You guys might disagree with me, but I fully believe Dreamâs apology was genuine.
I mean, for starters, the fact that he apologized in the first place is proof he was actually sorry. Because the truth is, this whole situation wouldnât have had a very big impact on his career even if he dug his heels in and insisted he was in the right. All his friends would have kept on supporting him, maybe even would have told him he was right. He wouldnât have lost many subs over the whole situation. Overall Dream would have been mostly fine if he let the whole thing just blow over. But he didnât. Dream came out and apologized for what he did even when his reputation wouldnât have suffered to massively otherwise. In fact, by apologizing on twitch he was probably bringing more attention to the situation than it would have gotten if it had just stayed on twitter in the first place. I mean, even throughout the stream, the chat was spammed with nothing but support. People saying Dream was right or that twitter is just toxic, etc, etc. So yeah, the fact that Dream felt the need to apologize for his actions even when he wasnât technically required to? It shows that he does know he was in the wrong.
Not only that, but he didnât allow donoâs. Which is honestly more than I can say for a lot of Youtubers during their own apology videos. You see Youtubers and streamers constantly monetizing apologies. Dream could have monetized the whole stream, got a little out of it. But he didnât, and that reads as very respectful to me.
Starting from the beginning of his explanation, I see a lot of people who âarenât buyingâ the idea that the war cry was a Spongebob reference. WhichâŚI donât really understand. I mean, to be honest, thereâs no reason not to think the original incident was just a mistake and nothing more. He was referencing a scene from a dumb kids cartoon. The show was wrong for including the âwar cryâ, Dream was not originally wrong for not realizing. Just the other day a friend of mine did the same thing, as a reference to Spongebob. So I honestly donât get where the idea comes from that Dreamâs story isnât believable? Especially since, if he knew the questionable story behind the whole thing, why would he have done the âwar cryâ on stream?
Secondly, a lot of people arenât entirely happy that Dream cited death threats and doxxing as the cause of his angry tweets. I understand how it could be seen as shifting blame. But it wasnât. Honestly, if Dream hadnât explained that he was reacting to threatening messages and not polite explanations when he made that tweet, people would be demanding to know why he reacted so violently to polite criticism. It was important to know what exactly triggered that reaction from him. And he didnât waste much time on that detail. Sure, Dream mentioned it, but the brief mentions of the awful messages he was getting were sandwitched by apologies for saying something offensive and for blowing up over twitter. Legitimate, genuine apologies where he admitted he was wrong and that he shouldnât have done what he did. Every time Dream pushed any blame onto hate messages, he pulled it right back onto himself not long after. It wasnât an excuse for his actions, it was an explanation for his actions. Dream wasnât trying to absolve himself of any wrongdoing, he never tried to insinuate that it wasnât really his fault. Telling us why he did something is fine during an apology as long as it doesnât turn into telling us that he was right for what he did. Which it didnât.
Then thereâs the question of weather it takes away from his apology that he moved on to a different subject so quick and cracked some jokes here and there. Now, I donât actually think this was in good taste. I feel like he should have ended the stream after the apology and made a new one if he wanted to do something more lighthearted after. However I donât think his apology is any less genuine for it. Dream seems like the kind of person who doesnât like to be vulnerable. He keeps most of his personal information private, rarely discusses anything serious, and didnât even show his own best friend what he looks like until four years into their friendship. Dream clearly doesnât like to put everything out there. So of course, discussing such a serious issue? It must have beenâŚdifficult to say the least. And some people cope with being uncomfortable with comedy. Itâs not exactly a good or healthy coping mechanism, especially when youâre offering somebody an apology. Because it can make you seem less genuine. But having that negative coping mechanism doesnât actually mean you didnât care or werenât genuine, it just means youâre uncomfortable being open and vulnerable. So yes, maybe he should have put more focus onto the apology. Maybe he should have made his feelings clearer. But he managed to push aside his discomfort for long enough to get the point across and I can respect that much. Because despite the more lighthearted behavior that popped up every once in a while, he was obviously guilty and kinda nervous, and that made it so obvious that he wasnât lying when he said he was sorry.
Then thereâs the content of his actual apology itself. First off he specified what he did and why he reacted so rudely on twitter, which I already talked about earlier. âI lash out, and thatâs what I probably shouldnât doâ he continues. âMy first reaction is to attack back, and then I step back and realize iâm being harsh. Thatâs something iâve always done. So iâm sorry regarding that. I did not mean to offend anybodyâ. And honestly, thatâs something that I understand. I think itâs natural for a lot of people to go on the offensive when theyâre faced with any level of hate. Itâs a completely understandable reaction. However, that doesnât make it an okay reaction. And I think, had Dream refused to recognize that he was in the wrong for lashing out, his apology would be harder for me to side with him on. However he didnât do that. Despite the reasons Dream gave for why he did and said what he did and said, he still admitted, plain and simple, that he shouldnât have done it. That he was the one who was wrong. That heâs sorry. And thatâs how you know he wasnât using his explanation as an excuse. Because he was still willing to admit that ultimately it was him who was wrong. âObviously I donât mean that towards people who are genuinely just trying to help people that are oppressed, or help people that are actually upset- that are mad about something that iâve said or done- so iâm genuinely sorry for saying that, I was being an asshole, and I do that sometimes, and I have to learn from that and try not to.â Multiple times, Dream acknowledges why he said what he did. That it was his initial defensive reaction when people were threatening to come to his house (shortly after he was doxxed), and his initial defensive reaction was wrong. He knows it was wrong and he wants to learn to stop. Maybe he could have worded his apology better, maybe he could have scripted it beforehand, maybe he could have dragged it out and pulled out the fake tears. Dream probably could have done a lot of things to make the apology more sympathetic or more likely to be accepted. But overall, even with the stammering and occasional poor wording he used, you can tell that Dream is trying his best and is legitimately apologetic. âi dont want people to be afraid of calling me out for being an ass. iâm sure i made the person who made that original thread feel invalidated by saying the things i said, but i wasnât trying to, i was just getting harassed by people that werenât that person. that person had completely good intentions by making the original thread about native americans and they had really good intentions to make sure that their culture wasnât being appropriated and that their culture doesnât disappear, and that is 100% good. and theyre a good person for doing that. i wasnât saying âf offâ to them.i want my content to be a safe space. i hope i can learn and reflect. im not perfect, i can always learn and be a better person, and i will try.â he says later on.
I do get the feeling that Dream isnât completely educated on the topic at hand. Obviously. Heâs from a very conservative state where he wonât have been taught all these things (I sure wasnât where I live). He doesnât completely know what heâs doing when it comes to how to handle minorities, but I really, truly think heâs working hard to figure it out. Heâs trying his best and I canât help being a little proud of him for that because I remember when I was in the same position he was, with some kinda gross views on things and not much clue how to change that. But I tried, and I like to think I got a lot better, and I know he can too. It seems like he wants to.
No Native Americans have any obligation to accept his apology. What he did was offensive and ignorant and if you were hurt by his actions then thereâs no reason you should have to just get over it. I will never try to force anyone to accept an apology that they donât want to accept. And itâs not my place to accept that apology for you. However, I feel like I can safely say, as someone whoâs done similarly dumb things to him years ago and who grew up in an environment similar to the one in the state he lives, that I wholeheartedly believe he was being genuine, for whatever thatâs worth.