Kuroshitsuji manga speculations

I WAS RIGHT. BAM.

As I was scrolling through the kuroshitsuji tag, I saw something @shinigami-mistress said here.

So the killer(s) might still be close by. There’s some theories they are in the house even. Could that be the reason that Grell’s stay back? We know that Knife Dude isn’t a simple human. Even Sebastian has said it would take 5 to 10 normal people to kill Agni.

What I’m about to say is a super stretch. But wouldn’t it be interesting if the real Ciel had a demon of his own?

Also, good thinking about the ring being the stolen candy.

Check out this post that @dorkshadows made. Very interesting!! I kind of imagine that both twins are unintentionally the villains. They are still so young and went through a ton. And let’s be real, kids and teenagers are emotional.

First of all: OH MY GOD. Second of all: I’ll be adding pictures later if I add them at all.

THIS CHAPTER.

When Agni digs through the fireplace, we fort get to see a scrap of picture that looks like a happy young master. We also get to remember how mad he was when those pictures were brought up. It seems that there are quite a lot of photos burned in the trash can. Suddenly, Agni is incredibly shocked while looking at a piece of a photo.

Meanwhile, Prince Soma is excitedly welcoming someone inside. He definitely knows this person, but we don’t get to see a face. We only get the mystery person saying, “Don’t touch me like we are pals.” Obviously it is someone that Prince Soma is close to and who he is fond of.

My assumption is that Agni saw a picture of both Ciel and the young master who is posing as Ciel. It would make sense that he would be startled to see two Ciels. Also, why else would he run to Prince Soma who seems to be content with the person who has arrived? Maybe the familiar voice made Agni nervous? Maybe because he just discovered that there is another Ciel while Prince Soma wouldn’t know this. Agni ran to Prince Soma before the gun appeared. It’s interesting…I could be totally wrong, but I’m going with the idea of the twin theory. I believe that it is the real Ciel that just showed up. It would explain why Prince Soma is excited to see someone who he sees as his friend. The only thing that weirds me out is as to why the real Ciel would want to shoot Prince Soma.

This picture is solely for me being suspicious, but it - for some reason - reminds me of the bed here (with the boy I believe to be the true Ciel). 

Also, Elizabeth was insanely upset, even when Sebastian pushed that the young master was worried. From what I could tell, Elizabeth would be the first to NOT trouble the young Lord. She didn’t even seem to waiver or feel too terribly bad about making him worried. She didn’t really appear to want to go back that much - especially since, you know, she sneaked out as soon as she was brought back. I’m wondering if that bed is truly Ciel’s and she has discovered the truth. It would explain why she so badly wants to stay and said that “She won’t return to that side”.

When i saw that scene, I thought that maybe Ciel’s eye was blocked so the reader wouldn’t be able to see that his eyepatch was taken off. Meaning, that Elizabeth saw that Ciel’s eye was unharmed. And if such a scene truly happened, its obvious that Elizabeth would open Ciel’s eyelids out of curiosity. She would’ve seen the Devil’s seal and freaked out. Realizing that Ciel was in such pain, she would’ve started crying. This would also explain why Elizabeth says “I’m sorry I wasn’t able to save you”.

Okay this one I’m not really 100% on. Or 60% really, but I’m gonna roll with it and put it out there. With a positive toward the twin theory followed by speculations.

This wouldn’t have been the first sleeping/dreaming Ciel scene. (I’m referring to the prior Undertaker creeping.) I found it interesting that during this scene, the young master’s eye was once again blacked out. However the outfit is the same that the young master had put in upon entering the starlight craze room. It truly could just be the young master passed out and Elizabeth is in on whatever the P4 are up to. It could even be that she somehow found out about Sebastian’s true form via the fortune teller or the mark on his eye. OR she could have discovered the truth about the real Ciel. Seems awfully simple way to go about that last option. Upon deeper inspection, I noticed the floor he was sleeping in is checkered, however the room the young master originally knocked out in appeared to be solid.

Okay. How the hell would the undertaker be able to get so close to the little lord is Sebastian was around? Something’s fishy...

I think it’s interesting that his left eye is covered. That way we can’t really be sure if that is the current Earl or the true Earl Ciel.

Tadah. Sebastian. Maybe he was having a nightmare of the Undertaker? But it was quite vivid and I don’t recall ever reading through a nightmare of his. (But I could be wrong.)

He says it himself that he wasn’t having a nightmare...so it was something else? If so, what?

He is looking more stressed than we’ve seen so far after the Undertaker’s words previously.

I’m thinking that the Undertaker is and has been taking care of the real Ciel Phantomhive. I don’t have a concrete reason as to why, but it just seems to be slowly falling into place. He mentions that the Earl is still with us, but I can’t imagine that he was referring the boy in the room at the time. It seems strange to just suddenly mention it when, if there was really only the one Ciel, that the Earl is around when clearly he has been here this whole time. And then this sudden scene? Maybe The Undertaker is planning for the real Ciel to make a comeback? Maybe Ciel was part of his experiments like how he messed with the people on the ship and the students in the school...but they were dead. I’m assuming Ciel is alive still and maybe The Undertaker is experimenting on people alive? Maybe he has a bigger purpose for him?

I’m rambling now, but point being, I 99% think that the real Ciel that was ‘sacrificed’ that day is alive (in one way or another) and the Undertaker has a play in why.

...I am just intrigued that the undertaker is all over Vincent. I’m not saying it has any meaning but it could.

“He must be.......” CIEL? NOPE. That’s why they can’t say it. Again conveniently “Phantomhive’s son”. This could also just be me pushing for the twin twist, but still. Come on.

This goes back to what I stated previously. I mentioned that for a boy of his age that he should be growing at least some. Even this demon knows this to be true. Thanks for the backup Sebastian.

SCREAMING. THIS IS THE CHAPTER I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR. GOOD DRAMA. I would love to know why The Undertaker would be crying over Vincent’s death. I need to know.

“The ‘Earl of Phantomhive’ is still with us, after all...” I am seriously doubting that he is referring to Vincent since he has just stated, “Even his bones burned to ashes.” 

These Shinigami’s also (like Sebastian) would have to know what this young master’s real name is.