Spawn and Ascended Astarion are the SAME PERSON
A lot of Spawn fans only seem to hate Ascended Astarion because ascension strips away the last bits of restraint he still had as a spawn.
He STOPS softening himself.
He lets the FULL EXTENT of his selfishness, cruelty, ambition, and arrogance show OPENLY.
And instead of admitting THAT’S what actually bothers them, many fall back on the morality argument as a coping mechanism.
Because honestly, I STRONGLY feel that if Ascended Astarion kept the softer, more emotionally vulnerable presentation of his Spawn self, while STILL sacrificing 7,006 souls to hell, a huge chunk of the fandom would suddenly stop caring about the morality of it.
Because the issue doesn't REALLLLY seem to be the ritual itself.
The issue is that ascension makes him impossible to keep romanticizing as secretly a good person.
But that’s the fault of the player for not paying attention because Astarion was never a good person.
Because if morality was truly the deciding factor, Spawn fans would not have been romancing him in the first place.
Wyll and Gale are RIGHT THERE.
Astarion, even at his softest, is still manipulative, selfish, violent, power-hungry, psychopathic, and just openly cruel at times.
Spawn just masks it better.
Ascended simply doesn’t bother anymore because, frankly, he no longer has to.
As Neil Newbon himself put it: Ascended is “mask off,” while Spawn still has his ON.
Spawn fans act like ascension magically turns him into a completely different person, like some kind of split-personality situation.
This isn’t Kingdom Hearts.
There’s no Roxas/Sora/Namine/Kairi identity split happening here.
Spawn and Ascended are the SAME man.
NOTHING Ascended Astarion says or does comes out of nowhere. Those traits were ALWAYS there.
Go pull up his Act 3 speech at the inn where he talks about the ritual, envies Cazador, and rants about power. Now pull up the speech he gives immediately after ascension.
The creepy cadence, the sinister tone, the hunger behind his words, and even the messed-up things he’s actually saying are identical—because it’s the SAME PERSON.
Ascension didn’t suddenly create a new Astarion.
It just stripped away the last of his restraint and let the mask fully drop.
Spawn literally says: “The problem with what Cazador did is that he did it to me.”
That is not the statement of a secretly noble man horrified by the evils of slavery. It’s the statement of someone angry he was the victim rather than the one holding the whip.
He also says: “I don’t mind being nice, of course, as long as I can bend people to my will.”
But apparently Spawn and Ascended are “completely different people.”
Even before ascension, he repeatedly talks about taking over Baldur’s Gate, controlling the Absolute, dominating others, and pursuing power at any cost. Once he ascends, he outright says he’ll create spawn slaves, block out the sun for them, and eventually conquer the world. In one ending, he literally follows through on this while smiling.
The game NEVER hides who he is.
Spawn Astarion encourages Dark Urge’s violence with visible excitement: “I say play it. Play it for all it’s worth. No one should be denied their true nature.”
Or: “You and I are alike. We both want to kill. It’s in our nature and I respect you for that.”
Once again the tone, body language, and even vocal delivery in that scene is identical in how he carries himself when he Ascends. Someone even put him in a modified version of his ascended epilogue outfit in this very cutscene, and my god does it bring it on home even more that this is the same guy that becomes an evil Lord.
The only difference is presentation.
Spawn wraps the ugliness in charm and vulnerability.
Ascended STOPS pretending.
That’s why the “he becomes a different person” argument falls apart.
His values didn’t change.
His priorities didn’t change.
His cruelty doesn’t suddenly appear out of nowhere.
The mask is just permanently off.
Even his treatment of companions follows this pattern.
Spawn can say deeply hurtful things yet later apologizes.
Ascended says the same kind of things but no longer feels obligated to soften them afterward.
The core personality remains the same; RESTRAINT is what changes.
And the game REPEATEDLY reinforces this.
If you become an illithid and compare Spawn's breakup to Ascended, both versions reject you for the same reason: He finds illithids revolting.
Ascended says it brutally.
