I'm feeling in a sort of Eret-son-of-Eret mood today. Any delightful headcanons about Mr "Ooh, I don't like Dragons, oh hang on, actually, I totally want to be besties with Stormfly"?
I think Eret, prior to the whirlwind transformation in HtTYD2, adopted his big-talk attitude mostly to make himself believe his own boasts. He is, deep down, a pretty chill guy. It is hard to make him actually, really dedicated to something, because despite his commanding voice and posture, he is a follower, not a leader. He adapts himself to whatever trend will benefit him most. He can do a lot of difficult things (fight, trap dragons, etc.) so he hires out his talents to powerful men (like Drago) who can pay him big and keep his livelihood afloat. In order to keep his own well being at the forefront of his actions, he talks big and wholeheartedly about his alliances and beliefs, even if he doesnât actually believe them, because he wants himself to believe them, because he either wants to or needs to reap in the benefits. He eats his own lies as a matter of habit, and doesnât think twice about it.
Now I know they never said this, but from the moment I saw his design, I thought that Eret was from the Northern Wanderer tribe from the books. He and his men all have that feel to their designs. And in the books at least, they are a very persecuted tribe, hunted as slaves and the like. So maybe Eret hasnât got much family thanks to the vikings, and he basically adopted a âif you canât beat âem, join âemâ mentality by making himself a mercenary. His moral center has taken a beating from the decisions heâs made, but deep down heâs not really, really dedicated in any particular direction of life except what seems best for him. And that is a very delicate facade to keep up, so thatâs why he became so eager to change in HtTYD2.
That being said, this isnât just about Drago, it is a two way road. I think Eret had a lot of trouble adapting to his new life post-HtTYD2. Because Berk isnât hiring him for trapping or fighting or even fishing, they just want to show him how amazing dragons are, they want to help him out. Heâs never been put in that position before, so now he is truly getting to wrestle with his actual alliances and beliefs, rather than changing them depending on the mood of whether heâll live or die. He finds it hard to lie to Hiccup because the young chief is so earnest, and canât seem to do anything to impress Astridâs high standards of dragon-training. He canât do anything but be grateful to Stormfly, and respectful toward Skullcrusher. He just does not have a choice in what he chooses to present himself. For the first time in a very, very long time, his moral center is being challenged by the fact that he doesnât have any reason to be dishonest on Berk, and thatâs confusing. But, in the long run, it is, of course, better.
I think the phrase: "Thanks⌠I think." pretty much sums up Eretâs first several months on Berk. Confused, unsure, a bit distrusting, and baffled by the possibility of someone caring who isnât paying him money.