to the world to protect terrorists, she enters the mansion and gets the butterfly's miraculous.

Who is Lila? I don't know, currently a five-year-old girl whose real name we don't know.

Or Manon, I don't care.

But, seeing the damage that miraculous ussers do, her desire is that they never existed.