Likewise, Ascended Astarion almost crying in front of the mirror after seeing himself for the first time in two centuries sounds EXACTLY like his spawn self. Him whining about the quality of the wine in the ascended epilogue? Spawn. Him sulking about not getting to throw the epilogue party? Again: Spawn. Because they are the SAME PERSON.
People take his tragic backstory and rewrite him into someone he never was, as if beneath the trauma there was secretly a Wyll waiting to emerge. But the game spends all three acts showing otherwise.
Astarion IS a tragic character.
Those things are NOT mutually exclusive.
Even outside the game itself, WORD OF GOD from Neil Newbon and Stephen Rooney have consistently referred to Astarion as an evil person. Even the game’s own materials repeatedly describe him as evil and corrupt.
His arc was never about becoming a morally good person.
Freedom from powerlessness.
Freedom to allow himself to trust and love someone after 200 years of degradation.
That doesn’t magically make him morally good.
In the patchless original game this is where we leave each path before the credits.
Spawn's ending, in the vanilla game, is framed tragically. He flees from the sun in terror and humiliation while everyone else more or less awkwardly moves on with their lives. This version of freedom still leaves him trapped by vampirism.
Ascended’s vanilla ending, meanwhile, is framed as a triumph. He stands joyfully in sunlight that he can finally enjoy permanently, speaks happily about his future, the wine he can finally taste, his palace, and about marathoning a love-making session with his spouse.
The patches soften Spawn’s outcome because players reacted badly to how bleak it felt, but the original framing still says a lot about the intended emotional contrast between the two routes.
And honestly, the patches don’t really hide that one of these paths was very CLEARLY framed like a failed quest. They instead feel more like a retroactive Band-Aid meant to soften the blow for fans who can’t accept that the guy who spent all three acts manipulative, selfish, power-hungry, and openly cruel IS, at his core, an evil jerk.
Also, before all the revisionism and backtracking Larian has become known for when it comes to their most popular character, “I Want to Live” was outright referred to as Astarion’s theme. And honestly, the lyrics practically spell out his story, and his romance with redeemed Durge.
It’s pretty obvious Astarion was treated as the main male lead of the narrative. He was written first, has the most content in the game, and his storyline is deeply intertwined with the EMOTIONAL core of the plot (breaking chains/taking back one's life). His ASCENSION feels like the culmination of his arc while redeemed Durge—who shares the same writing staff, was written as the other main lead, and arguably has the strongest narrative connection with him—comes across as HIS canon love interest.
Also, out of the three male leads it's telling that Astarion can ONLY marry you though ascension. Wyll can marry you. Gale can marry you. But Astarion only gets a marriage-coded eternal union through becoming the Vampire Ascendant, NOT by remaining a spawn.
The vampire bride ritual, the language of consorthood, the “forever” dynamic—it’s all there.
Spawn fans try to argue this somehow isn’t marriage-coded despite the turning night being BEAT-for-BEAT with the Forgotten Realms vampire bride lore. Even Astarion’s admittedly douchey lie about his bride “still being a spawn” comes directly from that lore. And the ascension route is also the ONLY one where he brings up a DOWRY and making Durge his CONSORT—two terms that have historically been tied to marriage for centuries. But apparently when it comes to his ascendence, those words suddenly stop meaning what they normally do.
Then there’s the “some heroes will eventually journey to kill Lord Astarion” argument.
Because if the prophecy about him and his spouse surviving until Faerûn itself crumbles to stardust is meant to be believed, then clearly, they don’t succeed.
So evidently no righteous band of heroes are going to permanently do anything to him or his wife in the long run.
At the end of the day, Astarion’s story was never “good man corrupted by power.”
It was “damaged, ambitious, morally rotten man finally gaining the freedom and power to take his life back after centuries of abuse.”
Spawn and Ascended are NOT opposites.
Ascended Astarion is simply Spawn Astarion with nothing left to fear.
2087
dailybridgerton
gracieabrams
areudirty
ellievsbear
snowghoul
titsay
