Recently, a co-worker had the opportunity to see âUpâ and, although he thoroughly enjoyed it, he felt that some of the film's themes were rather mature for kids. I may or may not have laughed my rear off at his discomfort, and there may have been some mocking pointing at his dismay. As Iâm sure most know by now, Disney is infamous for incorporating adult-friendly fare into the kiddie fodder. However, I'll grant it to my coworker that some rather mature subjects were not played for laughs and might have been a bit much for a younger mind. That said, I decided to peruse a number of their animated films and name a few of these unquestionably heftier elements. Please, bear in mind these are typically themes not openly discussed with children until puberty, if not (sadly) later.
-Alcoholism: âCandy is dandy/ but liquor is quickerâ and turns you into a donkey so it seems. Disney warps a magical island of fun into a strangely unsettling lesson regarding hedonism and decadence. Most of Pinocchio's target audience were unlikely to understand the connection between brown bottles and little boys becoming literal jackasses.
-Conscience: This one may seem a little tame and random for the list; however, Iâd like to put forth this general
question: How old were you when you recognized you had a conscience and could make decisions for yourself? Um hm, um hm, now, would you really be watching Pinocchio at that age if not with a younger child? Riiiiiiight.
-Child exploitation: âS rampant. Just watch it again. âS everywhere! Pinocchio essentially spends an entire film running away from shady sorts looking to exploit a naĂŻve wooden child puppet thing for their own shady gains.
-Nudity: âNight on Bald Mountainâ may be terrifying to the small child, what with its imps, monsters, demons, and fairy lights; thus, the small naked ladies the Big Demon's holding are easy to miss on a first watch-through. The first naked ladies a kid might see may be nipple-less, on fire, and associated with the devil. Yes, yes, I know itâs an allegorical and artistic depiction; but, this piece is about mature themes and not merit.
-Bacchanal: Speaking of which-- Who can forget drunken little Bacchus and his half nude horse ladies? No one, thatâs who! One can only be grateful the MALE centaurs aren't anatomically correct; although, Disney did maintain a bit of their lustful nature as seen in the courtship sequence (and resurrected in one very nasty demise in Universal's âHarry Potterâ).
-That fish⌠lady⌠it⌠thing: Fish⌠should NEVER⌠be sexy. End oâ story.
-Exploitation: Yet again. Dumbo is owned by a circus, so this particular theme is rather part-n-parcel with the setting.
-Drunken elephantitis: And so Heffalumphs are born from the alcohol-induced dreams of an underage pachyderm!
-Jim Crow (literally): The crows of âDumboâ are an archetype heralding to the infamous âSong of the Southâ and quietly reiterating Disney's presence in a racially precarious time. While the debate still rages as to the positive or negative connotations of these characters, most of us were unlikely to understand this reference until we were well into high school.
-Sexual overtones: Inevitably, every kid asks that question, âMommy, where do babies come from?â And, for some reason, this seems to be a horrible plateau of communication for most parents; however, Bambi to the rescue! âYou see, honey, the boy bunny and the girl bunny just go into the log and out pop baby bunnies!â Basically, by the end of the movie, all our favorite young male animals (dare we say âstudsâ) have paired up... which might have been to alleviate any questions of sexuality or how close is too close in terms of âmale bondingâ âThank you, Flower.
-Death of a parent: Self-explanatory and certainly not the last time weâll see it on this list.
-Violent defrocking: While Iâm sure there are a number of reasons my parents never bought me this movie, I know that Iâve always hesitated to buy it myself for this particular scene. Everythingâs all happy go-lucky until Cinderella walks in in a dress lovingly handcrafted by her friends⌠only to have it torn from her frail, yet supple, body. Sounds like a nasty case of sorority hazing, and, if there are any doubts as to the validity of this claim, think of the last time you saw a garment torn off a body. Okay, now, was the material marketed for children? Right then.
-Sensuality: Thimble kisses aside, the maturity of a NUMBER of the female characters in âPanâ was a bit alarming. Disney made Peter the pimp of his own paradise where almost every gal wanted to be with him: If the mermaids werenât fighting over him, the Chieftainâs daughter was seducing him with her âdrum dance.â For a place where kids were never supposed to grow up, there was an awful lot of adult behavior from the girls.
-Arranged marriage: Finally! A rather tame mature theme that's more high-brow than gossip-inducing. The concept of betrothal and arranged marriage can be boiled down to a promise and is likely the easiest concept to convey on this list. Yet another reason âSleeping Beautyâ stands as a Disney classic, although formerly a slightly more obscure one.
-Sensuality: Included at the behest of a friend, it is claimed that the look the girl at the end of the film gives Mowgli is far too mature for her age. Hey, I found the âFantasiaâ fish too sexy; at least this oneâs human.
-Honorable mention: Man-eaters: Shere Khan and his cast of wily henchmen provide a comical and sometimes frightening introduction to the food-chain and the idea that man isn't always at the top.
-Rodent U. N.: Our beloved hero and heroine meet in what is, essentially, a United Nations of mice (a similar idea appears in Amblinâs âAmerican Taleâ-- also a favorite). As a child watching this, I understood Bernard was the handyman and Miss Bianca a lady, but I had NO clue why the other mice were dressed in funny costumes. Maybe I just wasnât as politically savvy a kid as I shouldâve been.
-Child exploitation: Obvious, sad, and Medusa is one of the creepiest villains from Disney simply for being so realistic.
-Loan Sharks: If your local mobster is unavailable, why not introduce your kid to their first shakedown the family-friendly way? Fagin, a loveable hobo (not bum, vagrant, and/or homeless beggar), finds himself in a little bit of money trouble with the wrong people; and, yes, we get to enjoy watching his property destroyed and dignity crushed. Ooh, the fun!
The Little Mermaid (1989)
-Infidelity: Although itâs not blatant, it is the first time that Disney suggests (in an animated film) the hero be attracted to anyone but the heroine. Notably, this is only possible at the behest of magicâUrsula just makes herself gorgeous for the perks. âWhat about Peter?â (just said pe-EE-ter⌠like Wendy in the film-- it gets to be habit after awhile) you may ask; however, while it's true he flirted around, the whole upset of Wendy being on the island in the first place was that he intended to keep her and only her (and Tink, but Tink was totally friend-zoned and knew it).
-Impalement: Self-explanatory and made all the worse for the slightly explicit nature of it. This is not Prince Philip leaping at a dragon with a sword. This is a man realizing he has a very pointy stick and pointedly pointing it at a very large woman with the intent of causing extreme harm.
Beauty and the Beast (1991)
-Hello, High School: The amusing antics of Lumiere and the duster aside, the girls of the inn are curvaceous blond triplets that swoon over the backstabbing (literally) bad guy. Might just be me, but I'm sensing some unresolved issues here.
-Asylum: The matter of sanity and there being a special place for people lacking it is a rather lofty concept for a seven-year-old. It also doesn't help that the definition of sanity and the merits that would land a person in such institutions are still evolving and has long rendered the term âinsane asylumâ obsolete. This plot point was definitely meant for a savvier audience.
-Seduction: Jasmine purposely cozies up to Jafar and gives him a look that still makes some guys slightly uncomfortable around the collar. And with that, every little girl in America learns that if youâre confronted by a bad guy, you should cuddle up to him until the hero comes swinging inâŚ. Any minute nowâŚ. Yep, any minute⌠uh, er⌠wait, stop, donât take that off! Wait! âNOâ MEANS NO!
-Honorable mention: Slavery: The concept of a sentient person owning another sentient person typically isn't broached outside of schooling; however, Disney introduces the fundamentals of both sides of the 19th century American slavery argument rather well through the genie. By no means am I suggesting this as a prelude to âRoots,â but I think it might make interesting teaching tool for the younger set.
There are a number of films not featured on this list, and, personally, I find âPocahontasâ and the onset of Pixar to be a great stopping pointâthe former because it's a minefield of adult material and the latter because the company has been rather seamless in their integration of older-people friendly jokes and fun. Things all said, I hope this lists inspires a second-look at some old favorites or a fun conversation or two about a topic we never outgrow: Good movies, GREAT movies grow with you!